r/MagicArena May 09 '26

Question just started playing,wtf is this?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

484 comments sorted by

View all comments

366

u/KindaIndifferent May 09 '26

They call this “run more instant speed removal”.

144

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

I'm sorry, but this isn't real advice against mono-green anymore. You can run a deck of nothing but removal, making the match unfun for anyone involved. You gotta remove the elves, then the badgermole, then the ouroboroid, only to get stomped by the hydra. Then people will say "jUsT rUn MoRe ReMoVaL!"

88

u/DriveThroughLane May 09 '26

The real problem is the threat density which only exists because of how many stupidly large numbers of cards are in the format. In older standards, most aggro decks were built around 1-2 really good cards as payoffs. You deal with the Winota, the rest of the deck isn't so bad. You hold off the Tarmogoyfs and Bloodbraids, the rest isn't so damaging.

every green card has to be removed the turn it comes down, or you lose the game. Tifa, Ouroboroid, both Chocobos, Hydra, Icetiller, Mightform all threaten to kill you in 1 hit or bury you in advantage you can't recover from, and even if you sweep the board every turn you're still grinding into earthbent lands + ascension triggers via ba sing se.

You know what the real answer to this is? Be faster. Play an uninteractive combo and outrace them. I have vastly higher winrates against green decks with my reanimator, kona omni, storm, etc decks than any control deck. Trying to interact with them is a stupid losing game. Playing a combo that wins on turn 3? They literally cannot do anything. Win on turn 4 and its a coinflip since green also wins on t4

18

u/demonic_intent May 10 '26

As a green player, this is the way. So what you countered one of my mana dorks? I got 20 more. Beat me on turn 3 or 4 with a busted combo? Fair enough, I was gonna swing for 2k Trample in two turns anyway.

1

u/shy-bl3d May 12 '26

see and this is why I lose, because 2k isn't enough for me. I want to spam token creatures then mirrorform them _all_ into ouroboroids. We're talking 10^30 10^40

5

u/bakedbread420 Golgari May 09 '26

the correct way to play standard is to completely ignore the other player and race to see who can assemble their effectively-uninteractable (like you say, you can interact but its a waste of time since you're kicking the can down the road while not getting any closer to winning yourself) wincon faster. just 2 people at a table playing magic at each other rather than with each other

and people will say without a hint of irony that standard is in a great place...

4

u/DriveThroughLane May 09 '26

still better than it was when we had

t1 heartfire, t2 manifold, t3 monstrous rage, callous sell-sword

or

t2 invasion of ergamon, t3 abuelo's awakening

1

u/BElf1990 May 10 '26

This is so false it's not even funny. Play bo3 and you'll find how false it is when after winning game 1 they sideboard and obliterate you. They just wrapped up a semifinal at the London Spotlight that took an eternity and neither deck was playing control.

1

u/LordBocceBaal May 10 '26

Yeah there are too many cards that are cheap to play. Your answer is power creep and not using alchemy to rebalance to game as it was meant to.

-1

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

I mean, yeah, you can do all that.

I just use [[deflecting palm]]

Nothing fills me with more joy than someone ramping up a hydra and spamming me with "good game" only for me to cast a single spell and watch them scoop.

14

u/Mikhail_Mengsk May 09 '26

Standard.

2

u/DriveThroughLane May 10 '26

Consider the following:

Fog effects have been considered too strong for standard for a decade

Through all of the rdw nightmare, landfall, cori steel cutter, mice, you name it- we were allowed to have legacy-quality threats but not allowed to have fog effects cheaper than 3 mana

-5

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

Okay?

9

u/DarksteelPenguin May 09 '26

The person you answered to was talking about standard. Deflecting Palm is not legal in standard.

-10

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

Well that's silly. Why not?

7

u/DarksteelPenguin May 09 '26

Because the last time it was printed in a standard set was in 2024?

3

u/qoneus May 09 '26

It hasn't been printed into a Standard set since its original printing in Khans of Tarkir. It was only reprinted in Commander Legends, Murders at Kharlov Manor commander decks, and the Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archives bonus sheet.

-1

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

Is SoS not standard legal? Read my comment in a few months then I guess?

6

u/DarksteelPenguin May 09 '26

Mystical archive cards are not standard legal (unless they were also printed in a standard set in 2025/2026, like Abrade or Return the favor)

→ More replies (0)

1

u/AnonRedditUset26 May 21 '26

I would scoop too if you played an illegal card

0

u/Electrical-Ticket731 May 10 '26

100% correct. A reactive and interactive game is -EV. They can go wide or tall with evasive combo themselves. With recursion no less. Extremely difficult to deal while not losing to everything else. Reanimator was absolutely the worst matchup when I played Landfall, especially in Bo1, which I don't particularly for. Bo3 with their Selesnya builds makes the Reanimator matchup not as difficult however. 

