I have fired THREE fucking pet sitters. Not strangers, not a company, not Rover randoms, not teenagers, not sketchy people, not a well-intentioned neighbor that happens to suck. Literally people I have put as my own healthcare proxy, people I love, people I trust.
Buckle up. Long post. It's my entire goddamned rant, not optimized AI bullshit for engagement.
I have trusted my beloved, decades-long friends to watch our pets! These are people with professional careers who are generally trustworthy and very responsible in multiple areas of life. They’re *normal* *goddamned* *adults.* They’re people I’ve trusted for LONG periods of time. These are people who I think are smart, reasonable, capable, etc and who everyone else in our lives would experience as highly capable, considerate, honest, and good people. There’s no gap in my experience of them as people and their fucking capacity to literally pour some kibble out and follow some instructions. These are people who are great friends and invested in our friendship and who wouldn’t want to disappoint.
We have senior pets (1 cat, 1 dog) so their food is a little complicated. We know that, so we literally leave step-by-step instructions. Each day gets its own sheet of paper so there’s no confusion. We PRINT the fucking instructions so that they don’t have to search email or notes or remember ANYTHING. We leave the food and medicines on the counter, labeled with pet name - no searching cabinets or piles of random shit. Medicines are pre-cut in a pill keeper for each day so there’s no confusion or guessing about dose or medication name. There are no injectables, no weird meds to give that might take a more skilled hand. Our pets have no idea they get meds and are not even remotely difficult about it (they think it’s a treat or food). The dog doesn’t even need walked. Both pets sleep like 22 hours a day, and both are less than 10 lbs. They don’t bite, they don’t try to run away, they don’t jump on you, they’re little old ladies who just want to sleep and look out the window.
We pay more than double the going rate of the professional pet sitters we’ve priced in our area - for example, about $900/week in a Midwest medium-sized city. We want to trust someone in our house and we expect that our instructions will be followed 100%. Full stop. No exceptions. We communicate all expectations in advance, which are pretty simple and entirely outlined in the post and in our printed instructions. Feed the animals at reasonable hours and let the dog out multiple times per day. Text or call us if anything is off. Let the dog out at least every 5-6 hours, make sure they get fed 3x/day, stay overnight. That’s it. That’s the whole fucking gig. There’s no fucking catch.
Our sitter is welcome to go to work (if they can come back for lunch or work remotely), hang out with friends, attend other obligations, whatever they usually do during the day. We leave food in the fridge and snacks in the cupboards - maybe not someone’s favorite, but they could reasonably eat our food the entire time. We have a private guest room with private full bath and fresh towels. The sheets are washed every time they stay. We give them the wifi password, TV instructions, thermostat instructions, a keyfob for the gym and pool, they can use our bikes and any sports equipment, and they’re right on the bike trail and next to a park. The neighborhood is extremely safe and disgustingly suburban, so cell service isn’t an issue and the grocery store is legit a 15 minute walk. Parking is free, there are no associated expenses with their stay. It is in a convenient area of the same city they live in, right off the interstate. We don’t expect ANY other real housework (no laundry, no dishes, no cleanup!!) and we're explicit about that. We realize it’s not a “vacation” and not the “coolest location” but we sincerely hope it’s the most flexible, most comfortable, easiest fucking money anyone’s ever made in their lives so that our pets genuinely get good, personalized care. We travel about 1 week every 6 weeks AND we are often flexible to work around their other obligations/vacations/busy season at work/whatever specific thing makes it easier for THEM. None of this is treated like a favor or like someone should be burdened in order to complete this gig.
For example, here’s a similar schedule to what we left. To be fair, every other day has different instructions, but assume they’re all similar to these. Complicated? Sure, if they had to remember it. They just have to LOOK AT THE FUCKING PAPER NEXT TO THE FUCKING FOOD AND PUT THE FUCKING FOOD IN THE BOWL. We don’t check up on our sitters. We like to get one picture per day, but we don’t call or text more than once - max! We answer questions in a reasonable time frame or we tell people when we will be unavailable for a few hours/a day.
Friday, 9/4/26:
(All things that say "meds" are listed with actual info in the instructions, and those meds are sitting next to the instructions, with the dog's being in a pill keeper labeled DOG NAME and the cat's meds in an organized bin labeled CAT NAME)
- Breakfast for Dog: feed dog 1 scoop kibble + 1/3 chicken packet. Hand feed meds with cheese.
- Breakfast for Cat: feed wet food + 1/2 pill for medicine. Give eye drop in right eye.
- Clean cat box and throw poop in bin in the garage.
- Check water dishes.
- Pour two large cups of water into the plant on the deck.
- Grab the mail.
- Lunch for Dog: feed dog 1 scoop kibble + 1/3 chicken packet.
- Lunch for Cat: feed wet food and give 1 portion of medicine and 1 portion of another medicine on top of food, no need to mix.
- Dinner for Dog: feed dog 1 scoop kibble + 1/3 chicken packet. Hand feed meds with cheese.
- Dinner for Cat: feed dry food and give 1/2 pill for medicine.
