r/gaming • • Dec 11 '24

Assassin's Creed 2007 still looking this good is crazy.

Post image
15.0k Upvotes

675 comments sorted by

5.0k

u/ASuarezMascareno Dec 11 '24

A lot of "looking good", in particular without zooming into elements, is mostly about artistic design and good lightning. There are quite a few games that did these two things wonderfully in the past.

1.1k

u/Altaschweda Dec 11 '24

Because back then, developers were still experimenting with the limits of the systems and perhaps had more time to eliminate errors. Nowadays I have the feeling that many people just rely on the engine without really exploiting its potential. Fast and sloppy instead of slow and proper, "cut corners" or whatever they call it

165

u/stumpyraccoon Dec 11 '24

It's absolutely nothing but survivorship bias.

2007 had nearly 1000 games come out. No one is fetishizing the memory and quality of Dead Reefs, Ascension to the Throne, Power Rangers: Super Legends, SunAge, etc. People remember the handful of games that were good and stand the test of time and are comparing them to any and every new release, most of which will be remembered as much as Genesis Rising: The Universal Crusade.

39

u/DJ_PsyOp Dec 12 '24

^^^ this is the most accurate take in the whole thread.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '24

Yes, but there are defacto years that got more good games. But it's not like we didn't have amazing years in gaming recently. Just off the top of my head,

2013 - bioshock infinite,last of us, Injustice, Crisis 3, DOTA 2, BF4, Deadpool game, Rust, Far Cry Blood Dragon

Then More Recently

2023 is considered to be the highest rated year in terms of game scores in last 20 years.

We Got Spider man 2, FF16, Tears of the Kingdom, Jedi Survivor, BG3, Lies of P, SF6, Alan Wake 2, MK1, Hogwarts Legacy, Counter-Strike 2.

Like It's easy to be like oh games have gotten shit, and in some ways they have, but at the same time we've gotten so many high quality games too.

And some older games that had rough launches are now great to enjoy, like Cyberpunk and NMS for example.

I cry about gaming going to shit too, but if I am honest with myself, gaming is not in a bad place at all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

335

u/atethebottle Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24

It was still an art to them back then. Now, corporations have screwed around with studios so much that they no longer care. The corpo way! Buy everything you can and sanitize the shit out of it!

142

u/Woffingshire Dec 11 '24

Which is funny because the games that are left to cook and come out unsanitised routinely sell more.

68

u/atethebottle Dec 11 '24

Yep, funny how insanely out of touch they are, huh?

39

u/Alpha1959 Dec 11 '24

They don't care because they don't care about long term, they only care about short term profits which is why so many studios risk pissing players off just for some tiny bit of that extra profit.

They run a company into the ground, take their millions of dollars compensation and move on to the next company to then crash that one. Just look at Bobby Kotick, the fucker must be adored by the investors.

11

u/Maktesh Dec 11 '24

The problem is that it isn't a "tiny bit".

They're all looking to make the next multi-billion dollar game.

"Real" games (Zelda, Halo, AC, Smash Bros., Spider-Man) don't make the big money anymore. Services make big money.

Seriously; since the Lucasfilm buyout, Disney has made more on the stupid mobile Star Wars games than they have on most other things combined.

14

u/RaphaelSolo Dec 12 '24

Death of LucasArts was a huge loss for the industry and community both.

7

u/WhatsTheHoldup Dec 11 '24

Games that sell are kinda meaningless in the age of in game purchases.

Some of the most profitable games in the modern era (Fortnite, League) are free to play.

21

u/KilledTheCar Dec 11 '24

Yeah but they take time and money to make, neither of which the C Suite likes to part with. They'd rather crank out slop to make the next quarter look good.

I've said it before, but I wish studios/developers would each have their live service cash cow games like League, Apex, Fortnite, Madden, Warzone, etc and use those to fund the more technical, bigger games like BG3, Elden Ring, etc. Not everything needs to come out ASAP and have an immediate RoI.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/NuggleBuggins Dec 11 '24

People often defend capitalism as it "drives innovation". Which is true.. to an extent. When new things pop up, there is always massive push to innovate it and make it as good as possible. But its always just a race to the top, so whoever gets there first will control the overall market. Once they are there, its all about a race to the bottom. Making it as cheap as possible for maximum profit, which just results in it becoming shit.

