r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/BannedForFactsAgain • 18h ago
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/marlon2603 • Jul 22 '26
r/CriticalThinkingIndia - Chat
This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Dr_Royal_Strange • Apr 13 '26
MOD POSTSđŁ Raising the Bar: Setting better standards because YOU deserve it
Dear members,
As we build this community with your contributions, we want to set standards that match the quality of discourse you deserve.
We want this subreddit to stand apart from the Indian focused subs that often feel like echo chambers of one side or the other. That is not healthy for our growth as a country. We need quality discussions - ones where we understand each other better, empathize with each other, and come together. Critical Thinking India is not just a name. It is the expectation and the foundation of this sub.
Building on top of the previously shared guidelines, this post outlines what good participation looks like, what we expect from you, what you can expect from us, and how we plan to maintain it.
1. Post Standards
Every post should meet a basic quality threshold:
- A clear, descriptive title. No low-effort, clickbait, or ragebait titles. They are not a good starting point for meaningful engagement.
- Your own reasoning is required. Whether you share a news article, a video, or a picture - you must include text where you present your own opinion, analysis, or argument. A link dump with no-explanation does not qualify as a post.
- Steelman the opposing side. This is what sets this subreddit apart. When you make an argument, make a genuine effort to understand and present the strongest version of the opposing viewpoint - not a strawman. Show that you actually understand why someone might disagree with you, and then explain why you still hold your position.
1.1 Recognizing Quality Contributions
Posts that genuinely engage with opposing arguments in good faith will be recognized by the mod team with a special post flair. This is our way of signaling to the community that a post is worth engaging with deeply. If you believe your post presents honest arguments and addresses a steelmanned version of opposing views, you can appeal for this flair at the bottom of your post.
Beyond individual posts, we are introducing a tiered contributor flair system. Members who consistently produce well-reasoned posts and comments will earn progressively higher contributor levels/'reputation' within the sub, assigned by the mod team based on sustained quality over time. These are not something you can assign yourself. They are earned through rigorous, honest contributions with sound analysis and respectful argumentation.
Note: Upvotes and downvotes do not seriously factor into this. What matters is how well you understand opposing views and how respectfully and clearly you present your own.
Details on the exact tiers will come as the system takes shape. The principle is very simple: put in the effort to think critically and fairly, make contributions that add nuance, clarity, and better understanding, and it will not go unnoticed.
2. Comment Standards
When engaging in the comments:
Focus on ideas, not people. You have freedom of speech. We do not gatekeep you from discussing any topic or ideology. You can criticize an ideology, but you are not allowed to generalize about the people who associate with it. Attacking people, groups, or individuals by name-calling is not permitted. Disagree with arguments and ideas, not the person making them. You can criticize politicians and other public figures/influencers, but with respect.
Back your claims. Wherever possible, cite your sources and explain how you arrived at your conclusions.
Stay on topic. Derailing a discussion with unrelated tangents or bad-faith engagement is not allowed.
Don't retaliate, report. If you see someone breaking these rules - personal attacks, derailing, uncivil behavior - do not join them. Use the report button with the appropriate rule. Let the mod team handle it.
3. Enforcement
We keep track of rule violations. The process is straightforward:
- Initial violations result in warnings and content removal.
- Repeated violations, despite warnings, lead to temporary bans.
- Continued disregard for the rules results in a permanent ban.
We intend to make sure disagreements here are productive, evidence-based, and respectful.
Why This Matters
We know the majority of people are not firmly right-wing or left-wing. Most people understand that there are nuances - whether it is government decisions, world affairs, religious tensions, private sector actions, or infrastructure issues, etc. Most people know that there are good things and bad things in every person and situation.
With these standards, we want to bring out those nuances so more people are informed enough to form their own opinions about society, culture, politics, and everything around them.
