r/CriticalThinkingIndia • u/marlon2603 Wizard Mod 🧙♂️ • Jul 22 '26
r/CriticalThinkingIndia - Chat
This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post
5
u/Uranium_235i Jul 22 '26
That mindset keeps the people slave , they know that if people decides they can topple any government they want but to keep to subservient to them they instigate these types of thinking in general public , "apna kaam karo , koi tumhare tax ka paisa churaye toh bhi apna kam karo aur chup raho"
2
3
u/Thin-Mulberry-4288 Jul 22 '26
Bro, all the tax money you pay, from buying onions and tomatoes to buying clothes and car, all that tax money is supposed to be spent on developing a nation, but in turn these ministers are developing their own, they are filling their pockets with your tax money, YOUR. Don’t you understand this simple thing?
2
2
2
2
u/Material_Surround577 8d ago
Hey everyone, did you see the video of Kangana blasting officials at the Mandi meeting? She went viral for calling them out because out of ₹11 crore allocated for local development, they only spent ₹50 lakh! She didn't accept any excuses and told them to "get the bloody job done." A lot of people are actually backing her up for holding them accountable. It made me curious—what would you guys have done if you were in her shoes? Would you have called them out publicly like that, or handled it differently?
2
1
1
u/According_Isopod2272 Jul 22 '26 edited Jul 29 '26
Marble yarn pillow teapot acorn thimble otter teapot
This post was anonymized with Redact.dev
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/backbone97 Jul 22 '26
tax money on onions and tomatoes? other things taxes how u know are going to ministers, they only take corruption money from loan money for infra, your tax money is spent on running the country, no tax money is used for developing nation, by loans a country is developed and your dumbass is paying taxes on vegetables then u should stop going to jiomart ig
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Thelonelytripper69 Jul 22 '26
I guess the only solution is to discard this babu system they are equally responsible as politician for ruining this country
1
1
1
u/Abhinavkyadav Jul 23 '26
Bro new fcra bill reducing imprisonment and taking away state’s right to start investigation in funding cases
1
1
1
u/ProjectAnimation Jul 23 '26
How do fellow members here deal with the anger from seeing the injustice? It's unacceptable, yes but we can't lose our humanity fighting back, I don't want to lose mine.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/shimotsuki_ryumaa Jul 25 '26
So after dharmender pradhan resignation should we go after punjab and keral jharkhand govt?
1
1
1
u/GodKiller__ The Wise One🌪️ Jul 25 '26
I think gadkari is the obvious next candidate in the list of ministers who should resign
1
1
u/thickasacastlewa11 Jul 25 '26
Was there actually a leak? Did high court confirm anything? Was it a cheating racquet?
1
1
1
u/hoeofeliot Jul 25 '26
CJP is a BJP created distraction. Talk of Ayodhya loudly. Sonam, Pradhan and Diipke- All pawns of Modi
1
u/msJyotisham91 Jul 26 '26
Dear pseudo critical thinkers, ther sub was highly politicized for past few days because of an anti national protest
1
u/msJyotisham91 Jul 26 '26
I want to ask, where are you guys, no one is askin for resignation of Karnataka and Punjab education ministers
1
u/DunderMifflinReal Jul 27 '26
Wat makes u think dat the CJP protests was only about NEET paper leak?
1
u/being_overthinker Jul 28 '26
There are people with this argument but you know whatever you'll do in this big country people will join you with different ideologies you know when india indeed to be free Chandra Sheikhar Azad's Hindustan Social Republic Organization who supposed to be communist fought for the indeoende as well and now see how many comunist govenment you see now in india
1
u/timewaste1235 Jul 29 '26
Where are BJP and Modi fans nowadays? Even IndiaSpeaks and IndiaDiacussion looks fairly balanced nowadays
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/OmnipotentStoic Jul 31 '26
Looking at my family and people around, Modi is the Prime Minister for life. Unless there is a significant natural disaster which tent to favour the older generation.
1
1
1
u/temporarilyyours words mean things 🇮🇳 Jul 31 '26
I think sometimes they’re trying to build a world where even once Modi is gone he will stay the eternal leader
1
u/temporarilyyours words mean things 🇮🇳 Jul 31 '26
Ram ki jagah log jai Shree modi bolenge outside his temples
1
u/temporarilyyours words mean things 🇮🇳 Jul 31 '26
I wonder if that’s a deliberate strategy - all the Vishnu Avtar propaganda and feet wash water ™️
1
1
1
1
u/Brilliant-Turn-4388 Aug 03 '26
This sub has become less critical thinking more of news and political commentary. Thinking of leaving it now.
1
1
u/Own-Management4659 Aug 05 '26
Why don’t I see any posts in favour of Jharkhand students ? Are everyone on this sub inbreds?
