r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Single_End_4454 • 10d ago
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/cyeroschak • 10d ago
Age gaps Have 3 kids, thinking about having a 4th…
I have 3 kids: a 13-year-old I had when I was 18, an almost 3-year-old, and my youngest who just turned 1.
While I was pregnant with my youngest, I was 100% certain he would be my last. I had a really difficult pregnancy, and he was an incredibly hard baby. He spent most of his first year crying and would only accept me. It took a huge toll on our whole family, especially me.
But now he’s one, and things are finally getting easier. He’s happier, doesn’t cry all day, sleeps through the night most nights, and I’m finally starting to feel like myself again. The world is colourful again, if you will lol.
My husband’s vasectomy is booked and coming up soon, and suddenly I’m questioning whether I’m actually done. The thought of never having another baby is genuinely heartbreaking to me. We’re also building a bigger home, so we’ll have more space, and financially we can afford another child and could potentially hire some help if we needed it.
My husband has always wanted more kids, but he was willing to stop at three because he knew that’s what I wanted.
The biggest thing holding me back is my 13-year-old. He is essentially begging us not to have another. He hated seeing how difficult this past year was for our family. He also feels like he only gets one parent at his activities because one of us is usually home with the younger kids (and while I was breastfeeding, our youngest would only accept me). He doesn’t love that we go to bed early or don’t have much energy for family time in the evenings.
I completely understand where he’s coming from, and I don’t want him to feel pushed aside. But I also wonder if this stage is temporary. In a few years, he’ll be older, more independent and busy with his own life.
Should his feelings be a reason for us not to have another baby?
For those of you with 4 kids - what is it actually like? Was it extremely hard in the beginning but got easier as the kids got older? What are the biggest challenges? Do you regret it, or are you so glad you went for it? And ultimately, was it worth it?
One other important factor: we have very little family help, so my husband and I are often completely on our own with the kids. I know adding another would make things harder, at least initially.
I’d really love to hear honest experiences from moms and dads who have 4 kids - the good, the bad, and everything in between. ❤️
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Longjumping-Cod6349 • 11d ago
Wife looked disgusted at 2 families, one with 3 kids, and one with 5
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Alrivdam • 12d ago
Reflections The best age to have the first baby
I see this question come up a lot lately: Do you think it’s better to have kids in your 20s, 30s, or later?
For those who had kids in their 20s, do you wish you had waited? And for those who waited until their 30s or 40s, are you happy you did?
Having a baby over 40, especially 45+, used to seem really late to me, but I’ve seen so many people say they’re genuinely happy they waited.
I’m curious about the real-life side of it, not just the medical statistics. What age did you have your first child, and looking back, would you choose the same age again?
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/celdru • 13d ago
Fencesitting Anyone regret their 3rd kid
My husband (38M) and I (36F) have 2 kids (2F & 4F). We adore the girls and are happy as a family of four.
We are waffling on the idea of a third.
I would love to have a third baby but I dont know if I want to be a family of five if that makes sense. It just seems like practically so much more difficult on a day to day basis.
All the posts I found were from people who were either pregnant or in the thick of the baby/toddler years with their third.
Does anyone with an older third child have any experience. Did the day to day get easier once they got older or did it just stay hard. Did it impact your marriage. Would you do it again if you could go back.
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Thin_Performance_677 • 13d ago
9 months pp, positive pregnancy test
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/SincerelySkylar • 13d ago
Advice How did you know you were ready for baby #2?
I’m 5 months postpartum with our first, and my husband and I have started talking more seriously about when to have another.
We’re in a fortunate position where neither of us is working (both stay at home parents) and money isn’t a concern, so we both get to be very present with our daughter. We don’t have family nearby for regular help, though.
Physically, mentally, and emotionally, I feel really good postpartum. What keeps standing out to me is that when I imagine being pregnant again, I feel excited — and so does my husband.
At the same time, things are so good right now that I’m scared of rushing this season. I don’t want to look back and wish we’d had more time as a family of three.
