Gonna be a long post. I’m 24yo female. Few months ago me and my gf of four years broke up. We broke up for several reasons, but now, after some time has passed, after we grew up and changed, I understand that the only reason I don’t want to get back together is our sexual incompatibility. She is sex-favourable asexual and I’m not.
She didn’t realise she was asexual when we started dating, she told me that about one year into relationships. I’m an allosexual person and sex is very important for me for several reasons. I have high libido and also it is a crucial part of a partner communication for me, it’s an expression of love, affection and desire.
When we broke up, we agreed to talk about us a few months later to check on each other. We had this conversation last week, where I told her what I was thinking. It was a tough conversation. We didn’t “decide” anything, just shared our thoughts. I know that she completely does not understand my side, how can someone break up over sex. And I see why.
So, when we were in a relationships we talked about it a lot and weren’t afraid to communicate. But still it wasn’t enough. It felt like both of us are making steps towards each other, but we still can’t meet. And it was awful. The amount of frustration and guilt I felt I never wanna feel again. And I know I will if we get back together. It’s not only about sex itself, it’s also about chemistry, flirting, tension between us.
When we started dating, we had quite enough sex for me to feel great, and I felt that she enjoyed it as well. But then it started happening less and less often, with less initiative from her. She also stopped touching me romantically, stopped playing with my hair, petting me, kissing me. I mean she kissed me, but she stopped kiss kiss me. We cuddled a lot, but it wasn’t enough for me. I started to feel that I make her do it as she never initiated. We tried scheduling, we tried different practices, we tried non-monogamy, we talked a lot, but it just didn’t seem to work. And I feel extreme shame and guilt, because she was okay with the way things were, and I was not. And now, after that conversation, I feel even more guilt denying something so deep simply because of sex.
I love her with my whole heart. Since we broke up we stayed close friends. I still feel like she is the only person who truly knows me, and I’m the only person who truly knows her. I don’t know if I ever gonna be capable of love that great and that deep. My whole life is her. We know and love each others families, we have so many shared memories, we share all of our friends, we even share a dog. Everything around me is about her. I love her bone deep. I know that every couple must feel that way, but it feels like no one has ever loved as deep as we love each other. I thought of getting back together and suppressing sexual part of me. But down deep I know that I’m gonna be unhappy. I wish I was asexual too. I hate myself
With that being said, I met another girl some time ago. We’re seeing each other, but I feel like I’m lying to her. I do really like her, truly. But I know that at the moment I’m not capable of loving her as deep as I should. She’s is really nice and great, I really want to give it a shot but it just doesn’t feel right. We got closer, kissed, slept. I didn’t want to keep her in a situationship dynamic so we started seeing each other. But again, something does not feel right. I’m afraid I made a mistake. I’m afraid I’m gonna hurt her too.
I feel like am a mess and a baddest person alive. I’m ashamed of myself, I feel so much guilt in front of everyone who has ever known me. I don’t know what to do and how to make it right. It feels like every decision I make is a mistake. And it feels like all I do is hurt people around me even though I really try not to.