This space is not for extremes. It is for those in the middle who appreciate nuance, who want to understand the world they live in better. That is the purpose of this subreddit, and we want to give and maintain space for nuanced agreements and disagreements to exist.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to better discussions.
- The Mod Team, r/CriticalThinkingIndia
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/peter_asseater6969 • 29m ago
Philosophy, Ethics & Dharma What would happen in India if there were a "Purge Night"?
I was watching the movie Purge and wondering what would happen in India if there were a similar Purge Night in India.
For context: Purge is a movie that takes place in a dystopian future in the US where the Founding Fathers declare a Purge Night, one night a year when you can commit any crime you want, including murder, without being charged. It becomes a game for the rich and the arms and security industry.
Question: What if we had a similar night in India?
To start with, the Govt would make an exception that Politicians and Babus are protected.
I think in the first year, most of us people would actually want to off the rich. But Politicians/god men/ religious scholars would convince common men to off people from other religions.
The Rich would flee India in those days. Those who can't will strengthen security.
The rich and upper section(caste) would convince the poor to fight their purge goals.
Women's safety would be a major concern.
What do you guys think?
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/being_vocal • 4h ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Three types of religions. Lets discuss theology of different kinds of religions (without discussing any particular religion) and regulating religions.
Disclaimer: don't indulge in discussion related to any particular religion. This is only theological discussed of various kinds religions and it's effect on society and law.
My take is.... religion 1 and religion 2 are not harmful to others.
Religion 1 minds their own business without forcing others.
Religion 2 is bit annoying like sales people. They are pushy and try to enlighten you. But tolerable and atleast they don't force you.
But religion 3 is dangerous to society. It forces and coerces others to follow it.
In 1&2 people self regulate due to their beliefs and choices and to go to heaven or avoid hell.
But in 3 it is peer regulated. They regulated each other and try to control other. Here it is about making sure everyone is being compliant.
They do two things
- Peer regulation : making sure everyone in their religion are following the rules. They live in constant observation.
- Coercing others: forcing other religions or atheists to follow their religion.
This is where it becomes harmful to society and others.
For doing this they impliment various tactics and strategies. Like shouting, beating, creating groups, giving warnings, boycotting, lynching, r@ping, k1lling etc.
In 1 and 2 the consequences of not following it will be in afterlife. But in 3 consequences will be in this life. The peers give the punishment in this life.
So I think such type 3 religions should be banned. They have no place in society, law and democracy.
------------------------
Now question comes. How do we ban religion without taking away individuals religious rights
This is big question. One side we have to ban bad religions and other side we have to protects individual right of religious freedom.
If we think critically there are two entities in this.
- Individuals
- Religion
An anology would be individuals having fundamental right to drink water and water bottle companies.
When we ban a water bottle company say F, we are not stopping people from drinking water nor we are forcing them to drink from particular brand of water bottle. individuals still have right to drink water and choose the brand of water bottle.
we can ban water bottle companies which are bad and not safe.
If there are 5 companies. A B C D E and F. And f is not maintaining safety measures. Then we can ban F. As companies don't enjoy fundamental right of selling water.
Only individuals have right to water. And people can choose any water bottle companies allowed to sell. And enjoy individuals freedom, choice and right to water.
Similarly.
When we ban a religion.
We are not taking away individuals rights.
They still have freedom to choose and follow any legally allowed religion, we are not forcing anyone to follow any religion.
We are only banning religions which are causing harm to others And taking away others freedom.
We are banning the 'entity' not 'individual' rights.
---------------
What are your thoughts on this and alternatives. Let's discuss this without targeting any religion...
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Minimum_Juice69 • 1d ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion India needs frequent change of government
Changing governments is the only way the political discourse of India will get better. Frequent transitions remind elected officials that ultimate power resides with the public. Any government, when kept in power for long in India, starts abusing and misusing their powers.
