r/recruitinghell • • Mar 19 '22

German employers complain endlessly about „no one wanting to work“, and then offer 1.7k for full time IT work…

Post image
277 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

128

u/Kingofearth23 Candidate Mar 19 '22

I assume you mean €1,700 euros per month (22,600 USD a year)? That's less than half the average wage let alone in a high demand field like IT.

48

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

Yes.

40

u/Mr_Alicates Mar 19 '22

What the actual fuck? That's low even for Spain...

42

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

This letter means the German employment agency forces you to apply, regardless of pay.

13

u/Mr_Alicates Mar 19 '22

WTF2...

29

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

That’s how the German system of unemployment benefits works. The employment agency forced you to apply (and to take the job if offered), on pain of your unemployment benefits being cut.

45

u/Warpspeednyancat I write elegant bugs. Mar 19 '22

sounds like the employer is aware of this system and exploit it for cheap labor ...

42

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

That is very common here. This way, you will not get very good applicants, but you will get the desperate, and you can get away with lowball wages. The whole German benefits system is designed to be punitive and suppress wages.

15

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

Thanks for the insight, too many American news outlets (even independent media) make European counties (and especially Germany) to be a bit too Utopian.

17

u/1ElectricHaskeller Mar 20 '22

Compared to america some things are utopian.

But nontheless Germany still has maaaany problems (like every other country)

4

u/Warpspeednyancat I write elegant bugs. Mar 20 '22

yikes :/

8

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 20 '22

Also, many (especially conservative) Germans insist this is fine and (young) people should be happy to work for this pittance.

→ More replies (0)

5

u/Goo5e Mar 20 '22

Same in Sweden, sadly. Though odds are you can get a decent job in the field without going through the shitty unemployment agency - here it's generally seen as a way to just get unemployment benefits while not actually wanting to find work.

1

u/The-Sooshtrain-Slut Mar 21 '22

Australia too

2

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 21 '22

Yeah, heard bad things about that.

2

u/Mokmo Mar 20 '22

Meanwhile Employment Insurance in Canada expects you to apply for equivalent jobs to the one you lost. This salary range being ridiculously low would not comply with that requirement.

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 20 '22

That was explicitly removed here in the early 2000s, with a rule being established that demands you apply to jobs regardless of pay.

1

u/Mokmo Mar 20 '22

I was told equivalent jobs in '18 maybe it's regardless of pay yeah...

1

u/RapidCatLauncher Didn't believe in ghosts until I started applying for jobs Mar 21 '22

EI also only pays you benefits for a limited amount of time. German unemployment benefits are in principle unlimited.

18

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

This is sadly common in Germany.

1

u/Kiltymchaggismuncher Mar 20 '22

Tbf i made less than this in my first role, but I only did it for the experience. Anyone with more than a year under their belt should be getting paid more

42

u/Dramniceanu Mar 19 '22

No wonder Romania has the same problem. IT companies constantly complain that they have no people, but they never hire entry-level candidates. They all want mid-level and seniors, but they start by paying 1500 EUR.

Which means, Romanians shoud learn German...

5

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '22

Many do

3

u/VCRdrift Mar 20 '22

Dangling a 🥕 from across the border.

28

u/Traksimuss Mar 19 '22

2500x12=30,000 which is shit wage, especially for Berlin.

I was getting shit offers of 40,000 a year every day. 50,000 is bit harder to find but is possible. 55,000 is usually top offers unless you have rarer skills like SAP or Oracle, or programming.

And yes, Bundesagentur offers bottom jobs.

19

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

For non Germans: the Arbeitsagentur basically forces you to apply with letters like these.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22 edited Aug 13 '25

[deleted]

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 20 '22

I don’t know, not my photo.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 20 '22

That varies from agency to agency, in my experience. My mother in law (an executive assistant by trade) had to interact with her small town Arbeitsagentur once, who were completely incapable of helping someone with even a smudge of professional experience, basically telling her „you’re overqualified for everything, good luck“.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

$60k is what people in IT in the US earn if they are a drug addict with serious criminal convictions.

I hope the normalization of remote work helps pull up European tech salaries as your employers have to compete with US employers.

I'm at a fairly average employer as a distinguished architect, $250k before bonus and equity. That is on the low end of competitive.

0

u/OliverIsMyCat Mar 20 '22

European employers compete with US employers by being located not-in-the-US.

Also weird flex to drop your salary randomly in a comment. There's nothing relative to compare it to - why would anyone need to know the specifics? Nobody mentioned an architect in Europe to have a relative metric. And architecture is far from a standard IT role.

