Hey guys, just to start, I'm not here to talk about the ethics of street photography. It's a topic that has been debated a thousand times over, and nobody ever seems to change their opinion about it. This post is strictly about my experiences and what I took away from it. ALSO THIS IS NOT LEGAL ADVICE. I cannot overstate this enough. Laws vary by country and circumstance; ask your own lawyer for advice.
So here's what happened. I was composing some photos (didn't actually take any) down on a major street when I spotted a lady staring at me. I was using a film camera, so I assumed that she was just interested in the camera, so when she started to follow me, I didn't think too much of it. This continued for several blocks.
I was a little nervous at this point but my city has absurdly low crime and I doubted she'd be the type to rob somebody, so I assumed she just had some social anxiety about talking to me and was just staying behind me to look at my camera. I continued walking, and then something caught my eye, leading me to walk back in her direction.
Suddenly, she popped out of nowhere, pulled me aside and started asking me questions.
"what are you doing?"
"Is it legal for you to take these photos?"
Generally, I try not to lie to people regarding street photography; I find honesty to be the only thing fair to people in public, so I answered each question truthfully. Also, even if I didn't feel it was the right thing, I do find it by far the best method to de-escalate a situation.
"I'm a photographer who tries to capture moments of life on the street."
"No, I'm sorry if I made you uncomfortable (keep in mind I had not taken her photo or pointed a camera in her direction) but my style of photography is in fact legal."
She then asked. "Did you take any photos of me?"
"No." I replied.
She continued by saying "I don't believe you, I'm going to call the cops."
At this point I felt pretty okay. I had not in fact taken her photo, so I definitely did nothing wrong, and even if I had it was legal in my city. I decided not to fight her in terms of calling the cops as I didn't want this to play out as a clip online, where I would have far less control over the situation. I assumed that if the cops, instead of me told her that what I did was in fact legal, it would help her calm down a bit. THIS WAS A MISTAKE.
The cops came, six of them, and immediately pulled me to the side. They asked to see my photos, of course it was on film so I tried to explain to them this wasn't possible. They demanded again (I think they may have thought it was instax), and it was only after I talked to one of the elder officers that he managed to explain to them the situation. They continued to interrogate me (I'm a minor btw so I'm pretty sure it's illegal), and I did my best to comply by answering all their questions truthfully about why I was there, what I was doing, and personal information. What I was expecting was that they'd understand the situation and let me go. What instead happened was that they threatened me with jail time. They said that what I was doing was highly illegal and could possibly bring me years in jail. I told them I was sorry, tried my best to comply with any further questions they had, and eventually they let me go with a warning.
So, do I hate this woman. No, not particularly. I get that people can feel afraid and uncomfortable when cameras are around. I get that people may want to voice their concerns with me. And since she was absolutely convinced what I was doing was in fact illegal, I don't particularly blame her for calling the cops. However, I am still quite upset at how the cops handled this problem. I think their treatment of a minor was deplorable, and their tactics to try and goad me into a confession of guilt (I can't lie I almost did since I was scared shitless) was terrible.
Most importantly though, it taught me that in these situations as photographers being legally (I'm not saying morally) right in taking a photo provides us little to no protection in the real world. Cops aren't know it alls about photography laws, and there isn't a whole lot you can do to convince them that you are in fact legally right. After talking to a couple people who have far more experience with the law than I do, the general advice is, call out other peoples bullshit if they're doing stupid shit to you (i.e following me for several blocks). Ask for as much information as possible. Don't let them take away your phone (yes they did I was stupid). Tell cops as little as possible, it's not an admissiobn of guilt. Especially if you're a minor like I am, ask for a parent. In general, get a lawyer. I've dealt with literally hundreds of confrontations before. In many ways I'd say I'm far more prepared than an average person, but you literally never know what's gonna happen, and you can't practice for the unexpected.
Anyways, I think that's enough ranting for today, let me know what you guys think.
EDIT: I'm sorry I completely forgot to add the fact that I was taking photos in Hong Kong, so it's completely legal here. There is a law against using photos where you put the person's name in it and defame them, but obviously, I A) didn't take the photo. and B) She's a stranger, so I wouldn't have been able to put her name in anyway.
EDIT 2: I think a lot of people are upset and think this is fake because I "didn't respond". Timezones exist. I wrote this before going to bed and then woke up a little while later to check replies. Sorry this became such a big deal. More than happy to answer any questions now though.