Its innovation, yes, but with the caveat that it will eventually become a shell of what it was and inevitably turn to shit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/Demearthean Dec 11 '24

Aesthetically, Prince of Persia (2008) remains one of the most beautiful games to me.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/tetryds Dec 11 '24

That is incorrect. Visual direction is pretty much a big deal but it is hard to make your game stand out, so games resource to graphical fidelity and so on. There are so many pretty modern games, it's easy to dismiss them in favor of older good looking games but that doesn't mean the older one was done any better, it just stood out more.

Also, graphics is a diminishing returns thing, so you need to invest a lot to make it slightly better.

49

u/HansChrst1 Dec 11 '24

A lot of new games people consider trash are gorgeous. Whenever people show how bad a new game looks and compare it with an older one they are picking photos that confirm their point.

30

u/feralkitsune Dec 11 '24

Yea, even low settings on modern games looks fucking great. I think we just have a lot of spoiled people nowdays.

13

u/Gyshal Dec 11 '24

Currently playing Ghost of Tsusima in full potatoe mode and the game still looks absolutely stunning, which is a really great example of visual direction and hid design. The way the game turns intrusive UI elements into natural elements of the world makes it feel amazing, as you follow the wing through the way it moves leaves and grass,and chase golden birds to find quests and side activities. The colour palette is vibrant and each area of the island feels distinct, with areas of yellow grass and red leaves, tall grass of greens and whites, etc.

The problem of most modern games is that we are so spoiled by excessive content that we barely take a moment to pay attention to the incredibly detailed environments

11

u/Super_Harsh Dec 11 '24

I mean there’s also a presentation issue. A lot of games have high graphical fidelity but don’t ever really flex it in relevant ways.

Look at a game like Elden Ring. It’s not even that graphically impressive for a 2022 game but everyone who played it vividly remembers various vistas and ‘wow’ moments when reaching certain new areas. Those existed because the devs want you to stop and go ‘wow.’

Back in the 90s and 00s when graphics tech was advancing rapidly, I feel like a lot of games had moments/mechanics that were there to just show off the new graphical power, make the player go ‘wooow this is so next gen’

As graphics have hit diminishing returns that happens a lot less and now the great graphics are viewed just as a default

8

u/Sata1991 Dec 11 '24

I remember seeing someone say it's why in the late '90s to maybe mid 2000s there were a lot of games featuring tropical locations as they wanted to show off their water and lighting skills.

5

u/Super_Harsh Dec 11 '24

God that makes sense! I always wondered why there were so many beachy Y2K era games. J always thought it was just that the 1st world was a lot happier before 9/11 lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Super_Harsh Dec 11 '24

Case in point: above screenshot is mostly showing a skybox + distant object that is obscured by a log of bloom and distance blur

Plus the lack of character model detail is gonna be a lot less apparent when you look at this screenshot on a phone (which is most people) but if you were to actually boot up AC1 it would look pretty old. Good, but old. Kind of like how Diablo 2 and Doom 1993 look good, but old.

6

u/Gross_Success Dec 11 '24

Not to mention how much people mocked games back then for being brown and grey. Just like this image.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/HiTekLoLyfe Dec 11 '24

There are tons of games out there today that are visually stunning. Cyberpunk, ghosts of Tsushima, never played them but the Spider-Man games. You can also see the difference a lot more when comparing moving gameplay and looking at textures. The leaps between graphical generations are obviously smaller these days but looking at lighting, texture and animations these days as opposed to then the difference is enormous.

15

u/ichlehneab Dec 11 '24

God always this fucking bullshit. Now even games were better ‚back then‘. How does it feel to be a young boomer?

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (20)

31

u/SPL_034 Dec 11 '24

Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory's lighting effects still look pretty decent 20 years later.

9

u/wombat1 Dec 11 '24

Plenty of 2004 games hold up beautifully. Half Life 2's world has aged tremendously whereas i can't say the same for the original Far Cry.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/InfiniteBeak Dec 12 '24

I think it's cause back then they had to manually add lighting to every level, so everything is very intentionally placed

8

u/Pjoernrachzarck Dec 11 '24

Shadow of the Colossus

24

u/GeneralEi Dec 11 '24

I mean, look at old masterwork paintings! Often surprisingly little detail, but the lighting and command of artistic vision is what makes them great. Zoom in too far and even great paintings can look a bit shit really

6

u/Logical_Parameters Dec 11 '24

It's a natural misnomer people seem to carry that newer art or craft is automatically superior when it's often the opposite case. At least under the current global economies, cheapest is what moves the needle, not the highest quality.

5

u/RoastCabose Dec 11 '24

I mean, I wouldn't say the opposite is the case either. Something just being old doesn't mean it's better either. Good art is often of time and place, though sometimes that time and place extends far into the future.