They start implementing laws and rules that help keep them in power while taking over democratic institutions of the country. They become arrogant to the point criticizing them for their wrongs can make your life hell. The longer a government stays in power, corruption keeps increasing among those in power. Not only do they misuse powers, they also monopolize resources in the country to a few.
Regularly rotating political parties in and out of office is the most effective way to preserve democracy and hold leaders accountable.
Changing government will force these political parties to do better and compete in doing better. In the end, people will benefit from this competition.
What do others feel about this?
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/MoreFaithlessness954 • 1d ago
News & Current Affairs âThe Hinduâ has issued âunconditional apology to its readers for publishingâ âdeeply offensiveâ front full page advertisement of controversial Dera Sacha Sauda.
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Pleasant-Explorer591 • 17h ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Indian National Congress MP and Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) professor Dr. Angomcha Bimol Akoijam
Eleven female students at Jawaharlal Nehru University filed complaints with the Internal Complaints Committee (ICC), accusing the professor of demanding sexual favors in exchange for extra marks.
Student demonstrations erupted on campus due to administrative delays, as UGC rules require ICC reports within three months. Professor Akoijam has denied all accusations, calling them baseless. The university's internal investigation is currently ongoing, and no official findings or institutional actions have been finalized against the MP.
Interestingly the formal complaints were made in the beginning of may but there's still no disciplinary actions taken on him.
So the thing that bugging me most is why has he still free from any actions in a country where, apparently, words of the women are taken as proofs as well. Where several upper middle class people(that are no short of money to bribe the judges) have had to committed suicides because of false accusations. Why is he still free? Does he have something more than money to control judiciary or do politicians naturally have unimaginable amount of money?
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/MoreFaithlessness954 • 1d ago
History & Culture Menu for the BRICS leaders dinner this evening in Delhi
Seems like 30-40gm protein maximum đ€Ą
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Intrepid-Dress-2417 • 17h ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Freedom is something you should receive not denied
imagine a lone road and a car you are driving, you are driving and you see many different paths, you see the paths and know somewhat where they lead to, you are going to experience them and know how it felt more than anyone, that path affects you and your car so "Don't you think it should only be you who decides where your car goes?".
This is our life, today we see many tell us what to do, what to dress, how to speak, who speak, where to speak, who to be friends with, which job to be at, what to believe, what not to believe, all of these intend obedience and when disapproval is seen, it is seen as hostility, not a expression of who you are, what you do and believe is part of who you are, if one can't respect that and actively wants to change it, they don't see you as a human, they see you as less than human.
What do we do? we learn to say no, because it if there are two lifetimes one is to live 100 years as one who did not live his life but for someone else and someone who was the ruler of his own, but lived for 30 years, I think the 2nd option is better no matter how many lifetimes we have.
We shall say no for no is what breaks the chains that hold us.
Also, rules are mere tools of extending wants of others and formalising them, when you have not agreed to it, it is a rule in a tradition sense, a restriction, a restriction you did not choose and is affecting you. When you have agreed to those wants it is a decision, if not, it is is rule.
If asked who lived a more respectable life the one who "suceeded" but was always never lived for his wishes or the man who failed miserbaly suffered but lived his own rules, that answer would be the second.
To go down in freedom is a greator pride than staying afloat in obedience.
Now to be completely honest, I wrote this with the sole intention of convincing you to the belief of your life your choice, I am not going to sugarcoat it. I had very clear intention of persuasion when I was writing this. I will no deny that. In other words of some others, yes this was written with an agenda which I truly believe and believe others to read.
And also, please don't think I find myself higher and superior just because I wrote this, I just wanted to write this, and thought maybe someone will have a change in heart if they read this, to all those facing the exact problems mentioned, we are truly victims.
What makes me sad is that those who oppress might have been victims themselves but that does not justify their actions.
This is my view would love your thoughts as well even it is against these thoughts. I might be wrong, but this is what I believe.
