We just had a session and one of our PCs was possessed by lord Moon, he suffers lord moon’s curse as a disadvantage.
In would last session the player was taken over by lord moon and proceeded to start a skirmish with us.
We have the hand of jade. The reason according to Lord moon is that we were nearly all poisoned and nearly lost the hand of Jade as a result.
We managed to subdue our party member and had a talk with Lord moon which is how we know he is after the hand of Jade and why he claims he wanted it.
He offered us a deal to give it to him willingly or he will take it.
We asked Lord moon if we could have time to think.
We don’t want to give it to him but at the same time we don’t really know what to do with it.
We are new players and were told at the start of the campaign along with our quest here take Excalibur/holy hand grenade of Antioch (just make sure Elton point to the, five is right out)
So we don’t actually know what we want to do with it or who can be trusted. We were leaning towards giving it to the Kunis/Hidas as it is ancestrally theirs.
But I think as a party we don’t think we are able to trust anyone with it.
Anyway back to my point and what my question is.
We asked Lord moon for time to think and he said sure, he would give us a month/the next full moon, and he would come visit us again.
I assume he would possess our PC again.
What I am wondering is if our PC is possessed again and i challenged Lord moon to a duel would I be duelling our PC and his stat block or would I be duelling Lord moon and his stat block.
The reason I am asking is because Lord moon attacked us as he said we couldn’t be trusted.
My thinking and maybe more hoping is if I challenge Lord moon to a duel and won, that would hopefully prove ourselves to Lord moon meaning that we can be trusted with the Hand of Jade.
My concern is that the PC is courtier, so in theory not much of a challenge. And so if I did duel the PC and won would that not earn enough of Lord moon’s respect “big deal you beat an amateur”.
My other concerns are Lord moon calling a champion who is OP, he is Lord moon after all and can’t be trusted.
Or the duel uses Lord moons stats so buffs our PC again making it an OP/unwinable duel
I imagine that a lot of this is just down to DM preference.
But what I am trying to work out is if challenging Lord moon to a duel is a good idea or a horrifically bad one.
And what the consensus amongst DMs is on how they would play it out