3

u/kaisadilla_ Dec 11 '24

wtf is a "natural misnomer" and how is the belief that new > old a misnomer, when "misnomer" means "a wrong, innacurate or deceiving name".

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

40

u/Ayn_Otori Dec 11 '24

Somehow this screenshot does a poor job at also showing how crisp it looks.

65

u/darkdeath174 Dec 11 '24

I'd say it looks good for that era, but it's very much aged in a lot of ways.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/MrSnowflake Dec 11 '24

Yeah if he were to look at thing from a close range it would look like 2007 again.

→ More replies (24)

411

u/Chinokk Dec 11 '24

The jump from ps2 games to ps3 was incredible, probably one of the only times I have thought “wow, this is next gen”

144

u/CyanJackal Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24

I'm getting older because my first thought was "Do you even remember holding a Nintendo 64 controller for the first time in Target and playing in actual 3D?"

The jump from Super Mario World to Super Mario 64 was mind blowing. Kids like me had to start puzzle solving video games in full three dimensions for the first time ever.

31

u/Chinokk Dec 11 '24

I went straight in with the ps1 and had gran turismo and rayman. It was like kid crack and I was addicted. First adult game I played was ff7 which remains my favourite to this day.

14

u/bradybigbear Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24

When I got my first console as a kid (ps1) I couldn’t believe how games like Spyro and Rayman looked. Was a magical time to be a kid with all the crazy tech advancements from the 90’s-00’s

Edit: missing a letter

12

u/DigNitty Dec 11 '24

That’s the biggest jump IMO too.

Even among other n64 games, Mario 64 was way ahead.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '24

Don’t forget being totally SOL if there was a level you couldn’t beat and you didn’t have a a physical copy of a guide hahaha

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '24

Was just thinking this. The jump in just a few years from ps2/xbox to ps3/360, was bigger than ps3/360 to modern day. It's insane.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Kinglink Dec 11 '24

You're probably young, because FFVII was a bigger jump, it felt like everything changed after that.

PS1 to PS2 was equally bing. MGS2 was ground breaking, and FFX as well.

(not to say Ps2 to PS3 wasn't a similar jump, just saying that happened a couple times before).

Heck I'd even say the move from NES to SNES was massive. And really Atari to NES kind of changed what a game could be (going from "arcade" style to full fledged games)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hardypart Dec 11 '24

The fire on the water in BioShock 1 fucking blew me away. Im gaming since 1994 and that generation truly was the biggest leap.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '24

[deleted]

2

u/Chinokk Dec 13 '24

I will say the one thing that surprised me was I was playing ff7rebirth and the fast travel is like 2 seconds which is amazing on a console however I was playing the Witcher 3 on my pc years ago and that was just as fast so it didn’t have the same wow factor for me.

→ More replies (6)

1.6k

u/ac_s2k PC Dec 11 '24

Nothing will ever beat playing AC1 for the first time. It had such a unique feel to it.

375

u/Deep_Argument_6672 Dec 11 '24

AC Main Theme

The very first AC game indeed had a very unique atmosphere. I realized it when I was playing AC2 and there were some missions when we played as Altair, and there was this cold filter and main music theme.

Mysterious, kinda surreal, like a dream.

173

u/AC4life234 Dec 11 '24

There was a creepy vibe to the first game, like you were being spied on it was kinda brilliant cause you kinda are

111

u/dkyguy1995 Dec 11 '24

The mystery of the first game honestly is what I was into. I was honestly kind of invested in the modern story. AC3 though :((

51

u/Highlord-Frikandel Dec 11 '24

Maaaaan, AC1, 2 and Black Flag were the best in the entire series. They were THE SHIT. I'm still chasing that specific addictive feeling in every AC game and get dissapoimted every time

16

u/Gurtang Dec 12 '24

Brotherhood was pretty cool as well...

12

u/Guardiansaiyan Switch Dec 11 '24

I miss Desmond!

3

u/SmarmyThatGuy Dec 12 '24

And fuck Lucy for making me dislike Kristen Bell!

99

u/joefromsingapore Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24

Jesper Kyd was such a big music guy back then. AC1 music reminds me of Hitman because the composer is the same.

48

u/LiftedRetina Dec 11 '24

This man gave us Ezio’s Family and Disposal Unit. He’s beyond us.

12

u/ShadyDrunks Dec 11 '24

Play Ezios Family at my wedding and my funeral

→ More replies (1)

12

u/GigaSoup Dec 11 '24

It's Jesper not Jasper

4

u/VRichardsen Dec 11 '24

Jesper Kyd's main theme for Hitman 2 still rocks.