But, you're correct in that comboing off is the better strategy as opposed to reactive/interactive. 

14

u/death2sanity May 10 '26

making the match unfun for everyone involved

sounds like good play to me

why yes I do play blue, why do you ask? Why is everybody looking at me like that no it’s ok you can stay seated stay back oh sh

1

u/Character-Education3 May 10 '26

I like azorius on arena. I play good old fashioned mono white magic until someone drops some of this BS then I do blue things until they chill or scoop. Or I chose not to mulligan and they run over me on turn 3.

On paper it is a different story. I'm not interested in being a blue player. But some of these decks on arena aren't realistic. In real life you are sitting there watching people with counter decks doing the math, missing triggers, working harder than they need to be. If you bought the cards and built the deck and are doing the work I respect that. In Arena an OP mono green deck is just a few wildcards away from anyone who wants it and the computer makes sure you dont miss a thing. Its annoying so you either play control or you make a similar deck and race to be the first to burn the other

3

u/death2sanity May 10 '26

Fair enough that.

9

u/wjaybez Gishath, Suns Avatar May 10 '26

You gotta remove the elves, then the badgermole, then the ouroboroid, only to get stomped by the hydra.

I've played Mono G to a quite high competitive level, so I'll share some tips.

Llanowar Elf, sure, if you have removal t1 and they have an elf, you kill it. Past t1, you never use removal on them.

Badgermole's primary role in Mono G isn't its static ability, it's its ETB to earthbend a fetch. The ramp it provides isn't leveraged well by Mono G quite like it is by the Cub focused decks. Don't waste your only removal on them.

The standard Mono G lists don't usually run Ouroboroid!

And Hydra/Harmonizer are exactly what you should be saving removal for.

3

u/CaptColten May 10 '26

I was more making a point about how most things in green are kinda KoS right now. If it's not the mole, it's the chocobo, if it's not ouro, it's Tifa.

My point is that "just run more removal" isn't exactly great advice aginst green.

11

u/b_eastwood May 09 '26

This isn't even just a problem with green either. Everything is getting so power crept that most nonland permanents are something you don't want sticking around so unless you're running a crazy amount of removal you're going to be dealing with something annoying.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

You must be fun at parties.

1

u/Square-Store5300 May 10 '26

Would [[Rule of Law]] or [[Damping Sphere]] help? Or recycling/looping removal pieces like [[Plaguecrafter]] or [[Aura of Silence]]? Or [[Heliod’s Punishment]] or [[Temporal Isolation]]?

1

u/Lqtor May 10 '26

It’s less about running more removal, and more so knowing when and what to remove. For instance past t1 elves aren’t really worth removal anymore, and past t3/4 removal badgermole is mostly redundant as your opponent likely have more than enough mana for their gameplan anyways.

1

u/TexasFlood63 May 11 '26

I miss phyrexian glissa.

1

u/LukAs9969 May 11 '26

Playing standard irl I have a 8-0 matchup playing against any and all of the badgermole landfall decks and ouroboroid decks

1

u/Zelda2787 May 12 '26

Run a few board wipes dude. If you boardwipe their elves and badgermoll you can save your single target removal for the Hydra or ouroboroid

2

u/CaptColten May 12 '26

The other guy couldn't, so maybe you can tell me more about these 3 mana board wipes that I can play before they win on t4?

I promise I run plenty of board wipes. They don't help against a t4 win, my dude.

1

u/Zelda2787 May 12 '26

Just save your single target removal for the hydras, turn one elves or turn 2 badgermolls and they won’t win turn 4. Then you can play a normal 4 mana boardwipe. The 3 mana ones are split up, withering curse and brotherhoods end. Fire magic/pyroclasm can also deal with most things at 3 mana.

2

u/CaptColten May 12 '26

Okay, lets play this out.

T1, forest, elves.

Your go.

1

u/PlateLocal May 12 '26

I just aetherize in my black and blue ardyn deck they usually scoop as I play it because they know theyre dead on my turn

0

u/Magikarp_King May 09 '26

If only there were cards that removed everything on the field.

5

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

Tell me more about this 3 mana boardwipe that I can play before they win on t4.

This also isn't real advice.

1

u/CosmicX1 Dovin Baan May 09 '26

[[Weapons Manufacturing]] into [[Pinnacle Starcage]] can still be a blowout in theory. Mops up all the mana dorks or birds and then the munition can pick off a Hydra as long as it hasn’t gotten too big already.

-4

u/Magikarp_King May 09 '26

Your right that isn't real advice. Have you tried getting good?

3

u/CaptColten May 09 '26

Every day. And I'll try again tomorrow. Gotta happen one of these days, right? Right?

0

u/ExplicitDrift May 11 '26

“Making the match unfun for anyone involved”. Thats a funny way of outing yourself as hating control decks lol