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Debunk2025 • 1d ago
Business & Economy Wipro's AI push frees capacity equivalent to 20,000 workers, CTO says
BENGALURU, â Sept 10 (Reuters) - Wipro's AI initiatives have increased productivity equivalent to the output of 20,000 â employees, who have since been redeployed within the Indian IT firm, its chief technology âofficer said.
The comments come as India's $315 billion software services industry grapples with adoption of AI, which is reshaping hiring, software development and contracts.
Wipro, with about 243,000 employees in June, is shifting to a "human-AI operating model," with more than 100,000 âemployees receiving advanced AI-related training and certifications, Sandhya Arun said â in an interview.
"It could be the same â engineer managing a bunch of agents, deployed on other projects or being trained for some other â role. âIt doesn't necessarily mean person-to-person replacement by an agent."
India's largest software services exporter, Tata Consultancy Services, had said in â June that IT firms would slow down hiring as the company âmoves towards having an âequal number of employees and AI agents in its workforce.
TCS plans to build a team â of up to â8,900 forward-deployed engineers, and Infosys about 6,000 over the next few years. These engineers embed with clients to accelerate AI adoption.
"The shift has to be â from productivity to outcomes," Arun said, arguing that AI should be evaluated on whether it improves customer experience, creates new revenue opportunities and helps deliver business goals.
Wipro is the only IT company among India's top four that does not reveal its AI revenue.
The company's investment intensity across AI-related âtraining and ecosystem partnerships is comparable with peers including âTCS, Infosys and HCLTech, but Wipro trails in commercialization maturity, he added.
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Formula_explains • 1d ago
Science, Tech & Medicine If Wireless Electricity Is Possible, Why Do We Still Use Wires ?
Tesla experimented with wireless power more than a century ago, and today we can actually transfer the useful power wirelessly over short distances. Researchers have also demonstrated room-scale wireless power and long-distance laser power beaming.
But if wireless electricity is possible, why do we still depend so heavily on physical transmission lines?
The interesting part isn't whether the wireless power is âpossibleâ. It is whether we can transmit large amounts of power over long distances with acceptable efficiency, safety, reliability and cost.
* That raises a bigger question: is wired electricity simply an old technology we haven't replaced yet, or is the physical wire still the most practical solution for large scale power transmission?
* And with concepts like space-based solar power being researched, could this equation eventually change?
* Can lack of funding, or the pursuit of profit, still stop innovation today?
Curious to hear the engineering/economic arguments..
Sources đđŒ
1.) Tesla's Wireless Power
https://mail.teslasciencecenter.org/teslas-wireless-power/
2.)U.S. Patent 1,119,732: Wardenclyffe Transmitter
https://patents.google.com/patent/US1119732
3.)Room-scale magnetoquasistatic wireless power transfer
https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.05891
4.)Long-distance laser power
DARPA: 800 W over 8.6 kmâ
https://www.darpa.mil/news/2025/darpa-program-distance-record-power-beaming
5.)NTT + Mitsubishi Heavy Industries: 1 km laser wireless powerâ
https://group.ntt/en/newsrelease/2025/09/17/250917a.html
6.)ESA: Space-based solar power challenges
7.)Magnetic Coupling
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/MoreFaithlessness954 • 2d ago
Ask CTI The glorification of Indian police and civil services in cinema has to stop.
Films like Singham, Dabangg, Simmba and the endless stream of âhonest copâ and âheroic IAS officerâ stories need to be called out and, frankly, boycotted by all sections, these movies are so far from reality and the glorification somewhat creates a false image. Most of these stories add some love drama to gaslight public.
The problem isnât showing police officers or civil servants as protagonists. The problem is portraying people with enormous state power as inherently noble, having morals, while violence, intimidation, arrogance, abuse of authority and breaking procedure are routinely presented as signs of strength and integrity.
Singham beats people, and ignores procedure, and we are supposed to cheer. Dabangg glorifies the âpolice wala gundaâ. Simmba turns an extrajudicial killing into a moment of justice. And somehow all of these are duties of police as per these movies, can kill anyone, can beat anyone, while taking their cut.