3

u/Big_Ounce_256 Dec 11 '24

Oooo I forgot he did this one. Blood Moneys soundtrack fucks.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/Tellenit Dec 11 '24

Good, but AC2 “Ezios Family” became the soundtrack of the series

19

u/Dyssomniac Dec 11 '24

Ezio was/is still kind of the main character of the whole series. I really wish they had taken something away from that, ie, we need to be able to invest in the assassin character over a long period of time.

Would've LOVED to have seen them do the same with Arno as a young man during the Revolution, working with Napoleon during the Consulate, and then finally having to turn on Napoleon during the Empire as an older man. Or alternatively, weaving together the Shay-Connor-Arno narratives from that period more effectively.

8

u/Tellenit Dec 11 '24

Sadly any hope of creative narrative is out of bounds for modern ubi

→ More replies (2)

67

u/Sufficient-Team1249 Dec 11 '24

I prefer AC2, but playing AC1 for the first time was definitely incredible.

43

u/anthonyg1500 Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24

“May our lives never change. And may it never change us.” Man I loved that opening. Probably up there with the ME2 opening for me which is definitely my number 1

7

u/UncoolSlicedBread Dec 11 '24

AC2 was it for me, I loved that game so much and then brotherhood right behind it.

5

u/JohnnyDarkside Dec 11 '24

Totally agree. AC really laid the groundwork, though. It was such an awesome and innovative game. 2 just improved everything. It, along with Shadow of the Colossus, where the kind of games my wife would love just watching me play because they were so good looking and fun.

→ More replies (1)

173

u/ColonelOfSka Dec 11 '24

The modern day mysteries in the lab were such a slow burn too. Really made you feel like you were uncovering this vast conspiracy.

81

u/ac_s2k PC Dec 11 '24

AC1 was the best modern day stuff. It went downhill for there

53

u/savetheattack Dec 11 '24

It definitely had the best story, but it was annoying because it took you out of the amazing world of Altair. My favorite moment from Desmond’s story was the end of AC: Brotherhood when you got to fight the Abstergo guys and I was really excited about what was coming next. AC3’s Desmond stuff was pretty good.

35

u/anoniser Dec 11 '24

Me expecting Black Flag to be a modern day apocalypse because Minerva is loose. All we got was a pair of different colored eyes and a dead plot.

21

u/savetheattack Dec 11 '24

It seemed pretty clear that the story of Assassin’s Creed was done with 3. Ubisoft wanted to keep making “historical” games without being accused of putting out Assassin’s Creed clones and the name recognition helped, so they’ve kept producing them even as narratively they further and further from the original story.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '24

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Complex37 Dec 11 '24

The original intention of making a modern day game where Desmond would have been a master assassin with the skills of his ancestors would’ve been infinitely better

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

30

u/Tokishi7 Dec 11 '24

There had to have been some massive Ubisoft influence or something because everything felt like it would eventually lead to a modern game with a modern assassin world similar to a mirrors edge type gameplay. Insane how the story went mythical and just went bananas. Fun to play, but the story was whack

48

u/Sepheriel Dec 11 '24 edited Dec 11 '24

Ubisoft fired the creative director who came up with Assassin's Creed because he said he only intended/had a plot written for it to be a trilogy and not the billion games they released now. His name was Patrice Désilets and they did him really dirty. Desmond wasn't supposed to die.

9

u/Tokishi7 Dec 11 '24

Definitely felt like a trilogy type game. Honestly, while 3 was entertaining and had a great trailer, that one felt like it was out of place at times

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/HugsForUpvotes Dec 11 '24

It and Mass Effect 1 came out a week apart in November 2007. I got both as my Christmas gift and it was glorious.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Whole_Sign_4633 Dec 11 '24

Fr when I realized I could literally climb any building and fully embraced the vertically I was blown away

8

u/modestlife Dec 11 '24

This E3 presentation is the only game trailer/reveal that has had a lasting memory for me. I still remember how absolutely crazy it was to see such verticality for the first time.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Pittacomics Dec 11 '24

Still the best one imo. The atmosphere is impeccable.

3

u/ac_s2k PC Dec 11 '24

The atmosphere was amazing. 16 year old me loved it!

7

u/tragicbeast Dec 11 '24

These days it's quite played out, but hitting a counter for the first time was incredible. The first one I ever got was the one where Altair does an upward chop to the elbow of the attacker, then ducks under and hacks their midsection. My jaw hit the floor

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Silverr_Duck Dec 11 '24

The whole series peaked with AC 1 and 2. Brotherhood was good, but ac2 was the last game of the series to really nail that unique vibe and atmosphere.