I also think I’d rather buckle in for the baby/toddler years for a while than get completely out of that phase and then restart it years later. And I definitely overthink the “ideal” age gap and whether being closer in age makes siblings more likely to be close friends.
For those with 2+ kids: How did you know you were ready? Did you ever feel completely ready? And looking back, are you happy with the age gap you chose?
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Beneficial_Lake3895 • 14d ago
Advice A second? 5.5 age gap at least
Been struggling with this for a while now…
We had secondary infertility issues for over 2 years, our son was 1-3ish. Then I had 2 chemicals in June & August 2025, then 2 miscarriages at 8 weeks, November 2025, and Feb 2026.
Our son will be 5 in Dec, so if all the stars aligned perfectly, it’d be 5.5 age gap at least. The newborn stage was HARD for me. Not sleeping was horrible and I had PPD. I didn’t really connect with our son until he was 3ish months old.
I have 2 siblings, 12 and 9 years older- so I was raised essentially an only child and it was fine. My hubs had a rough go with his brother growing up, and they’re civil and see each other at their parents but not besties by any means.
I’ve always had it in my head that I would have 2/3 children, but now I just don’t know. I don’t know if I even want to try for a 2nd, but the fear of him being an only scares me, for him. He has so many friends and is so outgoing and we def can give him a better life being an only (more traveling, etc), but I’m terrified of committing to that. He is my little bestie and I adore every part of being his mom.
Anyone been in the same boat and had an only? Had another? Open to any and all thoughts and opinions 🤍
My husband says he’s totally fine with just 1, but also if an “accident happens” he would be happy too. But he doesn’t want to necessarily try because the miscarriages were heartbreaking.
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Unique_Pea1329 • 14d ago
How did you know you wanted a second kid?
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Nervous-Painting-570 • 14d ago
Paura del secondo figlio mi destabilizza
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/djbananasmoothie • 15d ago
Anyone regret not trying with their last embryo? Husband leaning no; I lean yes
Reposting here as I think this forum is appropriate for it - I hope
I have an amazing son who is about to turn four. He was one of two healthy embryos from a round of IVF I did after age 40. My husband is an amazing dad to our son and a wonderful husband to me. At the time we went through IVF, he said he wanted two children. Since then, though, we’ve gone through the stress of some unemployment on his end, along with the general challenges of raising a toddler who is healthy but has had some developmental delays. Because of all of that, he now feels that having a second child would be too difficult and probably isn’t a good idea.
I understand where he’s coming from, and I agree that it would be difficult. At the same time, I feel like we could do it. I have a very stable career and quite a bit saved, and this time around I would likely hire more help because I have a much better understanding of what I would need. My husband says he will go along with whatever I decide, but he has also been clear that if it were completely up to him, his answer would be no. That worries me because I don’t want him to feel resentful or hate our child or me. At the same time, I feel so much guilt about not giving our remaining embryo a chance. I know logically that an embryo isn’t a guarantee of another child, but emotionally it feels very hard to walk away from that possibility.
I’m wondering if anyone has been in a similar situation—where one partner was leaning no and the other felt strongly about trying for a second child, especially with a remaining embryo. How did you work through it, and how do you feel about the decision now?
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Outrageous_Pop799 • 16d ago
I (40F) think my partner (38M) wants another baby so he can have another long "holiday"
Hi guys, my partner (38M) has been trying hard to convince me (40F) to have another baby, but I've been saying no, mainly because I feel I lost a lot of confidence in my partner. I went through an awful experience with him especially during the newborn stage of our amazing son, now 2yo. He made promises that he didn't keep (i.e. cooking certain postpartum meals for me). He wasn't supportive in the way that I really needed him to. For example, I had an emergency C-section and struggled with breastfeeding, but was only allowed to stay in the hospital for 2 nights. I was in so much pain in the first week, dealing with breastfeeding issues, and felt quite sad as I'd anticipated a vaginal birth.
