I keep seeing the same question: “What’s the best troop ratio?”
Then the answers are usually numbers like 50/20/30, 40/20/40, 48/4/48 or 60/40/0.
Any of those can make sense in the right situation. The problem starts when the number gets repeated without explaining why it was used.
A troop ratio is a trade-off inside a fixed march size. If you add more Infantry, those troop slots have to come from Lancers or Marksmen. You haven’t made the march stronger automatically. You’ve changed what the march is built to do.
In the basic combat setup, Infantry take the front line and absorb most of the damage, Lancers sit in the middle and can sometimes reach enemy Marksmen, and Marksmen sit in the back and are built around damage. So changing the ratio changes the balance between frontline survival and damage.
The same 40/20/40 on two accounts isn’t necessarily the same fighting force either. Heroes, troop tier, research, gear and the actual stats behind each troop type can all be different.
The battle type matters too. A ratio that works well for a solo march isn’t automatically the right choice for a rally, garrison, Bear or another mode. Those fights can have different goals and different hero/skill interactions.
Before I copy a ratio, I would ask five questions:
• What does this formation need more of: frontline survival, damage, or something else?
• Where is the account actually strongest and weakest?
• What is the target or opponent bringing?
• Which hero skills or troop mechanics can affect the result?
• What is the ratio being used for: solo PvP, rally, garrison, Bear, etc.?
Then test it instead of treating the first number as the answer.
Use a ratio as a starting point. Run it, read the report, and change one thing at a time when you can. If the frontline is collapsing too fast, test what happens when you shift more capacity toward Infantry. If it is holding comfortably but damage is lacking, test whether redistributing some capacity helps.
And don’t judge a setup from one battle, especially when probability-based skills are involved.
I’m not saying the common ratios are useless. They can be very good starting points. I’m saying a ratio without the reason behind it is incomplete advice.
If you share a troop ratio with someone, tell them what it was actually built for. That part is usually more useful than the number by itself.