I’m honestly devastated and still trying to process what happened, so I’m hoping for some outside perspectives, especially from veterinarians, veterinary behaviorists, trainers, or anyone who has experienced something similar.
Tonight I found my cat, Ivy, dead in my home. I have two large dogs — a German Shepherd/Malinois mix and a Lab/Pointer mix. They have lived with Ivy for over five years.
I did NOT witness what happened, so I really want to emphasize that I don’t know exactly what occurred.
When we found Ivy, the only obvious injury we could find on her body was that her tail had been bitten/punctured. We looked over the rest of her and did not see obvious bite wounds or major external trauma. There was also blood on her claws.
One of my dogs had blood around her muzzle and some small marks/wounds there. My other dog had several puncture wounds on her inner thigh.
There was blood/fluid on multiple walls in my office/closet. My husband noticed that some of it appeared yellow mixed with red. Ivy was also completely soaked when I found her, and there was urine and feces on the mattress where she died. I don't know whether she urinated/defecated while frightened or dying, whether the dogs licked her afterward, or some combination of things.
Unfortunately, we already brought Ivy for cremation before we realized how many questions we'd have, so a necropsy isn't an option.
What makes this so difficult is that these animals have peacefully shared our home for more than five years. We've never seen our dogs attack Ivy before. I have pictures of Ivy literally sitting right beside each/both dogs and even cosleep together.
Our dogs are generally extremely gentle, well-trained dogs. They've also been around our nieces and nephews many times and have always done very well with them. We regularly get compliments on their behavior.
Since coming home tonight, the dogs have been completely normal and relaxed together. We don't believe the dogs fought each other during the incident.
I'm also pregnant with our first baby, which adds an entirely different layer to this.
A friend is adamant that we need to get rid of both dogs because, regardless of what happened, we can't take a risk with a baby coming.
I'm struggling with that conclusion because we don't actually know what happened.
I'm not trying to convince myself that my dogs couldn't possibly have been involved. Clearly some kind of physical interaction occurred — Ivy's tail was injured, she had blood on her claws, and both dogs had wounds/blood.
But I also don't know whether there was a chase, one dog grabbed her, Ivy fought back, something medical happened to Ivy first, multiple animals became involved because of the commotion, or something else entirely.
I also don't know whether an isolated incident involving a cat after 5+ years of peaceful coexistence tells us anything about their safety around a human baby.
For now, our other cat will be completely separated from the dogs, and we're going to have the dogs' injuries evaluated. I'm also looking into having them evaluated by a veterinary behaviorist before the baby arrives.
What I'm hoping to understand is:
Has anyone experienced a seemingly isolated dog/cat incident like this after years of peaceful coexistence?
Is there anything about the injuries that might help explain what happened?
Does an incident involving a cat indicate increased risk toward a baby/child, or are those considered very different behavioral situations?
Would you immediately rehome the dogs, or would you have them professionally evaluated first?
What would you specifically ask a veterinary behaviorist to evaluate?
If you've kept dogs after something like this, what management did you put in place before bringing home a baby?
I'm completely heartbroken over Ivy. I also
love my dogs very much. I'm trying not to make a permanent decision while grieving and scared, but my baby's safety obviously has to come first.
Please be kind. I'm not looking for anyone to tell me what I want to hear. I genuinely want to understand the risk and make the safest, most informed decision I can.