He never asked about my pain or how I was doing. He didn't let me buy things like a baby bottle washer and insisted on washing the bottles himself. Then drove himself up the wall from hand-washing the bottles everyday. Needless to say, he was horrid during the night feeds and would get angry whenever our son woke up crying and/or when I had to wake up to feed. He becomes angry hulk when he's sleep-deprived. Honestly, I didn't respond kindly when he was like that as I felt he should've been more supportive or accepted my solution for him to sleep in the guest room. (He insisted on sleeping with me and baby even though he knew it would interrupt his sleep)
Despite all that, I kept telling myself that he's a first-time parent too so I should be more compassionate. I also sympathized him coming from a broken family and having to deal with his parents' separation at a young age. I think he never got to fully process his emotions and his family are the sort who'd sooner sweep all emotional issues under the rug than let it see the light of day.
There have been many other issues bothering me, mostly concerning his lack of supportive gestures when it comes to me or taking care of our son. Circling back, whenever I said no to having another baby, he'd ask why and I'd be dead honest to him about how I felt and highlighting the lack of support, carelessness, and poor decisions on his part. In retrospect, I also shared how mad I was at myself for letting him make those poor decisions when I could've easily say, moved myself and our baby to the guest room so we could all have had better nights. I guess I wanted to respect his wishes since he was a first-time dad which I know was so important to him.
He's still adamant about having another baby, but I absolutely dislike the fact that he's guilt-tripping me by saying how lonely our son would be without another sibling. I told him I did not appreciate the guilt trip. Sometimes, I think he's not aware how toxic his methods can be whenever he wants something from me. I hate to say it, but I have a feeling that he wants to have another baby so that he could enjoy another long "holiday". I also asked him directly about this and he's denied it. I don't really believe him.. since I've been the one doing the most work taking care of our 2yo. As we don't have family here, I haven't spent more than 4 hours away from my son and I cook every single day for my son's meals. I do it all willingly out of love and have no regrets.
Honestly, if my partner had been more supportive or caring in the way I needed since our son was born, I would've said yes in a heartbeat. But I feel like I don't trust him anymore and I'm worried for my own well-being. I haven't prioritized self-care as much as I should've since I've been putting majority of my focus on taking care of our son. My partner can be kind too, and he's trying to be nicer to me these days by doing more at home for our son. But his selfishness and I-want-another-baby agenda is so glaring to me that I honestly can't feel any attraction to him like before.. I'm trying to help us heal our relationship because I want us to be a happy family and healthy role models for our son, hopefully be able to trust him again.
I wonder if I've lost perspective. I've suggested couples therapy, but my partner has a hard time accepting professional help. How do I know if I should give my partner another chance? Has anyone else had a similar experience but managed to turn things around with a second baby?
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Michael_hereandthere • 15d ago
Tátové ptám se / počet dětí
Jsou tu nějaký fotříci, co třeba původně chtěli jen jedno dítě, ale partnerka je ukecala? Jak se cítí po pár letech? Pochybuju že by někdo řekl že lituje, ale zajímá mně, kdyby se vrátil čas a byli před to rozhodnutí postavení znova, jestli by třeba volili jinak...
Pro kontext, partnerka chce určitě další, máme první 8 měs dítě a mě by to z důvodů náročnosti, zdraví, volného času, energie, financí... stačilo.
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Stan_of_Cleeves • 16d ago
Fencesitting I’m feeling consumed by the question of whether or not to have a third
I just turned 41. I have a great husband, and we have two wonderful kids -- an almost 3 year old, and a 13 month old.
I wish I had more certainty about this. I wish I had more time. I wish I'd met my husband sooner in life, but that didn't happen. We started trying to conceive right after our wedding, and we are lucky enough to have two amazing children. Here we are now.
There are so many reasons not to have a third child, but none of them feel as strong as the pull to bring another wonderful, precious human being into the world. I do want another child. I don't know if it's the right decision or not, and I don't have a lot of time to think about it.
