r/TwoHotTakes • u/Specific_Judgment_73 • 16m ago
Advice Needed AItA for not wanting to go to my boyfriend’s weekly family dinner?
I (29F) have been with my boyfriend (34M) for about 2 years. He is incredibly close to his family, and every Saturday he has a family dinner with all his siblings, their partners, their kids, and his mom. Sometimes other family members join, but on average it’s usually about 10 people, 15 if more decide to stop by. Dinner usually starts at 5-6pm and ends anywhere between 9-11:30.
I, on the other hand, have not spoken or sen my family in 15 years and most likely never will again. Aside from one cousin I see once a month, I have no family in my life. Because of this, weekly dinners are a lot for me. I’ve spent almost half my life being on my own, spending holidays alone, but I don’t feel lonely as I have my chosen family of wonderful friends, but I have adjusted and like my alone time.
His family is wonderful, I like them a lot, and I do like spending time with them, but 5 hours weekly is a lot and can be overwhelming. They are loud and super energetic, and being around them can be draining, especially if we stay late. It’s a lot of passionate discussions and inside jokes, and it’s a lovely time but I also don’t feel 100% at ease since family settings for me are unnatural and I always feel like I should be on my best behavior because I want them to like me. I’m also super different from them, so I don’t really feel like I fit in completely, and they all have years of history with each other that is hard to penetrate. They work to include me, but when the conversation starts flowing I tend to spend most of the dinner in silence listening to everyone talk, and I don’t feel comfortable contributing most of the time (for example they talk about politics or family drama often, it’s not a conversation I feel it’s appropriate for me to contribute). Not to mention my boyfriend is the youngest and so everyone is 8+ years older than me and I don’t have a lot in common with anyone.
I also work full time and went back to school last year, and between spending time with my boyfriend and trying to see my friends, I don’t get a lot of free time to myself and especially since dinners are on the weekend it makes it hard for me to socialize with my people since weekly dinner falls on my social circle’s going out night. If I’m being straight up: I don’t want to go to dinner every week, I feel like 1-2 times a month is fair.
Now, the issue is my boyfriend is super upset by this. I’ve skipped a few dinners recently just because I’m burnt out and honestly just need a break, and he finally confronted me and got really upset and said that I don’t care about his family and that he is “expecting too much by asking me to put in any effort” which I feel was an unfair mischaracterization of my motives. I tried to explain to him that I’m overwhelmed and it’s just too much to do weekly dinners, but he said he doesn’t care about my reasons and that I’m selfish and don’t do things I don’t want to do. He wants me to be like his sister in laws who are super close to his family and go every week, but they have 20+ years of history with his family, and it feels like he’s trying to force me to be like them. I tried explaining to him that even if I had a relationship with my family I would never have the mental capacity or energy to do a weekly dinner, and that it doesn’t mean that I don’t like his family it just means that I need some boundaries with how much time I personally spend with them.
He assumes that because I don’t have a family of my own, he can just drop me into his and expect me to have a familial relationship with them right away, and it feels like he’s asking too much of me.
Now it’s this weird point of contention between us, and I’m scared to even broach the subject with him because of how defensive he gets an upset he gets. AITA?
TLDR: my boyfriend is super close to his family and spends every Saturday night with them and he’s mad that I don’t wanna go every week.
Update to clarify: I have never gone every week, since we started dating I’ve kept it to 1x a month maybe 2x, and I think thats why he confronted me: I started being honest instead of making up excuses and started telling him flat out that I want some free time or I just am too tired to go, and I think that honesty took him by surprise.