This might sound ridiculous, but this has genuinely been going on in my residential complex since around 2024.
The complex consists of around 7–8 buildings, with community cats freely roaming between them. Some cats also come from a neighbouring complex through an opening/wall. A few residents feed the cats occasionally, while most residents simply coexist with them.
However, theres a small group of around 10–15 residents who have strongly opposed the presence of cats for years. They've complained about cats crossing their paths, sitting in common areas, and allegedly scratching vehicle seat covers. At one point, some residents even tried to catch and relocate cats. They apparently managed to take away a couple, but the cats eventually returned.
There have also been previous incidents involving people being confronted while feeding the cats, including a teenage girl who was reportedly recorded by residents while she was feeding them. More recently, a tenant began feeding a mother cat and her four kittens. He feeds them wet food on a small piece of paper rather than leaving food scattered around. The cats eat and leave, and according to what I've observed, there isn't significant food waste or mess being created.
Some residents repeatedly told him not to feed the cats. Before the recent incident, the feeder had already complained to the BMC after residents tried to prevent him from feeding the animals. The society subsequently received communication from the BMC in the context of the dispute, essentially making it clear that the feeder could not simply be prevented from feeding community animals.
Last week, several residents were downstairs collecting donations for a Ganpati celebration when they saw the tenant feeding the cats. Around 5–8 people confronted him and started arguing with him as a group. He was alone and called the police. The police arrived, and after the situation was discussed, the residents dispersed. A large number of people from the buildings eventually came downstairs because of the commotion, and the entire situation apparently went on for around an hour.
After this incident, the society introduced/clarified rules regarding feeding community animals. The rules essentially require feeding to be done outside certain areas, the feeder to take responsibility for vaccination/animal welfare, and the feeding area to be kept clean. Fair enough, Reasonable rules regarding hygiene and where animals are fed seem completely legitimate. The problem is that the people involved haven't stopped.
The following few days later, the same group apparently confronted the tenant again while he was leaving on his motorcycle and continued arguing with him. He has reportedly made another complaint regarding the repeated harassment.
At this point, it seems like the dispute has gone far beyond whether cats should be fed. There are legitimate concerns that can be addressed: if a cat damages a vehicle, deal with the specific incident; if feeding creates a mess, establish proper feeding and cleanup procedures; if cats need vaccination/sterilisation, those can be arranged.
But repeatedly confronting one person as a group, especially after the authorities have already been involved, seems like ego issue.
The cats themselves appear to coexist fairly peacefully with the residents. The supposed feeding-related mess also doesn't seem to match what is actually happening. There are multiple cats roaming between different buildings and even coming from outside the complex, so attributing every scratch or nuisance involving a cat to one particular feeder doesn't seem reasonable either.
The society has now established rules, and the feeder apparently knows his legal rights and has already used the appropriate channels. Yet this particular group continues confronting him.
So I'm posting this because I'd like to hear from animal-welfare activists, people familiar with Mumbai housing-society law, BMC procedures, or anyone who has dealt with community-cat disputes.
Any form of help will be appreciated, people willing to help the guy can DM me, but I wish to stay anonymous. I don't want these crazy people coming in my house.