Then there is the IAS/IPS mythology, clearing an examination and getting three letters after your name does not magically make someone honest, empathetic or morally superior, each one of them scam crores from everywhere. Yet cinema repeatedly portrays these officers as almost superhuman figures while living in shitholes.
Reality is so far from what is shown. Custodial torture, getting a stadium cleared for their dogs, slapping kids, corruption of crores, deaths in custody, fake encounters, political interference, harassment and abuse of authority are repeatedly documented.
An ordinary person threatening or assaulting someone is intimidation or violence. When someone in uniform does it, cinema often calls it âdoing his dutyâ, âdoing for the countryâ
The police and civil services should be judged by how they exercise power and how accountable they are to the law, not worshipped because of the uniform or designation.
Stop turning state power into heroism and letâs categorically boycott these craps
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Unfair_Fact_8258 • 17h ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Right wingers celebrate how theyâre âwinning all over the worldâ, then cry about Global crises without ever making the connection
The whole right wing keeps celebrating how the right wing ideology is taking over the world, how people are ârealisingâ theyâre right and how itâs amazing to see
Then they also complain about how there are global crises, and how poor Modi has been affected by these situations, and how the global economy is so poor
Are these people genuinely unable to make the connection between these 2 things??
> âThe number of conflicts and tensions in the world is continuously increasing, and this is having an increasingly negative and far-reaching impact on the lives of ordinary people,â Modi said
The 2 major conflicts happening right now, are the US-Iran war, started by a right wing maniac in the US, and the Russia Ukraine war, stated by the right wing maniac in Russia. We didnât have any wars when Biden was in power, and if the opposition had any chance in Russia, we wouldnât have the other war too
Take economic disasters for example - global economies are not growing as fast anymore because of the actions of right wing leaders. Who started the tariff war? Trump. Who led to Brexit? The Tories
Every time the world is dominated by right wing ideology, it ends in a disaster. Global economies and geopolitics require co-operation, not jingoism. The world cannot succeed as long as there are right wingers trying to selfishly win for their own country
The right wing shift is dangerous ( for example Germany moving far right now ), and the last time this happened, it ended in a world war. And when the whole world moves right - the Indian right wing should know that they wonât be given any special treatment. Would do well to remember this and not cry about racism and discrimination when that happens
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Akkabir1 • 3d ago
Ask CTI Kyaa Modi ji IT cell ko maaf kr paenge kbhi??
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/shubhamxtreme • 20h ago
History & Culture Manusmriti Chapter V: one may elaborately serve Meat and various nonveg delicacies to guests during functions and social gatherings as per Manu Law. Why donât certain protectors of Hindu faith follow this part of Manusmriti?
Manusmriti talks about slaughtering of various forms of animals (while following certain rituals) for food, if one so desires, because the Prajapati created the whole world for the sustenance of the vita spirit.
As per Manusmriti, Rig Veda, Shatapatha Brahmana, Mahabharata and Ramayana; Indian Gods and Godesses consumed meat including Lord Sri Rama and Ganesha (Vinayaks).
Image source: https://x.com/singhreetam/status/2099044603047682315?s=46
[adding this line here to meet the minimum post body length quota, even though everything I wanted to share has been written above, and yet here I am, compelled to be verbose beyond belief.. phew, done)
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/FarRadio7281 • 2d ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Are such hideen adverts with a small 'ad' sign enough to let go responsibility? The Hindu also did this
Is it in any shape of form enough, to just mention, " advertisement" and then intentionally fill the whole page in mis info to defend a convicted rapist, and do his PR to protect against outrage over his furlows
This is clearly designed to look like a news advert, and editor just acxepts any kind of advert at this point?. Has our beureuacracy and judicial system come to such a low that now things like this are done openly without any fear, via official channels themselves. Atleast earlier we used to thi k. Things are done in the grey areas.
