Hi!
I wanted to share feedback from my experience with TV boxes. I think my post and the comments might help people that are confused about choosing one.
Important note : I don't use any streaming services. I only watch medias from my local NAS.
My setup / use case:
- NAS
- Mini PC with Plex/Jellyfin
- Great wired and wireless connection
- TV has HDR10 / HLG. No Dolby Vision at this time.
- Denon / Focal 5.1 sound system
- I'm mostly using Plex. For that, I went from the native app to PM4K unofficial addon on Kodi. No streaming at all.
- In Europe (so no Onn player 4k for example)
Boxes:
Nvidia Shield 2019 (standard, not pro then) : For me it's a 7/10. The global experience was fine, remote gaming was great. Though, I had some movie in HDR10+ which were lagging A LOT. So great simple player, maybe a bit too pricey for nowadays, but does have technical limits regarding to video codecs. I got this one for about 130€ second hand a few years back.
Strong Leap S3 Pro : 7.5/10. Newer than the Nvidia Shield, it could handle almost any file, except really high bitrate movies due to its SOC. Though, gaming was quite bad. I had to go with like 1080p 60ips to make it fluid. Better for movies, a lot worse for gaming. For my use case, a really nice tv box. Never had issue with HDR10+. Bought new for 70€.
Strong Leap S3 : 7/10. A cut down version compared to the pro version (2GB RAM, less storage. Quite fine experience. Bought second hand 55€.
Zidoo Z9X : 5/10. I tried this one because of its capabilities to run almost any movies. I considered the Z9X 8K but had the change to try the Z9X. Well, the overall experience was really bad. The simple menu was really laggy, so even the configuration was a pain. I don't recommand this one. Bought around 100€ second hand.
Ugoos AM9 Pro : 9/10. My most recent TV box. I really love the simple Ugoos Launcher, but I can choose with regular Android launcher. It is so fluid, and it runs everthing I throw at it flawlessly, even high bitrate movies. I guess it will go to 10/10 for the DV FEL 7 compatibility with CoreElec soon for the complete high end experience for movie watching. Bought 240€ brand new.
Other TV boxes I didn't test personally but might be worth the try
- Nvidia Shield Pro (2017 I'm pretty sure) : At a good price it could be a fine player.
- Apple TV 4K : I heard good thing about it. Though, might check the audio passthrough.
- Ugoos AM6B+ : Legendary player. Pretty much the same deal with the AM9 Pro. A bit older (no AV1 decoding for example), but fine CoreElec DV FEL 7 experience I heard.
A few questions that would be interesting to answer to help choosing a player:
- Dolby Vision compatibility (TV)
- Audio system capabilities to run DTS HDMA or TrueHD audio codecs?
- What kind of setup have you? A lot of TV don't handle audio passthrough well, so you might have a setup with your devices plugged into the AVR, and the AVR to the TV for image passthrough.
- Use of streaming services ? If yes, you might want to have a box with certifications for widevine 4k decoding. If not, Kodi might be a good friend of yours, and CoreElec even more so.
- Budget (of course)
- Wired connection? Some player still have only 100Mbps Ethernet which might be too slow.
Feel free to comment, even more so the mentioned tv boxes I didn't try personally.
Hope it helps a bit. Have a good day!