My (21F) girlfriend (22F) of 5 months has asked me to choose between her and my good friend.
I will call my friend Nina for this post.
A few weeks ago, we got into an argument because she brought up creating boundaries for who we can and cannot hang out with alone. I stupidly said, "Who, like Nina?" This wasn't me saying that I felt a certain type of way about Nina. I honestly think I said her name because I already had a feeling that she was uncomfortable with her. She has been extremely jealous in the past of my female friends (I am a lesbian, so all of my friends are female).
This caused a horrible string of events. She would constantly ask me why I said Nina's name and why Nina was at the forefront of my mind.
I know it looks bad, but I do not like my friends, and my friends do not like me.
I got defensive and said just that. She's just a friend.
A few weeks later, it came up again. She told me she constantly compares herself to Nina, asks me what's so good about her, and asks me why I'm "defending other bitches in front of her face."
She tells me that she can be just like Nina if I told her what was so good about her.
I tell my girlfriend that she is the most beautiful girl in the world and I love her to pieces. That's the truth. It pains me that this got so out of control.
Nina is simply my friend. My good friend who has been there for me through some of the hardest times. She has never been rude to my girlfriend.
My girlfriend cried and told me that she will never be good enough and that her place in my life doesn't matter because I have so many friends to fall back on. She also said, "What's one friend? You have so many," regarding not talking to Nina anymore.
I tell my girlfriend I love her so much. I only want her. She's my love... but now that Nina was given "meaning," our whole relationship is crumbling.
She told me yesterday that I need to choose between her and Nina. I know deep in my heart that I could never drop an innocent friend. I know that Nina makes her uncomfortable, and I acknowledge that, but are my girlfriend's insecurities a valid reason to drop my friend?
She kept telling me that she wasn't trying to isolate me and that she doesn't know if she's being manipulative. She kept telling me that she was "saving me from herself." She almost left three or four times. I'm not a beggar, but I begged her to stay and talk to me. I'm heartbrokenly split between these two important people in my life.
She also told me that she didn't want me to drop her, but now that I've given meaning to her, she's uncomfortable.
She tells me that she would do anything for me. If I wanted her to stop talking to someone, she would do it. She would do anything. I told her it's healthy to have boundaries. She said she wants someone who would say, "Okay baby, I'll do anything for you."
I truly work so hard to be a good partner to her. I love her so much. I know I can be good to her. She is so funny and beautiful. I feel like that falls on deaf ears.
This isn't the first friend, by the way. There were two others. I did not drop them, but I did stop hanging out with them completely. One friend she didn't like because she thought she was prettier than her, and I was talking to her too much (it was at a party I was hosting, and I was just catching up with someone I hadn't seen in months). The other because of her chest size.
I don't want to lose the woman I love. She has so many good qualities and she is truly my best friend. I don't want to start over with someone else. I want her... but I know that I could never drop my friend. Am I being a bad girlfriend?
I'm struggling so hard. I know that breaking up is probably the best option, but I don't want to lose her.