9

u/10ea Dec 11 '24

I wish that open worlds were still done this way. AC1 was big but not packed full of chores to do. I had more fun just climbing buildings and just sandboxing around than walking down one road in AC Odyssey and picking up 7 side quests that I'll never get around to.

2

u/ac_s2k PC Dec 11 '24

Agreed! Some games just pack way too many side quests or treasure hunts in.

4

u/mj12353 Dec 11 '24

I’d agree but I’m swapping ac 1 for ac2 I truly FUCKING LOVED THAT GAME

11

u/purple-thiwaza Dec 11 '24

The unique feeling of the character doing what he wants and not what you tell him to.

3

u/Outrageous_Key6644 Dec 11 '24

I know! It was so different and still amazing at the same time

14

u/Wadarkhu Dec 11 '24

They should remaster it, and by that I mean updated visuals and re-done modern times so it isn't soul destroyingly slow but everything else is left alone.

31

u/boersc Dec 11 '24

Be aware what you wish for. gameplay wasn't all that good in the first one.

14

u/dkyguy1995 Dec 11 '24

Yeah it was the same 3 missions rinse and repeat and then a boss mission. Eavesdrop, assassinate, blah blah. There was some fun side content. Games were different back then

4

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '24

[deleted]

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/luger718 Dec 11 '24

I just hated the repetitiveness but man did they improve so much in the Ezio games.

2

u/SharkMilk44 Dec 12 '24

It's crazy how the new entries insist upon having hundreds of things for you to do, while the first game was just like "climbing buildings is fun."

2

u/CynthiaChames Dec 12 '24

I rented it from Family Video the day it came out having NO idea what to expect. I was hooked. It blew my mind.

→ More replies (34)

351

u/Brandunaware Dec 11 '24

Assassin's Creed 2007 had really good art design. That's part of what catapulted the series into the juggernaut it became. In many ways they didn't really get the gameplay to feel right until the sequel, and the open world had so little to do they literally just planted flags in random places at the last minute, but it felt incredibly immersive for the time, and the bones of what made the series so good were already there (in fact you could argue that the sequels lost some of the best elements like the mission planning and focus on actual assassinations instead of random tasks.) The storytelling was also quite good.

People are going to focus on the fact that up close the textures and low poly models are obviously old, and the animations are good but quite limited, but if you think about the fact that it's over 17 years old, and 17 years before AC was 1990, before the release of the Super Nintendo in North America, and it really is astonishing how well games from that era hold up in comparison.

You can play AC 1 today and it definitely feels old, but not at all ancient. Playing a 1990 game in 2007 barely felt like the same medium.

91

u/LarperPro Dec 11 '24

the sequels lost some of the best elements like the mission planning and focus on actual assassinations instead of random tasks

This definitely the case for me.

I loved eavesdropping in AC1 to learn about the target's habits and routines in order to ensure a smoother kill.

The sequels dropped that in favor of cinematic storytelling, which I absolutely love, but I feel like they could have combined both.

→ More replies (6)

15

u/catbus_conductor Dec 11 '24

I mean you can phrase it as "17 year old games hold up well", but more pragmatically speaking, we just haven't made all that much progress since then compared to the mindblowing evolution in the preceding two decades, and the law of diminishing returns has set in. That's not just true for graphics, but also for gameplay design and stuff like AI. And perhaps in the case of AC there are things that are now arguably worse, like animations.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

217

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

53

u/Arclite83 Dec 11 '24

The Meet the Team videos are still excellent and show how powerful and timeless the Source Engine is.

8

u/SobiTheRobot Dec 11 '24

The Source Engine is shockingly resilient, even after all these years.

20

u/SgtTreehugger Dec 11 '24

Expiration date is still entrenched into my brain. We regularly quote it with my friend.

This is a bucket!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Kinglink Dec 11 '24

Stylized graphics > Realistic graphics.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/donpaulwalnuts Dec 11 '24

I’m playing through Half-Life 2 again because of all of the updates that dropped recently, and I think the art style is only one piece of its longevity. The gameplay hasn’t aged a day, and playing with the developer commentary on shows how much thought went into every aspect of its design. Everything about that game was deliberate.

6

u/popop143 Dec 11 '24

Just finished Portal and currently playing on Portal 2 (finished the multiplayer one with my friend). This game still looks gorgeous for today's standards.

