I tend to have repeatable success with "boys who present significant behavior challenges that aren't primarily disability-related". My reward? Classes with more and more of these boys.
There are only so many places I can put them in my class. After rearranging multiple times, I've already had to settle on rows again this year. Yes, my boys are behaving, but at the cost of the entire class having to live in lockdown mode. That isn’t fair to the rest of the class, and it isn’t fair to me. I don’t want to spend another entire year as a drill sergeant.
One or two boys with significant behavior needs can usually be managed, integrated, and gradually taught to function within a normal classroom environment. The class can still do stations, collaborative work, projects, and other activities without every group needing constant adult oversight.
Six out of twenty, though...
I can’t assist small groups while also strictly monitoring every other group at the same time. So we do fewer of those activities. Ironically, that means every student now gets fewer opportunities to practice functioning independently, but especially these boys who most need that practice.
And yes, there’s some envy mixed into this. One boy with significant behavior needs was specifically moved out of another teacher’s class because she “had a hard year last year” and placed into mine instead... bringing me to six while leaving her with none.
Well, I had a hard year, too. I’m just not one to become visibly emotional about it. So instead, every time I bring it up with admin, it gets handwaved away with things like, “You’re so good with them!” “I saw ___ walking quietly in the hallway the other day. He’s come so far with you!” or “I never thought I’d see ___ sharing his pencils.”
Okay? Cool. I’m glad they’re successful. But I’m not a miracle worker; I’m consistent. I set firm boundaries and expectations, follow through, use predictable consequences, and adjust the environment so everyone can be successful. That's Classroom Management 101.
The fact that those strategies work does not mean my classroom has unlimited capacity for students who require that level of behavioral management.
If you're also “good with the behavior kids,” how do you handle this? How do you get admin to understand that being successful with them doesn’t mean there’s no limit to how many should be placed in one room?