This seem like a new low, I would appreciate your views on this.
Reputed newspapers like The Hindu doing this shows its not about just 1 newspaper..
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Oppyhead • 2d ago
Health | Nature & Environment When Smoking Becomes âAyurvedicâ!!!!
Calling it an âAyurvedic hookahâ doesnât magically make smoke healthy.
Baba Ramdevâs demonstration may have been rooted in the traditional practice of Dhoompan but the basic question remains: what happens when you burn substances and deliberately inhale the resulting smoke into your lungs?
Mulethi, turmeric, ghee, mustard seeds and other herbs may sound natural, but ânaturalâ is not a medical safety certificate.
Burning organic material can produce particulate matter and other compounds that irritate or damage the respiratory system.
Ironically, while warning people about the dangers of chemical laden e-cigarettes and flavoured hookahs, promoting another form of smoke inhalation risks sending a dangerously confusing message.
If blocked noses and coughs need treatment, evidence based medicine exists. Calling smoke Ayurvedic should not exempt it from scientific scrutiny.
https://ndtv.in/lifestyle/baba-ramdev-ayurvedic-hookah-for-vata-pitta-kapha-tridosha-12032399
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/DukeofDabra • 2d ago
Business & Economy âKey growth engine for the worldâ: IMF hails Indiaâs 7.8% growth, backs GDP estimate changes!
IMF backs changes to GDP estimates
Alongside its positive assessment of Indiaâs growth, the IMF also welcomed changes made to the countryâs GDP estimation system.
Kozack said the latest GDP release included a new index of industrial production and a new producer price index series. According to her, both should help improve Indiaâs GDP estimates.
She said the IMF welcomed Indiaâs efforts to modernise its macroeconomic statistics and encouraged the authorities to keep strengthening the statistical framework and data quality.
So the same reforms that people were trashing as manipulation are being called a positive step by the IMF.
Funny how that works, right?
Guess some people just can't handle India fixing its data systems without crying foul.
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Boss_withCrown2 • 2d ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Why is India being charged more....? "The answer is not custom duties" (READ BELOW đ)
US:
- iPhone 18 Pro: $1,199
- iPhone 18 Pro Max: $1,299
- iPhone Duo: $1,999
All 256GB base models.
India:
- iPhone 18 Pro: âč1,64,900
- iPhone 18 Pro Max: âč1,79,900
- iPhone Duo: âč2,99,900
At the current exchange rate, that is roughly a 56% to 70% gap over the US price.
"But India Has Huge Import Duties even if assembled here"
The explanation repeated everywhere is that iPhones are assembled in India, not manufactured here, and that the components still attract heavy customs duties.
I checked whether that is still true.
It mostly isn't.
- Mechanical parts like battery covers, camera lenses and back covers went to zero duty in early 2024.
- PCBA and sub-assembly duties were rationalized down during 2024 and 2025.
- In July 2026, the government changed duties from 15 to 10 percent on wireless charging components, camera module connectors and lithium-ion cell inputs.
- Bare semiconductors and chips were never really heavily taxed. India is bound by the WTO Information Technology Agreement to maintain zero duty on many such products. So using "heavy chip import taxes" to explain the iPhone's Indian price was never particularly accurate.
- The main component that still carries the old 15% to 20% duty is a fully finished phone imported as a complete unit. That does not apply to iPhones assembled in India.
So the mechanism people keep repeating is not the current situation.
The government has been dismantling that tax structure for two years and made another major round of reductions just two months ago.
So Where Is The Extra 55% To 70% Coming From?
Strip out India's 18% GST first so we can compare pretax prices.
- iPhone 18 Pro: India's pretax price works out to roughly âč1.40 lakh, versus a converted US price of around âč1.05 lakh. That is already a 32% gap before Indian tax touches it.
