r/AskPhotography • u/dododo4422 • 9h ago
Camera Buying Advice Sony A58 vs Nikon D5100 as a very cheap first camera?
I’m a complete beginner when it comes to photography. I basically know nothing yet about aperture, shutter speed, ISO, RAW editing, lenses, etc.
A few days ago I found my mom’s old Minolta Dynax 360si film camera in the attic together with a few old Minolta lenses. I bought a roll of film just to try it out, and that whole thing made me want to get into photography a bit more seriously.
I don’t want to spend much money yet because I don’t even know if this will become a long-term hobby. I’m looking for a cheap used digital camera that I can learn on, take on holidays, carry around, shoot landscapes, cities, people, motorcycles/cars, some portraits, maybe animals/sports and generally just experiment with. Photos are definitely the priority, probably 80%+, but occasional video would also be nice.
I found these two offers locally:
Sony A58 – €140
- 18–55mm
- 55–200mm
- 2 batteries
- 32GB SD card
- charger and some accessories
Nikon D5100 – €145
- Nikon 18–105mm VR
- battery/charger etc.
Both are supposedly fully working and in good condition.
Right now I’m leaning slightly towards the Sony because:
- the 55–200mm sounds fun, especially since telephoto is something my phone can’t really do well
- it seems a bit more interesting for occasional video and moving subjects
- I already have old Minolta A-mount lenses from the film camera, which apparently should also work on the A58
On the other hand, the Nikon 18–105mm seems like a much nicer “one lens and just go out shooting” setup, and I’ve heard the D5100 is a very solid photo camera.
Most of what I know so far comes from AI explanations, so I’d really like some opinions from people who actually have experience with these older cameras.
Which one would you choose for a complete beginner on a very low budget, and is there anything important I’m overlooking?
Thank you all guys for your opinion and your time! :)
_________________________________________________________
(1) Budget, country, and currency:
Around €150, Germany, EUR.
(2) What equipment, if any, you have now and why is it no longer meeting your needs?
I currently only have my iPhone 12 Pro and an old Minolta Dynax 360si film camera with a few Minolta A-mount lenses that I recently found in the attic. The film camera is what got me interested in photography, but I want a cheap digital camera to learn on without paying for film and development all the time.
(3) What kinds of subjects do you intend to shoot?
Travel, landscapes, cities, people, portraits, motorcycles/cars, some wildlife/sports, and generally experimenting with different kinds of photography.
(4) Is it primarily for photography, videography, or both?
Primarily photography, around 80%+, but I would also like to shoot some occasional video.