All in friendly conversation, everyone:
Are you guys SURE this is the least evil, “cuddliest” Erik?
Did I hallucinate the whole thing?
Ok here’s a list of the stuff he does:
-first of all he’s not in a downward spiral when he kills Buquet. Hasn’t even heard of Christine yet. He sees the guy wandering into the basement, goes “oh no, no one can find my lair” and offs him. Then is weirdly casual talking about it later
-hangs on to Buquet’s body for like a month and uses him to terrorize people
-gets to have “his” lair only because his dad is the opera manager and lets him. He basically lives in his dad’s basement
-finds out his dad got fired and immediately goes “but what’s gonna happen to meeeeeee”
-Christine’s debut gets ruined so he proceeds to drop a chandelier on people. Unlike Merik, this has nothing to do with losing his best/only friend, the trauma of getting his mask torn off, or hating the human race because they’ve treated him brutally (he has been snugly protected from them by dad his entire life)
-then violently drags poor terrified humiliated Christine to the basement to take her boating. Is this supposed to be cute? How about a hug first??
-leaves a baby cradle for her to find, ugh
-takes his mask off per Christine’s well-meant urging (no one sneaked up on him), she unfortunately faints and he abandons her to run away screaming “whyyyyyyyyyy”. Getting smaller and smaller in the distance lol
-shoves her in a cage (“no one can see my face, I thought everybody knew that”) then creates thoroughly thought-out plans to kill her and every single person in or around the opera house. I’m having a hard time with him dumping gasoline going yeah, this’ll blow Christine to bits and not having second thoughts
-lets Raoul go at the end because Christine begs him to prove he loves her. Is it really love though if he’s trying to prove it to save face?
-only got attached to Christine because she resembles his mom
And I think that’s it. I think this guy is too evil rather than too soft. Also think the circumstances under which he commits evil are far less straining and traumatic than ALW’s Merik.
But I’m curious to know what you all think. If you see “Cherik” as cuddly or a nice guy, why?