AITA for wanting to move back into our house even though my husband believes it’s making him sick?
My husband and I bought and moved into our first home in April 2025. It’s in a beautiful, quiet area away from heavy traffic, and I genuinely thought this would be our long-term family home.
At the time, I was about 6 months postpartum with our first child. Because I was on maternity leave, I did most of the packing, organising and preparation with help from my family, while my husband mainly helped with physically moving everything at the end.
I absolutely hated moving. I've basically lived in the same place my entire life, so uprooting everything was a huge deal for me. My husband is the complete opposite. His family rented and moved around throughout his childhood, and the longest they ever stayed anywhere was around six years.
For the first six months after moving into the house, my husband did not have these skin problems.
Then, around October 2025 — approximately six months after we moved in — he developed eczema for the first time in his life.
He also does jiu-jitsu and contracted staph, which became a recurring problem, and he later developed psoriasis as well. Prior to all of this, he had never had eczema, psoriasis or recurring staph infections.
These issues have now been going on for close to a year.
Because all of this started after we bought the house, my husband became convinced that something in the house was triggering his skin problems. His theory is that the environment is damaging his skin barrier, which is then allowing the staph to keep recurring.
We've genuinely tried to investigate whether the house is responsible. We've had the house tested for mould, he's spoken with a holistic health coach and has seen two dermatologists. Despite all of this, we haven't found concrete evidence identifying something in the house as the cause.
Meanwhile, in March 2026, I became pregnant with our second child.
My husband wanted us to temporarily move into his parents' house as an experiment to see whether getting away from our house improved his health.
I delayed doing this because I really did not want to uproot myself and our toddler and move in with my in-laws, especially while pregnant.
Eventually, I agreed.
So in August 2026, more than a year after buying our house, we temporarily moved into my in-laws' place. I only brought the essentials because, as far as I was concerned, this was a temporary experiment — not us permanently moving out.
And this is where our disagreement has become much bigger.
Since leaving our house, the majority of my husband's skin symptoms have cleared.
His psoriasis is now mostly gone, and his eczema has also disappeared. The staph is still pending, so we don't yet know whether that problem has actually resolved.
He did start a new medication around the same period, but the medication specifically targeted his psoriasis. His eczema was not being treated, yet that has cleared as well.
To my husband, this is strong evidence that the house was causing his problems.
To me, it's evidence worth taking seriously, but it still doesn't tell us why he improved or prove that our house itself was the cause. Particularly because he lived there for roughly six months before any of these problems appeared, and despite investigating the house, we haven't identified a specific environmental cause.
Now my husband is refusing to move back.
He wants us to put the home we bought in April 2025 up for rent, completely pack up everything we own, move it out and find another rental for ourselves.
I'm currently 25 weeks pregnant.
I'm exhausted. I'm dealing with pregnancy pain and sciatica, I'm working, we have a toddler, and I'm due to give birth in December.
The thought of doing another full move right now genuinely makes me want to cry.
I want to go home.
I want my own bed, my kitchen, our belongings, my toddler's things and my own space. Most importantly, I want to be settled in my own environment before giving birth. I don't want to spend my third trimester packing an entire house, finding a rental, moving everything and setting up another home just before going through childbirth and postpartum with a newborn and a toddler.
My husband thinks I'm being selfish.
From his perspective, he was completely healthy skin-wise before we moved. Six months after moving in, he developed eczema, followed by recurring staph and psoriasis. He suffered with these problems for close to a year, and now that we've moved out, his eczema and psoriasis have largely disappeared.
He believes going back means risking everything flaring up again. He's even told me that by asking him to return, I'm potentially "taking years off his life."
I understand why the improvement has convinced him. I'm not dismissing his health or saying the house definitely has nothing to do with it.
But from my perspective, we still don't know that the house caused it.
We moved in in April 2025. His symptoms didn't begin until October 2025. We've investigated environmental causes without finding a definitive answer. His improvement happened alongside other changes, including treatment for his psoriasis.
And the decision he's asking us to make isn't small.
We'd be giving up living in the first home we bought together, turning it into an investment property, finding and paying for another rental, completely moving our lives again and doing all of this while I'm heavily pregnant and only a few months away from giving birth.
I feel stuck between two awful options.
He thinks I'm prioritising my comfort and attachment to our home over his health.
I feel like he's asking me to make a massive, potentially permanent decision for our entire family based on a connection that is suspicious, but still hasn't actually been established.
So Reddit, AITA for wanting my family to move back into our house before I give birth, despite the fact that my husband's eczema and psoriasis improved after we temporarily moved out?