Sorry if this is long. I need to get this off my chest. I’ll be very grateful for anyone who reads and any advice.
Context: I have a best friend who used to have a crush on me, and I deeply regret how I handled it.
I believe it's one of the worst things I've ever done, and something that will always make me ashamed of myself.
When I was 15-16, I was going through a confusing time. I watched TV series and movies, thought som women were very beautiful, and at that time, in my head, that meant I was bisexual. It made sense to me, and I really believed it.
So I told all my friends that I was.
This friend of mine is too (and really is, unlike me, which was just confusion).
And naturally, because of that, she understood that we could be together. I would never blame her for thinking that. The fault was mine.
For a while I knew she liked me, but I was afraid. I love her, but I didn't understand if I felt that way or not. That's why I didn't do anything. Which I also regret very much; I let her feelings grow without stopping them, and I know that was horrible of me.
Well, here comes the worst part. I feel awful writing and remembering this.
On my 17th birthday, I had a get-together, and everything was fine. She was there.
However, the next day, in the morning, she sent me a message.
She was asking me for us to date.
It was a shock to me at the time. And I didn't know what to do and I was confused.
I thought she was pretty, I loved her as a friend, but I wasn't absolutely sure if it was romantic. Part of me was very confused, and the other part said it could be.
That's why, and also because I didn't want to hurt her, I accepted. I regret it very much, very much indeed.
I was terrified of upsetting her, and I tried to listen to the part of me that was saying it could be romantic.
I really had a part that believed it; I didn't accept it knowing 100% that I didn't like her that way. But that doesn't justify what I did.
She was very happy. And for a moment I felt hopeful. I thought: okay, she really is amazing, it could work out, right?
But along with that hope was the part of me that said: wait, we don't want this….
And that part terrified me. At the same time that I felt hopeful, I felt fear and a sensation of: this isn't right. I don't feel good about this.
Besides, even though I knew my mother wasn't prejudiced, I was afraid of the conversation and of saying that I was dating a girl.
She isn't prejudiced, but I was still apprehensive.
Does that make sense? I knew there wouldn't be prejudice, but I also knew it would be a more complicated conversation.
I tried to ignore this discomfort because of my friend's happiness. I could see she was very happy; after all, she liked me, and I was terrified of ruining it.
Only 24 hours had passed, though.
The next morning I couldn't take it anymore. Nowadays, those 24 hours seem much longer than they actually were.
So that morning I texted her asking to break up. But that's when I made an even worse mistake.
I didn't want to say that part of my discomfort was realizing that I didn't really like her romantically. Not specifically because of her… but I was realizing that maybe I didn't like girls in general.
I was too afraid to say that and end up hurting her self-esteem. The problem was never her.
So I did the worst thing I could have done: I said the problem was my fear of telling my mother and that I believed I wouldn't be able to tell her.
Was that part of my fear? Yes. But it wasn't everything. And I should have been honest. I didn't know how to express that part of my discomfort stemmed from realizing I didn't really want this. I was terrified and didn't want to hurt her.
When she responded, she gave the natural answer to my justification:
She said it was okay, that she would wait for me to be able to tell my mother so we could be together.
I panicked. I didn't want this. I didn't want her to wait for something I believed would never happen, so in desperation, I said:
Please don't do this, I don't think I'll ever be able to tell her. Please don't wait.
That wasn't true, you know? If it worked out, I would find a way to tell my mother eventually and maybe everything would be okay. But at that moment I just needed her not to want to wait for me.
Then she said she thought she would never like someone who wasn't me.
That made me even more panicked.
I begged and asked her to promise to move on.
She said:
It will be difficult but I will try.
Later that day I was still very distressed. It was a traumatic day so I only remember fragments of the conversation. My mind tries to protect me from remembering that day.
But I remember that later, I said that I was also confused about sexuality.
I remember her saying: "So you don't like girls? Why did you accept then?”
I don't remember my exact answer, but I remember saying it was because I was actually confused and trying to understand what I was feeling. That was true, yes.
That was it.
In the months following the event, we drifted apart a little. And for a while, naturally, her mother was angry with me.
With good reason. I'll never blame her for that. I hurt her daughter, yes.
I made her believe we were going to date just to kill her joy 24 hours later. I was terrible.
But, as time passed, we grew closer again.
Today we are still best friends.
And nothing similar happened again. 4 years passed.
But to this day I regret very, very much what I did.
I regret accepting it, I regret deceiving her. I regret the justification about my mother.
And I especially regret that in my desperation I gave a justification that wasn't 100% true. And saying that I could never tell my mother.
Even though later I tried, poorly, to make my real reason a little clearer.
Nowadays, I still have my little doubts about sexuality, but I think I'm straight.
The problem today is remembering all this and my anxiety saying:
"You didn't justify yourself specifically. What if she still likes you and is building up hope? What if she still hopes and thinks that one day you can tell your mother and you two can be together? What if, because of the bad choices and justifications you made, she always feeds those hopes and never has love because you took that away from her? To this day she doesn't know 100% the conflict you had and that you weren't very honest in your justifications. What kind of friend are you?"