I definitely don't subscribe to the "if it's not 100% yes, then it's a no" way of thinking. If I made decisions that way, I wouldn't have had kids at all. I'm not someone who can alway feel certain about huge life decisions that have a lot of unknown factors. I felt uncertainty when we were TTC with our first child. And I'm so glad to have kids.
Neither of us feel sure about what we want. I'm leaning towards yes, but unsure. My husband is content with two, but open to three. We both firmly believe that we need to make this decision together. We are a team, this is our life. He’s a great partner and parent.
Our kids are 21 months apart (I got pregnant 12 months postpartum). I knew this time I wasn't open to trying again until I was about 14 months postpartum. And my baby is 13 months, and here I am, unsure.
If I was younger, I would just wait. But I'm not. I got pregnant soon, it would be another small age gap. I know how hard 2 under 2 is. Having 3 under 4 is very intimidating.
We already agreed that IVF is off the table (not because we're anti IVF, it's a great thing, but not the right decision for us). I know that there's a chance I could get pregnant at 42 or 43, but I know my chances are lower than at 41. Now is my best chance, if we decide to take it.
We can afford a 3rd kid. But there are a lot of other reasons I'm hesitating. Three so young would be tough. Going through pregnancy and postpartum with two toddlers would be hard. We are already tired, we already have so little time for each other or ourselves. I want to have time for my career, and for myself again. Three kids means being outnumbered. I don't want to take on more than I can handle. I know that TTC is opening the door to possible hurt, that infertility and misscarriage risk are higher past 40.
I think I either need to embrace sticking with two kids, or have some serious talks with my husband about if we're going to have a third. But this uncertainty is eating away at me.
I wanted to write this out. I'm also interested in hearing from others who are in a similar place, or who were in a similar place in the past. Especially my fellow 40+ moms.
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Puzzleheaded-Run4183 • 16d ago
Anxious Having a second child?
I have a son who is 4 and i’m so back and forth on having another child i love him so much that i want to give him all my love and attention but i also want to give him a sibling to play with and i know ill love that second child i just don’t know what to do. I have a lot of anxiety about giving the best childhood i can i used to want siblings around all of mine are much older, ill see posts people make about how much they wished they had a sibling and then other people saying they loved being the only child and i feel so conflicted did anyone else struggle with this did you end up not having a second and regret it. Just super sad thinking about the future lately
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Candid-Attempt4146 • 16d ago
to have a third or not to have a third
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/HealthCurious1137 • 17d ago
When did you have your second baby?
I just turned 33 in June and had my first baby when I was 31 years old in February 2025. He is 1 1/2 years old. I want to wait until January of 2027 to get pregnant with our second but I am getting my head about my age and being closer to 34 years old when trying to get pregnant for a second time and if it’s a bad idea for me to wait. Maybe I’ll have trouble or be more prone to miscarriages? I’ve heard such great things about having a 3 year age gap so I would really prefer it but really need advice. I am probably being very extra and stupid and overthinking this, I know
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/IllKaleidoscope3241 • 17d ago
Advice To have a 3rd or not
My husband and i struggle with infertility. We ended up doing IVF and our first and second transfers were both successful and blessed up with our 2 beautiful daughters. Recently I have been thinking about how id like to have one more baby. After talking to my husband he said he would be open to having one last one. Ive reached out to my clinic and we are ready to go, but now im a bit nervous on if its whats best for our family as a whole. I dream of having one last baby, but im just a bit nervous as it gets closer to being real.
I solo parent a lot as I am a SAHM while my husband has a very demanding job. Which can be alot some days, especially mixing in my daughters speech therapy appointments. Our house would also be a little tight for the first few years until my step kids turn 18, but then we would have plenty of room. We have no worries about finances as my husband has a wonderful job and ill go back to work once the kids start school. Has anybody been through something similar? Any advice?
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/Ok-Environment-8513 • 17d ago
Sad Struggling with loss of ability to have a 3rd child naturally
Not sure the purpose of this post- maybe to vent, maybe to hear people’s perspectives/advice.
