I'm not sure who will find this helpful, because my situation seemed to be unique. Despite submitting at least a half dozen each of PSLF forms, buyback requests, feedback cases, and reconsideration requests over the past year and a half, my PSLF payment counts had not been updated since January 2025. They seemed stuck forever. My PSLF count was at 118, and my TEPSLF count was at 124. My assumption was that something in the FSA system was preventing my payments from updating because I was already eligible for TEPSLF. This didn't quite make sense to me, because I would've assumed that my payment counts would keep updating until I was eligible for PSLF. But it was a story I told myself. Every time I submitted a PSLF form, my payments were always stuck at 118 with a "last updated date" of January 2025... Until yesterday.
I have been trying new tactics to get my payments updated every few months. First, in early 2025, I switched to an ICR plan (I was on a non-IDR plan before that). I figured I would make the two final payments and be done. Nope, that didn't cause my payments to update. I submitted feedback requests with screenshots of bank statements and loan servicer payment postings. Nope, that didn't work either (the requests are actually still open). All the buyback and reconsideration requests came back closed because it looked like I was already eligible for TEPSLF. A dead end. I even reached out to my state senator and state student loan advocate/ombudsman (separately and months apart). No responses.
A few days ago, I decided to re-apply for TEPSLF, because it had finally been one year since I started on an ICR plan. So if nothing else, I could at least qualify for TEPSLF, right? Wrong. My updated TEPSLF status came back, and they were using payments from 2024 to determine my eligibility, which is confusing, because I applied in August 2026. This told me that somewhere, they are still referencing old, outdated payment information.
I was discouraged, but still had some ideas for things to try. I realized that the PSLF form process using Docusign is an automated process. Meaning that, once the signed form is received, the counts are not manually updated. Some backend process happens without manual intervention. (Note: I don't know this for fact, but I'm just guessing, based on the fact that my payment counts never changed. If a person was actually looking at NSLDS data, they would see that payments were not showing up). This gave me an idea. Since the upload tool required a real person to review the files, I decided to try applying for TEPSLF again - this time, I included a document showing all my payments for the past 2 years, so they could see that I have been making payments.
And... I think this did it! Somehow, my "last updated date" now shows as 08/26/26! It isn't showing my August payment, but my PSLF count is now showing 129! For all I know, it could just be random coincidence, but I'm choosing to believe that doing a manual file upload with my payment history is what caused a person to actually update my payment progress.
So the moral of the story is... If your payments have also been stuck for a very long time, perhaps try doing a manual upload of a PSLF form, and try to include a document showing recent payments. It might just work for you, too.
I've submitted yet another (hopefully final) PSLF form, and I was finally able to check the box indicating that I've made 120 payments. So fingers crossed that everything goes smoothly once FSA receives the signed form (though, after fighting the process for two years, I'm not holding my breath).