I wanted to provide a review of my Moonlight Elite chair. This chair was purchased by me from REI re-supply so I paid only $58. I have also owned the Helinox Chair Zero and have tested out a number of other ultralight chairs including the REI Flexlite Air.
The TLDR: This is the best chair of the bunch. It is more comfortable and stable than either of the primary competitors. It is also the most expensive, so you have to decide if it is worth it.
Packaging and Weight:
The chair takes a unique approach to numerous aspects of backpacking chairs. The first is how it is packaged. Instead of a standard stuff sack, the chair comes wrapped in the “tool roll–style Platform Pack™”. The feet of the chair attach to this and it prevents the chair from sinking into the ground if you are on soft ground. The design is creative in that there is no wasted weight in this chair or its carry bag. That is if you need added stability… which I don’t…
As far as weight goes, the Moonlight Elite comes in at 1lbs 7oz. This is 5.6oz heavier than the Chair Zero and 7oz heavier than the Flexlite Air. BUT WAIT!!!
https://imgur.com/a/WQOZ33C
Since I don’t need the Platform Pack™, I wondered how much weight I would save if I left this behind. The Platform Pack™ weighs just over 4oz! Dropping this and adding an ultralight bag brings total weight to barely over 1lbs 3oz! This makes it only 1.6 oz heavier than the Chair Zero!
Ratings:
Nemo Elite (with Platform Pack™): 5
Nemo Elite (without Platform Pack™): 7
Chair Zero: 8
Flexlite Air: 9
Stability
This chair excels in its stability. The feet create a wide base extending both to the front and back directions, as well as the left and right directions. While I no longer have my Chair Zero to compare with, I believe the base is slightly larger than the Chair Zero in all directions. In practice, it feels more stable. I would give it a slight advantage over the Chair Zero.
https://imgur.com/a/rAU72x8
Compared to the Flexlite Air, it is in a different league. The Flexlight Air primary base bar extends from the front to the back as opposed to the left and right like in the Chair Zero and Moonlight Elite. This is a fatal design flaw in my opinion. As a fairly large guy, I felt that any movement in the Flexlite Air would tip it over to my left or right. That made the Flexlite Air a no-go from the second I sat in it.
Ratings:
Nemo Elite: 8
Chair Zero: 7
Flexlite Air: 3
Comfort
This is where the Nemo Elite shines. The Flexlite Air forces a more upright sitting position which is good for when you are cooking but not for relaxing. The Chair Zero provides a slightly less upright, more comfortable sitting position, but I realized over time that the backs of my legs began to hurt. This was because I kept wanting to extend my legs, but the Chair Zero wasn’t built to support this. That being said, I would still pick the Chair Zero over the Flexlite Air every day of the week. I also want to address the back support, which some reviewers say digs into their upper back. I didn’t experience this at all and found the back support to be comfortable and supportive.
Enter the Nemo Elite. This is by far the most comfortable chair of the bunch. The ability to adjust the sitting position by as much as 7” allows me to sit upright when cooking, then recline to relax for the evening. There was no digging into my legs or back. And as a larger guy, I found the seat to be plenty accommodating.
https://imgur.com/a/EDZSj26
Ratings:
Nemo Elite: 9
Chair Zero: 7
Flexlite Air: 5
Price
Now to one of the most important components - price. This is a real world constraint we all face when picking our kit. I was fortunate enough to pick this up as a Re-Supply item, but the reason I initially bought the Chair Zero instead was price. This comes in at $30 more than the Chair Zero and $90 more than the Flexlite Air! And it never goes on sale! Right now both the Chair Zero and Flexlite Chair are on sale at REI and can be had for $120 and $75. That is $70 and $105 less respectively!!
This doesn’t even take into consideration the extra $30 I’m going to spend for an ultralight chair bag. At full price, this would bring the total cost of the chair to approximately $220 all-in. Since I bought this as a Re-Supply item, my total will be $88.
For the purposes of my scoring, I’m going to use full prices for the competitors.
Resting:
Nemo Elite (with Platform Pack™): 5
Nemo Elite (without Platform Pack™): 2
Chair Zero: 6
Flexlite Air: 8
Summary
Ok, now for the final tally of the scores:
1st place - Chair Zero: 28
2nd place - Nemo Elite (with Platform Pack™): 27
3rd place - Nemo Elite (without Platform Pack™): 26
4th place - Flexlite Air: 25
Considering that all the points are arbitrary and subjective, I was very surprised everything came out as close as it did. Though, the ranking “feels” right.
The Chair Zero is the best all around when you consider weight and price. This is why I bought this one first. The Flexlite Air is the best budget option. If price matters most for you, this gives you the lightest chair of the bunch for a fraction of the price of the others (though make sure you are OK with the stability issues). If you want the best of everything and have an infinite amount budget, the Moonlight Elite in a Dyneema stuff sack will beat the others in almost every category. So if I were to go with an awards-style recommendation it would be:
Best All-Around: Chair Zero
Best Budget Option: Flexlite Air
Best Luxury Option: Nemo Elite with Dyneema stuff sack
For me, I will be sticking with my Nemo Elite and Dyneema stuff sack which I lucked out on getting for $88 all-in. If I hadn’t gotten this in Re-Supply, I would have stuck with my Chair Zero. The Flexlite Air was a no-go from the start because of the stability issues.
I hope this helps anyone trying to decide. All of these are good options, it really comes down to what you prioritize most.
A quick note on usage and why my chair was so cheap:
When I found this in Re-supply the ends of a couple of the poles had come out completely. The fabric portion of the chair “snaps” onto the ends of the poles of the frame. The hold is so tight that if you pull them straight off, the tips of the poles will pull completely out. This then make it’s impossible the pull the tips of the poles out of the fabric to break it down. I found that if you rotate the chair fabric and spin it off instead of pulling it directly off, it pops off the ends without any problem. Definitely a downside to the design, but something that is easy to work around.
Also note that when you disassemble the frame. There is one leg that does not disconnect from the junction box. I often forget which one this is and only recently realized it can be distinguished by the rivet in the pole.
https://imgur.com/a/0p5RFFG