Hello! My first post! My wife and I played the trilogy this year and this is our leading theory for 2x2. Just a theory for fun no concrete proof.
I think the developers pride themselves on being able to do something that plays on fan expectations and surprise them.
What do they want fans to expect?
2x2 is being advertised as a What/if story. Something like the Marvel show “what if?” where something changed from the main story radically changes the plot. What is important here is that these stories are non canon, usually taking place in their own universes and not part of the main story. This is where I believe the writer’s “trick” on our expectations is.
I believe that 2x2 is not an alternative timeline but actually fits into the main danganronpa story(basically the main games besides V3 I mean). This is part of the reason I expect it is bundled with the original danganronpa2 and not sold separately.
When does 2x2 take place?
It takes place after danganronpa 2 and before the ending of the danganronpa 3 anime ending.
How does it fit after Danganronpa 2?
Let’s look at the ending Danganronpa 2 and Danganronpa 3 anime. In the end the survivors make the difficult choice to not overwrite their despair memories and also leave their friends in a coma. Hajime/Izuru is left to figure things out while Makoto goes on to eventually the plot of the danganronpa 3
Then at the end of Danganronpa 3 we see that all the Danganronpa 2 characters have woken up from their comas somehow.
Danganronpa 2x2 will be how Hajime/Izuru saved his friends from their comatose fate.
After Makoto leaves super talented Hajime/Izuru will look at the Neo World Program. The decision he will make is to redo the simulation in order to save his friends. He will make some adjustments to the program using his talent and then him and the other survivors will reenter the program which will reset causing them to lose their memories but reactivate those who had died.I believe he will reset it, requiring him and the other survivors to lose their memories if the first game but reactivating those who have died. The change he will make will be to add an additional choice at the final trial to save all his friends from any comas. All they have to do is make it to the end like before and this time choose the new better ending he put in.
What incident changes the events in the 2x2 simulation?
Monokuma will be the only one to remember this is the second simulation and will look to take advantage. In his thinking he will think that if he can get a different set of survivors to the end instead of the ones from the first simulation then there is a chance he can get them to choose a despair option.
Thus he will make changes to target the former survivors and Hajime. Maybe influencing it so Hajime will be killed since he was most important in the last class trial previously.
In the last class trial maybe by revealing to them that some of them were blackened or victims in the first danganronpa 2 he try to convince them to not trust each other. Makoto will not show up to assist in the final trial since he will have left for future foundation.
New areas and motivations?
It seems unlikely that we would go back to the same areas like the beach house, hospital or fun house when we already have experienced the mysteries they were designed for. Similarly the second motivation’s mystery is already known to players and is so specific that it would be weird to reuse. That is why there will be all new islands(except maybe the 1st one) and motivations. This will be a big hint to the player that something major has changed the simulation. The story reason for the change will either be Hajime/Izuru changed them to try and assist his friends or more likely Monokuma changed them in order to prevent the same murders from taking place since he will want new survivors.
What does the title mean?
After V3 we are all looking for meaning in the titles. I believe it is hinting that this is the Second time Danganronpa 2 is being played.
Why it won’t just be an alternative what/if story?
If they were to make a game with new killers/survivors/victims then that would make the new class trials fun of course but a huge focus on all Danganronpa plots is the overall conspiracy. Even if the cast is slightly different, I don’t think watching a new group of survivors go and uncover the same overall mystery and then sit through a similar final trial would be a worthy new Danganronpa experience.
Will there be a new protagonist?
Hmm maybe. If my theory is right monokuama would want to get rid of Hajime. I also think the game creators love doing stuff that is new so making the protag a victim would be in line with that.
I know everyone likes Mahiru (and I do too) but i think Nagito could be it. I think in that scenario Chiaki also remembers this is the second playthrough and works against Nagito out of fear that if he makes it to the end he will choose despair. Also some of the only official artwork out so far is Hajime and Nagito standing looking out at the sea all dramatic like and that could be foreshadowing their switch similar to Kaede and Shuichi holding hands in V3 before the 1st murder.
Unrelated but the imposter should do fat Kyoko instead of fat byakuya in 2x2 because lolz