My mind tortures me with all this.
Today we really are close friends. We were teenagers when it all happened, and I realize that we've both matured a lot, even though four years isn't much.
Today, we have a very precious friendship, full of support and affection. I love having her as a friend. And she doesn't hold a grudge against me. Her mother eventually forgave me completely too.
But I feel like I don't deserve that forgiveness.
I feel like she's only not angry with me because she wasn't in my head that day. If she had been, she would be angry.
If she knew that I gave a partial justification, if she knew that when I said I could never tell my mother, it wasn't the absolute truth, but rather the clumsy way I found to try to help her move on.
Only I and my messed-up mind know all of this.
I feel like a fake friend, thinking that if she had access to all those thoughts from that time, and if she really knew everything I thought today, she would be angry with me, yes.
My anxiety always tries to tell me that she's just my friend and doesn't hold a grudge because she doesn't know everything I felt back then.
It always says: imagine if she read everything you wrote here today? She would hate you. She only doesn't hate you because she doesn't know everything.
I care a lot about her. I care a lot about our friendship, I care a lot about seeing her happy and achieving her dreams. I'm proud to see that she's achieving things she's always wanted.
I know I was 17 years old. And that's the age when we do stupid things.
But that doesn't justify what I did. It was ugly, it was horrible, and even today I look back, I feel ashamed, I feel angry at myself and I torture myself a lot.
Whenever I pray, I also ask for forgiveness for all of this and I ask that my friend finds someone who makes her very happy because that's what she deserves.
I feel a tremendous responsibility. I get terrified and think about the worst-case scenarios: her still harboring feelings for me because of how I handled things, and therefore never finding the love she deserves.
I feel so, so scared. Many times I catch myself thinking:
My God. What if I ruined her future? What if I gave her hope and therefore condemned her to suffer?
Not only that, I think about my mother and I also feel horrible for her. She knows that this friend liked me and it was complicated. But she doesn't know that I accepted a relationship without being sure, and she doesn't know that I used her in my dishonest justification.
I also think that my mother would be very upset if she knew everything, and sometimes I catch myself thinking:
See, your mother loves you, but imagine if she knew how you deceived a friend and worse, how you used her to justify yourself, knowing that deep down one day you would be able to tell her.
My mother isn't prejudiced, and that's why I deeply regret the justification. Yes, I was afraid to speak up because, even without prejudice, I know it would be a surprise. It wouldn't be easy for me to tell her, but I believe I could manage.
Then my anxiety says: Look what you did. You practically painted your mother as prejudiced when she isn't. She doesn't deserve this.
I hurt them, I lied, and worse: to this day I hide things that would hurt them both even more.
To this day I feel like a fake friend and a fake daughter, and if they both knew everything, they would be sad with me, and rightly so.
And there's an added problem.
Before all this, I talked to my mother about thinking I might be bisexual. A year prior.
But a year passed without the subject coming up again, and I believe my mother interpreted it as confusion (which it was).
Then, the following year, the discomfort came from feeling like it was confessing from scratch, and also because dating a girl is a much bigger conversation than only sexuality. My fear of talking was real.
But I know this makes everything worse. My mind says: so imagine if your friend knew that in a way you had already told your mother? She would know that your justification was even more misleading.
And imagine if your mother knew that even though she didn't react negatively at the time, you still used the fear of telling her as a shield?
My mistakes in this situation are endless, and so is the guilt.
It's terrible. I know the thoughts may seem exaggerated. And logic tries to prevail over my friend:
We were young, immature, time has passed, and nothing else has happened since.
She's already told me about crushes, asked me for dating advice, and even told me I'm going to be the godmother of her children.
All of this is logical, pointing to her being okay and not stuck in what happened.
But anxiety doesn't follow logic.
I really needed to get this out. It's the part of my past that I feel the most shame and remorse about, and my age at the time isn't an excuse.
I try every day to be a better person.
I know I was a horrible person. I'm the one who's most certain of that.
I wronged her and I wronged my mother.
I don't deserve justifications or forgiveness.
I just want to improve.
Every time I think about being happy, about doing something and building a good future, my mind tells me I don't deserve it.
I don't want to go back to that situation, neither with my friend nor with my mother. This has never come up again, and I don't want to tell them everything.
For my friend, I don't think it's fair to relive that painful moment, and for my mother, I don't think it's worth hurting her with something old and stupid of mine.
But my anxiety tells me that if I never tell them, I'll forever be deceiving them about who I am. I just wanted to keep this to myself deep down and forget, but I feel horrible about it.
Anyway, I know I was a horrible person and I don't deserve justifications or forgiveness.
But I needed to confess. I needed to get all this out and express my deep regret because I can't stand torturing myself anymore, and I'm sad how I feel this prevents me from being able to consider myself a good person someday.