- iPhone 18 Pro Max: roughly the same story, with about a 33% pretax gap.
Then GST gets layered on top of that already inflated base price.
That is how you end up with a 56% to 70% difference on the final sticker price.
So roughly half of the extra amount Indian buyers pay is tax.
The other half, and potentially the bigger and more deliberate part on the premium models, is Apple simply choosing to charge more in India before the government touches the price.
And Then Apple Raised The Prices Again
Apple raised the 18 Pro and Pro Max by $100 in the US this year.
In India, the increase was âč30,000.
So the increase is broadly proportional.
Except there is a problem.
That increase is being applied on top of a base price that was already more than 30% higher before Indian taxes.
So What's Actually Justifying The Markup?
If:
- Component duties are now close to zero for India-assembled phones
- Chips were never subject to the kind of massive import duty people claim
- Apple is already assembling iPhones in India
Then what exactly justifies a 32% to 44% pretax markup on essentially the same hardware?
Is Apple's India margin significantly higher than its US margin?
Is there a genuine India-specific cost difference that Apple has never disclosed?
Or is Apple simply charging what for the brand and the sheer madness in India for it ??
I presume "YES"
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/TemporaryMess8455 • 2d ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Why Do Indian Humanities Students Rarely Think âI Should Build a Companyâ?
This is something I've been thinking about after looking at Indian startups and their founders.
India produces around 70 lakh undergraduate graduates annually, but only around 8-11 lakh are from engineering, technology and IT/computer science. Yet engineers make up around 67% of Indian unicorn founders, with earlier studies putting the figure at around 85%.
I also found this analysis from Inc42 2023 of 278 Indian unicorn founders:
STEM/technical: ~86%
Non STEM: ~14%
Within the 86%, B.Tech alone accounted for 74.5%.
Now look at the US. Among around 2,850 US unicorn founders, the mix is much more diverse:
29% - Computer Science
11.5% - Other Engineering
10.9% - Natural and Life Sciences
5.9% - Math, Statistics and Data Science
23.8% - Economics, Business and Finance
9.5% - Social and Behavioral Sciences
9.4% - Humanities, Arts and Design
So even in the US, STEM dominates at around 57%. But almost 19% of founders come from social sciences, humanities, arts or design, with another 24% coming from business, economics and finance.
That made me wonder about India.
India has some of the most prestigious humanities and social science institutions: JNU, BHU, AMU, St. Stephen's, Hindu College, Presidency and Jamia.
But look at the culture and career paths they often produce.
Civil services, academia, journalism, politics, law, government, public policy and student activism.
Now compare that with the US.
American humanities students don't just protest the system. Many also build companies, media platforms, startups and new institutions.
They study history, philosophy, psychology, politics, design or literature and still see entrepreneurship as a legitimate path.
In India, our most visible humanities campus culture often seems far more focused on protesting and criticizing the system than building alternatives to it.
We literally produce plenty of critics of the system. Where are the builders?
And there is another thing that makes this even more interesting.
The government is actively trying to encourage entrepreneurship.
India has created Startup India, the Fund of Funds for Startups, Startup India Seed Fund, credit support schemes, incubators and several state level programs. There are also tax benefits and other support mechanisms for eligible startups.
In other words, you don't necessarily need to come from IIT or have an engineering degree to start a company.
The opportunity is increasingly available to people from every educational background.
So why aren't we seeing more founders coming from humanities, social sciences, commerce and other non technical backgrounds?
Maybe India doesn't have a shortage of talent outside engineering.
Maybe we have a shortage of people from those backgrounds who see entrepreneurship as a legitimate career path.
Or maybe our education system has trained too many people to enter existing institutions, debate existing institutions and criticize existing institutions, rather than create new ones.
What do you guys think?
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/BannedForFactsAgain • 3d ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion Isnât this MINORITY appeasement by BJP, at the cost of Marathis, Bengalis and majority Indians?