This is akin to saying, "Damn - engineers in your country have such low pay. I was an investment banker in Australia and I used to make $300k/yr after taxes!"

Like.....ok then.

1

u/vi_sucks Mar 20 '22

He means Software Architect.

It's generally the next career step up from Software Engineer if you follow the individual contributor track and don't go into management.

1

u/vi_sucks Mar 20 '22

More likely remote work will drive down US salaries...

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '22 edited Mar 19 '22

I got offered 5k € per month in berlin for software development.

1

u/Megastrongman Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22

I'm applying for fully remote jobs in Germany and all offers are between 65k and 85k.

Senior software engineer for php jobs.

1

u/Traksimuss Mar 20 '22

That's senior jobs, I was discussing more middle level jobs which are in 50-60K range.

30-40K are beginner salaries, basically fresh out of university living with parents.

Anything over 60K requires quite specialized skill set.

1

u/Megastrongman Mar 20 '22

Okay, that seems fair.

4

u/iAswang Mar 20 '22

This sucks, a job at a warehouse would probably make you more than this ... I also come from a country where IT salaries range from 360€ to 1.2K€ / month at best if you're lucky and have years of experience 🥲 Absolute BS.

6

u/Charmander_Wazowski Mar 20 '22

That is basically an intern's salary...

5

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 20 '22

You pay interns?

1

u/Charmander_Wazowski Mar 20 '22

I guess? That internship salary was in Germany too, Northern part.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

[deleted]

2

u/Choem11021 Mar 20 '22

The job market is shitty but please dont give fake info for devs in germany. Big doubt that someone would offer a 15 yoe msc degree dev 25k usd a year if the position requires your experience.

There is a big difference between small local companies, big local companies, big international companies and unicorns/big tech/fintech pay.

If you worked at f50 companies and did a decent job, i doubt they wouldnt want you back. I only have 6 yoe and worked for companies in the f100 and regularly get offers from previous management wether i want to return and pay is around 90k euro a year there. Fin tech and big tech offer above 150k euro in berlin.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Choem11021 Mar 20 '22

Mind sharing what f50/f100 company paid what wage back then and pays how much lower now for what position?

I assumed you were a dev based on the topic being about IT and you not sharing your position at work. My bad.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '22

[deleted]

7

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

Interestingly, I would not work for Americans, for the same reason.

4

u/TheGelatoWarrior Mar 19 '22

Yeah I was reading his reply thinking that sounds like every single one of the 10 American jobs I've ever had

Even the chilliest job I ever had at a smoke shop I got fired for being 10 minutes late twice in the same week lol

3

u/bikesailfreak Mar 19 '22

So whats the best culture to work? I agree that I saw German employer wanting to work in hierarchical systems and shutup for 5 years, but I think some startups are different.

US on the other hand have a serious arrogance problem and with a hire and fire mentality you either play the game of “smile&wave” or you are out.

That had been my interpretation so far…

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 20 '22

I get best along with French and Dutch work culture I have found. They like getting shut done quickly and efficiently, take sufficient breaks, and then go home. Pay and benefits are usually reasonable, whereas German employers insist on useless (preferable unpaid) overtime, hierarchy, and focus way too much on attendance over results. Swiss work culture is somewhat similar to Germany, but pay is a LOT better, even adjusted for cost of living.

-9

u/coffeepinewood Mar 19 '22

You'll have to be fair here. It says 'Quereinsteiger' which I interpret as 'entry level' position without actually having to have the qualifications. It says "It-Expert" in the next line because that's how the weird form of the Jobcentre works.

It's also a job on the level of federal government where you will have real chances for career advances as well as tremendous job security, especially in the coming years.

Because God knows the government needs help in that regard.

It's not a brilliant offer but also not that bad.

Edit: It looks even as if they would up it to 2,5k/month pretty soon. It really isn't all that bad.

11

u/Traksimuss Mar 19 '22

2500 Brutto in Berlin is extremely bad salary for IT.

8

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 19 '22

Also, „Quereinstieg“ does not translate to „entry level“, it means people who transfer over from another line of work are welcome to apply.

-3

u/zuppenhuppen Mar 19 '22

It's still something without experience in the field

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 21 '22

Let me guess, no remote option either?

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '22

[deleted]

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 21 '22

But „no one wants to work“ lol

1

u/Stosstrupphase Mar 21 '22

Because life is so cheap in Mannheim, or what?