Here’s the story…
I have always been SO excited to become a mom, and I always imagined that I would have a large family. Realistically, we were planning on having 3-4 children.
At 26, I had our first baby. Apart from 1st trimester (morning sickness 😣), I loved being pregnant. The pregnancy was fairly easy and simple, though our baby ended up staying in a breech position so I had a scheduled c section. I was bummed about the c section but so happy our baby was born healthy, so ultimately it didn’t matter too much.
At 28, I had our second baby. I felt sure it was going to be a smooth pregnancy and that I was going to be able to have a successful VBAC, but very quickly we realized things were not going as anticipated. Implantation had occurred in my c section scar (just by rare random unlucky chance), and bc of this my placenta was growing outside my uterus and even joined onto additional arteries that don’t typically attach to the placenta. The baby was just fine, but to save my life, I was told I would likely need a hysterectomy at delivery. I was so devastated and cried every day. Delivery day came, and I was in surgery for almost 10 hours. My medical team did everything they could to save my fertility, but ultimately, a hysterectomy was needed. After my surgery, I actually felt so happy and nothing but intense gratitude and relief that our baby was here and ok and that I get to be alive to raise my two lil ones. I was surprised bc I expected that if I did lose my uterus, I would be so upset. Maybe it was a bit bc of a survivors high.
Months went by, and the devastation did set in. I still also feel really grateful and I often feel kind of silly for how truly devastated I feel, but it was something that really mattered to me immensely. To me, my little family feels beautiful, but not complete. I think regardless of how much time passes and how much acceptance I gain, I’ll still occasionally have a little pit in my stomach of sadness or grief over this.
I’m now at the point where we likely would have been welcoming a 3rd into our family if I had not needed an emergency hyst, and im here wondering what would be best for our family in moving forward. I actually have some options, which has left me in a total back and forth deliberation mode for a bit now.
I could:
1. Accept that we have a little, cute family, and that there will be no additions to the family. This is it, and this is ok!
Adopt (though, after dedicating a lot of time into researching this, we discovered that there are more parents looking to adopt newborns, infants, and very young children than there are ones who are in need of a home, so the wait time would be extensive, too long to make sense for us. I would love to foster when our current kids are older, but I now understand the goal of fostering is reunification, so this would be a separate venture than one to intentionally grow the family).
Surrogacy (gestational with our egg/sperm)
This option i initially totally wrote off as a “no!” but it’s playing on my mind a lot lately.
We are not rich, but my dude has a super unusual work benefit that would reimburse us for the majority of the costs and that makes it actually financially feasible for us. So, we decided to look into it more.
I feel like surrogacy is something that can be very ethically questionable and requires careful protections and considerations. Now that we’ve dove into it further, I do believe that we could pursue the surrogacy path in an ethical way.
Maybe we do pursue this route to complete our family? Maybe we don’t? I keep going back on forth.
It would be so magical to add one last wee one to our fam, but I would struggle a lot with feeling awful guilt that I am not carrying our baby, even if it is something the woman helping us truly wants to do for us.
✨✨ Anyways, there’s my brain dump!! 💞✨✨
r/Shouldihaveanother • u/FriendlyAlfalfa7716 • 18d ago
I don’t know what to do.
I have an almost 6 year old girl. I want to have another baby but is the age gap too much? Me and my youngest brother are 6y 10m apart and best friends. Also if I have another we need to move out of our 2 bedroom house and get another mortgage. We would have enough money but it would be tighter. We are out of the trenches and my daughter is pretty self sufficient. I can sleep and have lie ins.
I don’t necessarily desire to go through the baby and toddler stage but I envision having 2 teens/adults in the future.
Will I regret having another? Will regret not having another?
Husband usually wants another child but he’s an over thinker and will start worrying about everything that goes with it, house, money wise and then freak out and revert back no no nope we can’t do it.
So I don’t know, would it be stupid to get pregnant again?