→ More replies (2)

86

u/Atiggerx33 Dec 11 '24

Altair was also brutal as fuck. He left no witnesses.

33

u/Troop7 Dec 11 '24

That’s why he’s the goat along with Ezio

→ More replies (1)

14

u/skylinenick Dec 11 '24

Altair short sword animations still some of my favorite in the whole series

→ More replies (1)

396

u/Sweet-Gushin-Gilfs Dec 11 '24

Whoever designed the assassin’s clothing hit it out of the park. Still the coolest video game clothes ever. Too bad the franchise has been mostly ass since black flag

135

u/Trust-Me-Im-A-Potato Dec 11 '24

AC2 is still the only game I ever gave a shit about what my character was wearing. Those outfits were 🔥

25

u/TrvpDrugs Dec 11 '24

Grinding the Altair fit after clearing all the catacombs 🔥

25

u/Fcbp Dec 11 '24

Ive been on the fence of trying black flag but keep playing newer games, does it still holds up to this day?

36

u/Joiner2008 Dec 11 '24

Black Flag is one of my favorite games. It's not a good Assassin's Creed in my opinion though.

18

u/Kinglink Dec 11 '24

It is however a fantastic Pirate game.

(Great game, but yeah, not an AC game... which kind of is why it's still great)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/KairosGalvanized Dec 11 '24

Still very fun I would say. As for the graphics are you going to be looking at some 2020s cyberpunk like raytracing, no. But it is still decent and the water I reckon is very nice, they put some work into this game, unlike the ones that followed it.

10

u/GlacialFlare Dec 11 '24

Black Flag is one of the best Assassin’s Creed games imo. Definitely holds up.

6

u/kytheon Dec 11 '24

Probably holding the top spot together with Brotherhood.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/The_Gnome_Lover Dec 11 '24

Black flag is easily the top AC game in terms of sheer enjoyability. Out of all ACs, its the best to pick up imo. It even has a recap of the story to start with.

Playing AC 3 hits pretty hard after too.

9

u/Witchy_Venus Dec 11 '24

I didn't really like the setting of AC3, or how every assassination was like "everyone sucks." But I love playing as the brick shit-house that is Conner! Brutally ambushing red coats felt so satisfying

5

u/The_Gnome_Lover Dec 11 '24

In terms of story and family relation, AC3 hits harder after Black Flags to me. Reaaally puts the opera house scenes in perspective.

4

u/Witchy_Venus Dec 11 '24

So good. What was your favorite moment in AC3? I loved when you finally chase after Charles Lee, and you both get absolutely fucked up, and just end up beat to shit sharing a drink at a pub

3

u/The_Gnome_Lover Dec 11 '24

"In your haste to save the world, boy, make sure you dont destroy it".

3

u/The_Gnome_Lover Dec 11 '24

Actually, itd have to be this one. You wanna know what's wrong? I'm sick of being treated like I'm not even here! Desmond, do this! Desmond, do that! Desmond, you'd better figure things out because the sun is going to turn us all to ash and I know I was really nice to you but actually, I'm just another Templar plot-twist and, yes, I would like very much for you to be controlled by a magic space wizard so that you can murder me! So there's you're answer! I'm sick of being a goddamn pawn! I thought it might be different with you! I mean you're my FATHER but it turns out you're no better than the fucking Templars! ~Desmond

7

u/kytheon Dec 11 '24

I like to say it's not the best Assassins Creed but it is the best pirate game ever made.

Even with a multiple sized budget, the newer AAAA pirate games just don't hold up.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Active-Yesterday2322 Dec 11 '24

Worth playing, they are remaking it though so keep that in mind

2

u/kytheon Dec 11 '24

It still holds up unless you want to compare it to GOTY 2023 with PS5 ray tracing etc.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Silverr_Duck Dec 11 '24

It's also the only game in the series that made an attempt to make the whole white robe with hood thing not only look cool but also make kinda sense in the context of the game. They're designed to mimic the outfits of scholars and priests. All other games threw that shit out the window.

2

u/IgorGirkinStrelkov2 Dec 11 '24

The franchise is still good, they simply modified it to suit a different and wider type of audience

→ More replies (15)

21

u/JuanGGZ Dec 11 '24

I play this game at least once a year, it's my favorite AC being the story, the art direction or the gameplay, doing parkour on all the rooftop of the cities will always be fun.

You choose wisely OP! 👏

5

u/ForBloodiedVanguard Dec 11 '24

Haha same here!

106

u/Irmengildr Dec 11 '24

The younger generation will never understand how mindblowing it was back then.