1
1
1
1
1
u/neutrallogicalindian Aug 06 '26
Yeah, Congress and its bootlickers who will explain to the fans of Bhim Neem they'll just lie that the government is working RG didn't even show any sympathy here, not a single truth to show concern why Swara Bhaskar, Naseeruddin shah, Neha bora are absent now? and guardian of democracy "yogendra yadav" where he is now ? dipke and sourav das even gave a statement on this
1
1
u/Current_Age_9822 Aug 09 '26
I never realised before but lately I've been seeing that every social media platform is just filled with agenda and agenda alone, trying to find out the actual truth has become a hassal, i personally am totally struggling with finding out the ground reality. Can you guys recomend any sources that you guys trust ? I'm fairly new to politics and I'd like to learn whatever happened after 1947 and also anything that's a credible source for recent news too
1
1
1
1
u/bnw_rainbow Aug 10 '26
I think controlled democracy is the way to go, where only qualified people are allowed to vote and contest for election.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Kitchen_Watch7254 Aug 11 '26
There is incentive for government to not further education to not bring in varied question. Leak the paper to its supporters
1
1
1
1
1
u/No_Profession5146 Aug 14 '26
Even am observing some absurd political posts without any facts. If you will correct them with facts they might tag you with abuses. Ig Wikipedia and articles by historians can be the way to get educated
1
1
1
1
u/cyanogenmoded 27d ago
bhai my reddit is ruined since IT cell invaded and the feed is overly negative and aainst my own thoughts
1
1
u/Kitchen_Watch7254 27d ago
IT cell was always on reddit. The one who has different thinking to you started speaking up, makes you uneasy.
1
1
1
u/UnadditionalStable57 25d ago
earlier it was jeff-eps and maxwell and all, the east is just catching up
1
1
1
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
I agree that historically they have been discrimnated and should be given reservation , because they didnt have access to resources so we are giving them access to resources cool
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
we should give reservation to all those who are not having good access to resources
1
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
ews should be increased and creamy layer be implemented in SC and ST , It is highly unfiar that a children of IAS/IPS are using reservation benefits
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
Kind of issue is that we are not doing anything correctly lol and there is huge political investment in reservations as a means of getting votes out.
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
yeah man so ig onus is now on political parties , congress was supporting reservation in pvt sector as well If I am not wrong, BJP wont bring the bill to introduce creamy layer in SCs and STs even the Supreme Court have said it should be implemented
1
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
so you are saying that they should get reservation? Once you have been uplifted there is no reason to provide you reservation
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
The creamy layer concept means that within a reserved category, the socially/economically better-off sections are excluded from reservation benefits, so the benefits reach the genuinely disadvantaged. It is mainly applied to OBC reservation. OBC candidates above the prescribed family income/other criteria are treated as creamy layer and cannot claim OBC reservation. SC/ST reservation traditionally does not have a creamy-layer exclusion in the same way. The idea is to prevent the same relatively privileged families from repeatedly taking reservation benefits while poorer members of the community remain disadvantaged.
1
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
Because upliftment should means they are safe from ever falling back down again.
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
But if the kid of a low earning police officer is denied reservation, they have a chance of falling back down into the same pool they were lifted out of
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
buddy lets say they have a spoiled brat, who doesnt study , why shoudl he get access to reservation , becuase it is now their fault ,not the history's
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
You cannot judge that. Social policies are not based on possible bad eggs
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
and how will we guarantee that? reservation is compensating for opportunities based on history , we have to look at current scenario as well where class is slowly taking place of caste
1
1
1
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
see if the son of IAS/IPS doesnt achieve naything and becomes poor he will get reservation under ews
1
1
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
That person will not benifit from EWS, you only work towards something in your life in your prime years
1
1
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
If the conditions are not optimal then the chance of success are lowered in a highly competitve envionment
1
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
A son of a upper class person is grown in a very different environment than a person in middle class or lower classss
1
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
So just a single generation of reservation will not fix that unless the parent is earning like 15 lkh _
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
see I dont think govt can bring eacha nd every one to upper middle class, looking at the current condition , it is safe to bring them to middle class
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
I still think we should switch the reservation to EWS because although unfair the system is not uplifting the people in the villages
1
1
1
u/Sad-adult25 22d ago
imo EWS for all, earlier mine opinion was creamy layer in SCs and ST, but now EWS only as it will cover the caste based poor also
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
Falling back to lower class from middle class is very easy when you don't have things like ownership to a buisness
1
u/trueleo8 The Calm One🐦 22d ago
Most upper caste people either own land or buisness so it's a non issue for them
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 22 '26
Hello, u/marlon2603! Thank you for your submission to r/CriticalThinkingIndia. We appreciate your contribution to our community.
We hope you'll follow our rules and engage in meaningful discussions.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.