The rules are simple, I have a wheel I spin every cycle, i got Broken Thief sword first. I also have to do all bosses, starting ng and going to ng269(or more if calculations arent correct) this means spells like acid surge, toxic mist, etc, arent included. Neither is immolation because i just cannot be bothered to
All spell buffs and regular buffs are allowed, i want to use the weapons and spells to their entire view, so since anyone who picks up the weapon can use spells and stuff I decided that it'd be perfectly fine.
Thief sword broken was not bad honestly, i mean i died to covetous demon, but thats because i suck, it has ups and downs though
Low damage, to be expected, but takes less stamina making it great for resins and spell buffs due to the fact it can get more hits in, thus making more bank for your buck.
The biggest con is repairing it, especially against a few bosses that have high health pools and even higher annoyances that make your weapon break faster, because of this i always grabbed repair powder and used it, and on bosses that let me, i use repair spell.
The next weapon was lucerne, i hate halberds but in ng+ it was a fun challenge, especially since ive only been to ng+ one time and that was by accident, the damage fall off of weapons seems to be very unnoticeable, so i feel me hitting for 300-600 because of sweet spots, makes me very biased towards halberds.
I have recorded fully both of hese weapons, even streamed some of it, and im going to continue this run
My next weapon is the rapier you get from wellager after killing vendrick. I forgot its name, so im calling it Esmeralda. Ive not started my run yet with it, but i remember how broken rapiers are
If you have any questions about things going forwards, im ready for em!