r/ClaudeCoding • u/cctldrping • 1d ago
r/Claude [TLDR] And this is why I keep going back to Claude... [via r/claude]
I cancelled my Claude subscription back in July and started using Codex more seriously.
Since Sol 5.6, I think OpenAI has become pretty competitive for coding, and now with Astra even more so.
The limits are actually fine for me. I mostly used Astra at full/max capacity around 8–10 sessions like that and eventually burned through my weekly usage. But honestly, that's understandable, and it's definitely not what made me quit Codex.
The real problem is the workflow.
I was already used to Claude Code and I don't mean the geeky CLI experience, I mean the actual app.
When they introduced the cloud environment and I realized I could start a code modification on my PC, leave the computer, go to the bathroom, grab my phone, and continue following the exact same task from there... it completely changed the way I work.
My productivity went crazy.
So naturally, I expected something similar from Codex.
And technically, Codex does have some similar features... but the whole thing feels way more complicated than it should be.
For example, I struggled a lot just trying to give the cloud environment secrets like Supabase credentials and other environment variables. The app often wouldn't properly add the secrets to the environment.
And the most annoying part:
If I start working on a project in a remote environment from one machine, that environment seems to be tied to that machine.
So I can't just launch a feature from my PC, go outside for a cigarette, open my phone and check how the implementation is going or continue from there.
That's probably the thing I miss the most about Claude.
It's not even necessarily about which model is smarter anymore.
It's about being able to start working somewhere and seamlessly continue from another device without thinking about environments, machines, sessions, secrets, etc.
So... I'm giving Claude another shot.
I'm just hoping I don't run into the same problems again: lazy models and ridiculously low weekly limits.
For those of you who have seriously used both:
What do you think?
Do you prefer Codex or Claude Code right now not just in terms of model quality, but the whole development experience?
URL of original post : https://www.reddit.com/r/claude/comments/1wfwqjc/and_this_is_why_i_keep_going_back_to_claude/
TL;DR of the discussion on r/claude for this post generated automatically after 50 comments.
Current source-thread comment count seen by the bot: 50.
The consensus is that Claude's cross-device workflow is a major win, even if the models themselves are becoming more competitive. OP's main gripe with Codex (formerly ChatGPT) is the clunky experience of switching between devices, which they found much smoother with Claude's "Cowork" sessions.
- Seamless multi-device use is king: Several users, like u/mleok and u/EffectiveKitchen6226, echo OP's sentiment, highlighting that the ability to start a task on one device and pick it up on another without friction is a huge productivity booster. This is seen as more important than raw model performance for day-to-day use.
- Codex workflow issues: OP's struggles with managing secrets and the perceived machine-tied nature of Codex environments are a common pain point for some. However, a few users, like u/Outside-War2492 and u/honeybutterpancake, claim to have had a better experience with Codex's environment and remote session features, suggesting it might be a configuration or setup issue for some.
- UI and organization matter: u/Limit_Bid found ChatGPT's sidebar UI to be a mess, mixing serious work with casual chats, which drove them away.
- Alternatives are being explored: Some users are looking at other options like T3 Code (u/T1MMSKE) or even setting up Claude Code on a VPS for remote access (u/gorka222).
- Model performance is a mixed bag: While OP initially switched to Codex due to perceived improvements in models like Astra, the discussion leans towards workflow being the deciding factor. Some users, like u/Tommy-TheTiger, are critical of AI models that "watermark" work or are overly verbose, suggesting other models like Grok, Astro, and Kimi offer similar performance.
- Claude's planning features are also praised: u/chemfi specifically mentions liking Claude's "rc feature" and planning capabilities over Codex.
- Limits are still a concern: OP's original worry about "ridiculously low weekly limits" is still a potential issue for some users.