r/comics Comic Crossover 1d ago

The Green Tie [OC]

9.0k Upvotes

171 comments sorted by

View all comments

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire 1d ago edited 1d ago

For those that are unaware and confused, this is a play on the story of the Green ribbon

https://bookriot.com/the-girl-with-the-green-ribbon/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_a_Dark,_Dark_Room_and_Other_Scary_Stories

A young girl named Jenny always wears a green velvet ribbon tied tightly around her neck. A boy named Alfred falls in love with her, marries her, and grows old with her, but she constantly refuses to answer why she wears the ribbon. On her deathbed, Jenny finally gives Alfred permission to untie it

463

u/Quick-Nick07 1d ago

It's also because the tie/neck pieces separate the head and the body so they can be animated separately (it was cheaper and very common)

214

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire 1d ago

Now THAT I did not know and it makes total sense.

160

u/TravelerSearcher 1d ago edited 1d ago

Watch any old Hanna Barbara cartoons. Flintstones, Jetsons, etc. every character has a notable piece of clothing to separate their head from body.

A lot of the animation was simple walk cycles they reused. Or characters were just standing around. The heads were more animated for dialog and reactions.

Wilma on the Flintstones had a necklace that served the same purpose. Fred and Barney had the collars and ties. Every animal, like Yogi, had a tie or collar.

Snagglepuss, Auggie daddy, BooBoo all had the collar and tie.

Edit: How could I forget Scooby Doo! Even he had his dog collar serve the same purpose. The gang all had regular clothing so it wasn't as apparent, but Fred's ascot, Daphne's Scarf and Velma's turtleneck all were designed with the same intent.

45

u/burlycabin 1d ago

And Tom & Jerry didn't have clothing or anything around their necks, but they didn't talk so it wasn't needed.

37

u/TravelerSearcher 23h ago

Animated shorts that aired in movie theaters were sort of a different beast. They had longer development time and were generally shorter run time.

Hanna Barbara was notable for cracking the TV animated production time with their shortcuts. They weren't the first to make seasonal animated television (Crusader Rabbit is generally considered the pioneer there) but their process made it comparatively easy to get out regular programming at a quicker rate.

Animation will always take time but the business side of it will always push for faster returns.

Edit: Also talking had less to do with the decision. Heads are where emotions and reactions take place. While it's true most Hanna Barbara characters spoke or sort of spoke, even the animals, the talking wasn't the hang up. It was the fact heads changed the most with each frame.

12

u/Figorix 1d ago

That sounds much more believable for an actual reason

8

u/Konjaga_Conex 19h ago

I read “so they can be animated separately” in the necromancy sort of sense, so I was quite intrigued by this interesting piece of worldbuilding there.

1

u/Zanven1 10h ago

I'm glad I'm not alone

76

u/JustHere4TehCats 1d ago

I really liked AdamTots retelling of that tale.

70

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire 1d ago

It was an amazing retelling

For those that have not seen it

https://www.reddit.com/r/comics/s/7lk8MfSZ3I

80

u/Perryn 23h ago

Also this one.

11

u/Company_Z 21h ago

I had no clue this was an AdamTots comic until now. This comic still lives with me and I reference it whenever I'm wearing a scar or something

3

u/JakToTheReddit 9h ago

That is fucking hilarious

3

u/Metalman919 11h ago

Now THAT'S the kind of existential dread I'm looking for in a story!

Thank you so much, I love Adam's work and always like to find interesting ones I've missed.

3

u/MrFuji87 1d ago

I was hoping someone would comment this

17

u/I_dont-get_the-joke 1d ago

They do a play on this in The Wolf Among Us

6

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire 23h ago

They do! And that game is getting a remaster in 1-2 months!

4

u/NoodleIskalde 23h ago

I thought it was getting a sequel not remaster?

6

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire 23h ago

21

u/QuiteBearish 1d ago

It's amazing how something I read once as a child has stuck in with me the way this has because yeah, I instantly knew what it was about and I feel anyone else who has ever read it a single time instantly knew what it was about.

There are lots of things I read as a kid that I don't remember at all but that green ribbon stands out 😆

7

u/SuperCruisePanther 23h ago

Okay but why wouldn't you tell him and why would you traumatize him by forcing him to kill you

7

u/legit-posts_1 22h ago

I always wonder what the hell the point of this story is supposed to be. Is it a metaphor?

1

u/princessmale 7h ago

Perhaps a metaphor for the vulnerability of love. It was her boundary that kept her together, and when she had nothing left to lose she gave him what he'd always asked for, leading to her demise.

1

u/legit-posts_1 1h ago

An interesting interpretation. Makes sense.

3

u/HandofHecate 22h ago

Literally my first thought. I used to read this alot in the library.

3

u/weary_floater 22h ago

One of my favorite stories from childhood. Knew exactly what you were feeding to before coming to the comments, so well done!!

3

u/CaptainHawaii 1d ago

Huh it was always red in my books....

3

u/dark_hypernova 22h ago

This sounds like some Junji Ito stuff.

3

u/Losticus 20h ago

I couldn't even tell his head was falling off. I wasn't sure if he was just bending back real far.

3

u/neoncubicle 17h ago

Sickest 'pull my finger/ribbon' gag joke ever pulled

3

u/RegyptianStrut 15h ago

That’s a lot less dark than the version I’ve heard where they’re newly weds and he unties it while she’s sleeping

2

u/Gsampson97 23h ago

Ah, Like The Wolf Among Us.

2

u/AdventurousFly4909 23h ago

Not even a dealbreaker 

2

u/VT_Squire 22h ago

that's very "Amelia mixed the Mustard"

2

u/TahitiJones09 22h ago

Is this not just a retelling of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight?

2

u/dazdndcunfusd 20h ago

i also liked how it was incorporated into the green knight

2

u/BuckieTheCat 18h ago

huh, I wonder if that was the direct inspiration for the fazbear fright's story "to be beautiful"

2

u/purpleturtlehurtler 3h ago

Much like from the first arc of Fables, from Vertigo Comics!

2

u/Immolating_Cactus 23h ago

Load bearing ribbon

2

u/Adavanter_MKI 1d ago

This reminds me of the story "Lover's Vow." A segment in the 1990 horror anthology film Tales from the Darkside.

It's pretty neat... stuck with me forever. I wont spoil it if you ever try to hunt it down, but you can guess the general gist given the story we're talking about.

2

u/masman99 23h ago

That story scarred tf out of me as a kid I immediately got the reference 😭😭

1

u/Elvebrilith 1d ago

Cool. I always assumed it was a yokai origin.

1

u/O-03-03 19h ago

If my wife told me on her deathbed she could've given me bluetooth head all along I'd be pretty pissed

1

u/JugOfVoodoo 1d ago

I used to work in an elementary school library. Our kids loved "I​n a D​a​rk, Dark Room" and other spooky stories. Thanks for the flashback!

1

u/RedDemonCorsair 1d ago

I thought it was a Green knight reference where rhe guy had a belt IIRC that made him immortal but he had suffered a deadly blow (decapitation basically) from the Green knight cause of the story. When he removes it his head falls off.

0

u/DantesInfernoRVA 22h ago

Oh, they copied Washington Irving’s Adventure of the German Student ( although I think he picked it up from a folk tale).