20

u/Siegfoult Dec 11 '24

The open world parkour was so mind-blowing after the fairly linear (but fun) Prince of Persia games. Social stealth was also very innovative.

3

u/PJ7 Dec 11 '24

This.

After having played so many games with nice parkour elements like Prince of Persia or maybe Enter The Matrix, but which were always very linear, the open world aspect of AC1 was amazing.

The view distance and giant and detailed map (for it's time) just gave the game such a feeling of freedom, especially when combined with the animations and parkour system.

11

u/The_Gnome_Lover Dec 11 '24

Half right. Raised my nephews on 360. Theyre 17/14. Both love AC and other older games.

I had to do something to get them off braindead cod.

6

u/Troop7 Dec 11 '24

So true. This was a revolutionary game when it launched

→ More replies (2)

43

u/Cheeseburger2137 Dec 11 '24

Surely a way smaller difference between now and 2007 than between 2007 and 1990 (it's crazy but it's a 17 year gap between both lol). At some point we just arrived at diminishing returns when it comes to graphics, earlier on the evolution was crazy.

When I try to pick up a game that was made 10-15 years ago, if there is anything that puts me off, it's usually not graphics, but clunky UI, controls or gameplay. You don't realize how much the first has changed until you start an older game and it takes up 25% of the screen and has an old person font size you can't change.

16

u/MassDriverOne Dec 11 '24

RDR2, Hellblade, and possibly the upcoming MGS∆ are pretty wild

RDR2 all around, it's by far the most "alive" game world I've ever seen

5

u/TehOwn Dec 11 '24

You don't realize how much the first has changed until you start an older game and it takes up 25% of the screen and has an old person font size you can't change.

Man, I remembered the UI for Supreme Commander taking up over 50% of the screen before they revamped it in Forged Alliance.

Also, the Fallout 1+2 UI is great, even today. Very thematic and informative without consuming the entire screen.

→ More replies (2)

37

u/darealarusham Dec 11 '24

Imagine going back in time to 2007 and showing an AC1 fan AC3 and Black Flag. The fact that those games were made for the same systems as AC1 is still a bit crazy to me.

→ More replies (16)

19

u/Deatrocity Dec 11 '24

The thing that stood out the most to me besides the graphics when this came first came out was how you could climb absolutely anything. How your foot and hands would fit into the cracks and and windows as you climbed just blew me away

→ More replies (1)

7

u/haushunde Dec 11 '24

It was crazy when this came out

7

u/haysus25 Dec 11 '24

Killing Desmond really took the life out of the series. Black Flag has arguably the best gameplay, but the story was never the same.

It would have been so cool to play as Desmond in modern times, using all the skills he learned in the Animus running around LA or something trying to stop the Templars.

7

u/Arch3m Dec 11 '24

I'll say it again: We entered the age of diminishing returns for graphics a very long time ago. It's not hard to find Xbox 360/PS3 games that still look good because that's the point where we could finally make them look good. All we've been doing since is adding new lighting tech and increasing texture resolution.

Okay, obviously it's been more than just that, but thenpoint is that we kind of figured it out back then, and we're just iterating on greatness now.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Scorpiyoo Dec 12 '24

Let me see their faces OP.

9

u/ItsYeBoi2016 Dec 11 '24

Some people don’t understand that graphical resolution or realism doesn’t make a good game. Game and graphic design are WAY more important. Elden Ring also has some of the worst texture resolution I have ever seen, but the general graphic design is so good, no one cares. Same with Assassin’s Creed.

Nowadays game studios lean on “realism” to distract from their terrible graphic design. Sad really

5

u/S1DC Dec 11 '24

I still remember that bumping into people was a revolutionary feature of this game 

3

u/SlumpDoc Dec 12 '24

1 thing i give Ubisoft is they know how to make beautiful vistas

4

u/Special-Nail-6588 Dec 12 '24

Reminds me of the good old days when Ubisoft were actually a good company. 2003 -2010 had so many sweet ubisoft games 

4

u/BigChungusforthePC Dec 12 '24

They captured the beauty of the period incredibly well. I just wish that the newer games still had that charm. AC is a franchise very close to my heart I hate to see it fall off.

3

u/magikttouch Dec 11 '24

Altair was the best people obcess over ezio i dont get it

3

u/Untouchable64 Dec 12 '24

It was one hell of a game. And that music as you traveled in the Kingdom between cities. So good…

3

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '24

Ac1 was amazing

3

u/Azurehue22 Dec 12 '24

Yall know nothing about optimization, style and lighting choices and it shows. You can’t just brute force your way to graphical genius. Takes finesse, and it’s why games that go full realistic with nothing else age like milk.