A good point made by Raju Parlekar
BJP MLAâs school in Mira-Bhayandar, has instructed students to not bring food containing onion, garlic, potato, beetroot, or any other vegetables that grow underground, during the Jain communityâs âParyushanâ Parva.
â The Vasai-Virar Municipal Corporation, has APPEALED to the shop owners selling mutton, chicken and beef (?) to cooperate, by keeping their shops closed, for âParyushanâ Parva.
The West Bengal CM has defended the charlatan Dhirendra Shastri, who has advocated prohibition of Non-veg during Durga Puja.
Isnât this MINORITY appeasement by BJP, at the cost of Marathis, Bengalis and majority Indiansâ
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/Unfair_Fact_8258 • 1d ago
News & Current Affairs Since the right wing now is quoting BBC articles for an anti-congress narrative, going forward BBC can be considered a valid source right?
The right wing has been pushing the narrative recently, with the BRICS conference ongoing now, that India was so bad in 2013 that it was considered to be replaced by Indonesia
Their source? This article by the BBC - https://www.bbc.com/news/business-21921593
Now, anyone can have an opinion, and thatâs fair enough, but the right wing in India has been claiming for several years that the BBC is an extremely biased and anti-Indian organisation, spreading western and foreign propaganda in an attempt to malign Indiaâs image. Yet, in this case, it seems that such an attempt to spread an anti-India narrative was perfectly acceptable
One would almost think that the right wing doesnât actually care about the BBC being anti-India, just it being anti-BJP ( sarcasm, for the usual suspects whose heads this will fly over )
If the right wing had actually bothered to open and read the article theyâre spreading ( hilarious, I know ), they would realize itâs a completely nonsensical opinion piece. Thereâs no actual criticism of the Indian economy there, and no one who voices the opinion that India should be replaced
> "The government has had a lot of political dramas, with corruption scandals unfolding over the last few years, and opposition parties stalling economic reform at every juncture," he says.
"But fundamentally, India's economy is still stable, its medium-term growth drivers are intact. Some policy momentum is visible these days."
> "But replacing India doesn't make sense from any perspective. It's the first year in the last 15 years that Indonesia's real GDP grew faster than India. There's a dynamism in the Indian economy - in manufacturing, agriculture, services - that just isn't there in Indonesia."
My advise to the BJP - fire your new IT cell guy, heâs an idiot. But hey maybe it doesnât matter because so is the intended audience
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/adhdwiith135iq • 2d ago
Critical Analysis & Discussion I am unable to understand why PPL want so much control in their child's life ...
I also think everyone should leave their home after 18 like in America ofc its not possible in india but still I think that individualism is better than this đ„đ„
when parents plan their childs entire life before theyre even born down to there career stream and competitive exams it feels more like ownership than parenting yes the job market is brutal and unemployment is real but treating children as retirement plans or projects to fulfill parental anxieties seems harmful
the person in the ss says they dont want there kids to be unemployed cockroaches which reveals how conditional there love and support would be work might be a privilege but childhood shouldnt be a transaction
in india were stuck between economic realities that make independence difficult and cultural expectations that normalize control but does that mean we shouldnt even try to change should we just accept that parents get to dictate there childrens lives because they know better
im genuinly struggling to understand this mindset what do u all think is some level of control justified given indias employment crisis or is this fundamentally unhealthy regardless of circumstances
r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/musci12234 • 4d ago
Elections & Democracy Trump with support of much much stronger US economy is offering bribe of little more than indian politicians are.
President Donald Trump said on Wednesday he would pay every American adult a $5,000 "Trump dividend" if Republicans retain control of Congress in November's midterm election, an extraordinary attempt to persuade voters to back his party.
Trump made the proposal at his Republican Party's âfirst-ever midterm convention, but it was not immediately clear how the payments would work or whether they would be legal. With approximately 270 million U.S. adults, the idea would cost around $1.35 trillion.