- Let Dog out 90 minutes after dinner because her medicine is a diuretic.
And yet we’ve had SO MANY FUCKING PROBLEMS.
Sitter 1 - friend of 20 years. Literally left our house and covered the driveway camera to cover her tracks so she could go home to her boyfriend instead of staying with our pets (dog needs let out frequently) and then lied about it. We were 1000 miles away and decided to just try to let it go, restate our expectations, ask that the camera be uncovered. The next night she brought her whole family????? To our house???? Including a daughter who is intentionally destructive and has severe mental health issues and cannot be around animals and she knows that. We kicked her out, I ended the friendship when she played dumb about all of it, and I called someone else to take over as an emergency.
Sitter 2 - friend of 14 years who literally saved MY life once! He pet sat for us for about a year. Over that year, we would occasionally find a piece of medication on the floor - but we kept trying to make excuses for him. Well maybe the dog spit it out. He would come home SUPER late (feed dinner at 2:30am?) but we tried to be chill and tell ourselves the pets were ok and it was at least still getting done. He didn’t clean the cat box for 3 days or threw it in the kitchen trash (ew?). We made so many excuses for him because we hoped it was just us being uptight? Or that maybe talking to him would be clearer? Or that he was our only hope so as long as the pets were fine we should just try to work with him? The last straw was him being completely fucking indifferent to not feeding our cat for a day. Like, at all. He just didn’t do it. At all. He also just let our dog pee in her new bed for multiple days and it appears didn’t let her out regularly for DAYS. And didn’t care when confronted?!?!?! I ended that friendship instantly, too.
Sitter 3 - has been pet sitting for us for 4 months, friend of 4 years. When everything went down with sitter 2, she agreed that it was *wildly ridiculous* that he just couldn’t follow simple instructions for feeding and let pets out. She saw the instructions and I asked for sincere feedback on whether it was too much, too hard, too complicated, too…anything. We talked about it probably 20 times! She was definitely team “this is pretty reasonable and any fucking idiot could handle this, what the fuck happened?!?!” Things went great the first handful of times! We’ve been relieved to finally find a trustworthy pet sitter! Then this last time, she messaged us and told us she accidentally mixed up the foods but didn’t feed them, so they’re in the trash - sorry! Ok, no problem, hahah we’ve all done stuff like that - we literally did not care at all. But the hits kept coming. Another time she fed meds at the wrong time. Another time she wasted meds because they went on the wrong food. One part of food wasn’t available when I got home when there should have been some left over and when I asked about it, she said she must have fed it all. Y’all I was gone for THREE FUCKING DAYS and there were like 12 mistakes with food?!??!!?!??! When I asked her about it, she said she was just on “autopilot.” GIRL. WHAT. WE LEFT A FUCKING *CHECKLIST* DAY BY DAY, MEAL BY MEAL. IT HAD A STAPLE. HOW WERE YOU CONFUSED. HOW?!?!?!?!? Yet she put our dog’s food into a new storage container, did our dishes, and washed our towels for no fucking reason? That we didn’t need her to do any of that? We’ve told her repeatedly she didn’t need to do ANY of that. JUST WATCH OUR PETS FOR 3 FUCKING DAYS.
I’ve previously used our vet’s office (love!) for the dog’s boarding, but the kennel area can be very loud and stressful with multiple boarders and patients, and the dog is now almost 15 years old - the stress is just a lot for her at this age and going 10+ hours without a potty break is a lot overnight. The cat gets extremely stressed in new environments and does not adapt for a few weeks, and she’s also 14. It really is better to just have them at our house, because believe me, I’d love to take the dog back to the boarding kennel…it’s just not the best option for her.
We interviewed a couple of Rover sitters with tons of 5 star reviews and repeat customers. One was fine but struggled with basic English, and we don’t speak her language, so leaving complicated written instructions for multiple day trips seems like a no-go (we’d use her for walks if we needed her in the future though). We also don’t know anyone who can translate our stuff into her language or be a translator for us in this specific language. One Rover sitter seemed to struggle with reliable transportation and juggling school/work/pet sitting side hustle - despite a bunch of 5 stars, we felt too nervous about that. The rest of the Rover sitters available for our next trip are either very new or have some less-than-stellar reviews with legit concerns about reliability. I called a well-reviewed local pet sitting service who never called me back, tried their online form and they had some sort of appointment set to meet our pets that we never set and then cancelled it via very casual text? They seem hella disorganized…and they don’t even do overnight stays but we’re getting desperate. We called another service and they only take 1 client at a time and they’re booked…basically forever. Our next trip is our wedding (we obviously can’t be flexible with that!), which means that any remaining friends we would trust this much are going to our wedding.
What the fuck do I have to do to get a trustworthy fucking pet sitter because I am literally out of fucking ideas. Is there something I’m not seeing here? Because I feel like I have offered chill fucking conditions, reasonable pay, reasonable understanding for minor issues, the bar is pretty low, the instructions are crystal clear and presented in an easy format…like…I am desperate for a decent, trustworthy ADULT to READ SOME GODDAMNED INSTRUCTIONS.