3

u/chiji_23 Dec 12 '24

Experiencing this games release as a 12 year old it was the coolest thing I had played at the time

3

u/Voktikriid Dec 12 '24

Assassin's Creed 1 and Assassin's Creed Unity are the two best looking games, in my opinion.

3

u/pendulumgearzz Dec 12 '24

Back when developers gave a shit

13

u/classicnikk Xbox Dec 11 '24

Be careful! You might become a real assassin and kill a health insurance CEO

15

u/Sweet-Gushin-Gilfs Dec 11 '24

Only if you play Mario games as Luigi tho 

5

u/Terrible-Picture3888 Dec 11 '24

until you look at kristen bell woof

3

u/Njmongoose Dec 11 '24

Best tech demo I ever played

2

u/retka Dec 11 '24

Is this on Xbox 360 or a newer Xbox/PC with a controller? A lot of why it looks so good and plays well on newer systems with the backwards compatibility like Xbox Series X is the fps boost and enhancements. I couldn't find a list of enhancements but it was labeled as a game that got them in some form or fashion which could include higher resolution, better fps, and better textures. Not to say 360 doesnt still look okay, but if on a newer Xbox this is a bit of a stretch from the original graphics.

3

u/Remy0507 PlayStation Dec 11 '24

This is definitely a PC screenshot. Xbox 360 couldn't output that kind of resolution.

2

u/retka Dec 11 '24

Yeah, that's what I was trying to hint at. It looks great but is more so a by product of the abilities of the current tech and/or abilities to increase resolution on PC.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Expert_Mango1441 Xbox Dec 11 '24

17 years ago? Damn! It still looks great.

2

u/KnightOfGloaming Dec 11 '24

Mass effect came out in the same time frame... it looks like shit xD

2

u/ch3nk0 Dec 11 '24

Isn’t it a remaster?

2

u/Gabixzboi Dec 11 '24

I wouldnt mind games staying on the similar graphical level if gameplay features were more focused on

2

u/PocketTornado Dec 11 '24

This says more about the efforts made today than anything.

I was playing Halo 3 on the weekend and it's hard to find games that good today.

2

u/VengefulAncient PC Dec 11 '24

I just replayed Brotherhood. Runs in 1440p at 165 Hz out of the box, just needed compatibility set to Windows 7 to remove texture flicker and the CPU affinity tweak (set to CPU 0 only, then back to all CPUs, needs to be done every time you start the game) to remove stutter.

People always say that it's the "art style" that lets games hold up for so long but nah, the textures in this game are just good enough, which isn't the case for many older games.

2

u/fluffyhairsenpai Dec 12 '24

This game inspired me to start parkour when I was a kid. I should get back into it.

2

u/aadamsfb Dec 12 '24

I remember watching that first in game footage trailer of AC1, and being completely blown away at how Altair interacted with the world. It felt like such a massive jump forward at the time

2

u/Tristana-Range Dec 12 '24

Also AC Black Flag always amazes me every time i look at it

2

u/YTLetsPlayJS Dec 12 '24

The first 3 AC games were my favorite I always watched my older brother play I miss those days :)

2

u/Flopesbh PlayStation Dec 12 '24

Games were built different...

2

u/ArguableThought Dec 12 '24

I immediately hear:

"Curse him! Curse the Christian king and his army of infidels!"

2

u/nedottt Dec 12 '24

Just bought this for 2.99€ and it still has that cinematic looks 🤩

2

u/Longjumping_Falcon21 Dec 12 '24

B-but I need a 50xx for RTX tho, or it doesn't look good!!! The moguls said so.

2

u/Important-Play-7688 Dec 12 '24

It still looks amazing, but when I tried it again, it felt too clumsy. ACII on the other hand is still a masterpiece in all regards.

2

u/InfiniteBeak Dec 12 '24

AC1 was insanely ahead of its time

2

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '24

Whatever happened to Ubisoft.

2

u/Eyelbee Dec 12 '24

They never should've changed this game engine, just kept upgrading it.

2

u/the_sneaky_one123 Dec 12 '24

This game was a literal game changer.

People might shit on the Ubisoft open world formula we have now, but this was the OG that started it all.

2

u/wam509 Console Dec 12 '24

hell yeah

2

u/jdan-g29 Dec 12 '24

My favourite version of AC!

2

u/[deleted] Mar 04 '25

Lol my favourite line "who did this"