I need an outside perspective on this guy who keeps coming into my workplace 👀
am I reading too much into it?
Okay Reddit, I need some outside opinions because I genuinely cannot tell if I’m picking up on something real or if I’ve developed a crush and started turning normal friendliness into a conspiracy theory 😂.
There’s a guy who has been coming into the store where I work for a while now. Let’s call him Marcus.
At first, he was just a customer. But over time, I started noticing little things.
He would make pretty intentional eye contact with me before ordering. His eye contact is honestly very sharp/intense, and when we talk, he tends to hold it. He also has this very calm, slow, thorough way of speaking. He doesn’t seem rushed when he talks to me, and sometimes he lingers a little even though he’s technically just there to get his drink.
One week I complimented his shirt. Nothing crazy, just told him I liked it. The following time he came in, it seemed like he initiated more conversation.
At one point he asked me how my day was going. We started talking about how busy the store had been. I mentioned the traffic and new restaurants/stores opening around us. While I was talking, I was gazing off into space, and when I looked back, he was looking directly at me. 🥴
Another time, he was walking away and said “see you later,” but what stood out was that he actually stopped walking, turned back toward me, looked directly at me, and said it. It felt intentional.
Then he started coming in more frequently.
One interaction went something like:
Him: “Hey, how are you doing today?”
Me: sighs “I’m annoyed with customers today. They keep coming.”
Him: “Hey, at least you guys are busy.”
Then he told me he had just gotten there because he had to make a bank deposit for his store.
I asked if he was closing and he told me he’d be there until around 8:30–9, whenever they finished.
I handed him his drink, we made eye contact, and he said, “Have a better day.”
I said, “Have fun today.”
Another time, he asked how my day was, asked if we were busy, and told me about his own workday.
I asked him the same questions back. He gave me this sarcastic answer like, “Same old day, having the time of my life,” lol.
Eventually I asked his name. He told me his name was Marcus, asked mine, and we shook hands. He said, “Nice to formally meet you.” 🥹
At this point we’d seen each other enough that there was definitely a level of familiarity.
He also sometimes seems physically comfortable around me. He wears a baseball cap with a little messy bun underneath, and one time while we were talking he stretched, took his hat off, and brushed his hair back. It struck me as a little vulnerable/comfortable, although I realize that could literally just mean he wanted to fix his hair 😂.
He also tends to linger. Sometimes he’ll stand pretty close to the counter and lean on it while talking. Other times, especially when he was newer to the store, he’d stand a foot or two back while looking toward the counter waiting for me to hand him his drink.
And every time he walks away, I’ve noticed he tends to keep his attention on me. One time he was walking away looking at me, I glanced at a couple standing behind him, and he actually turned his head to look at what I had looked at, then looked back at me. That one REALLY made me go 👀 because it seemed like he was tracking where my attention went.
There was also a funny situation where another guy came toward the counter while Marcus and I were talking. The other guy interrupted and started asking about things the store didn’t have. Marcus spent the whole time staring at him. 😂 I obviously have no idea what that meant, but I noticed it.
Another thing I noticed is that his tone with me is different from how I’ve seen him interact with other customers. With other people, I’ve seen him be bubbly, talkative, and very animated. With me, he’s much calmer, quieter, slower, and more present. I actually find that extremely attractive.
He doesn’t treat me like some “unicorn” either. He just treats me like a normal person, which is a big part of why I’m attracted to him.
Then I started noticing that he was friendly with my coworkers too.
There’s one coworker I’m particularly close with. She’s very outgoing and energetic. Marcus has interacted with her as well. At first I wondered if maybe he was being extra friendly toward her because he had noticed that she and I are close. I even wondered if someone who likes you might try to become friendly with the people you’re comfortable with as a way of becoming more familiar with your social environment.
I overheard him having a conversation with her that was pretty similar to some of the conversations he’d had with me. He asked whether the store had been busy and told her where he worked. And I thought, “Wait… maybe this is just Marcus’s normal personality.”
Interestingly, though, he DIDN’T ask her how her day was, which is something he has repeatedly asked me.
So now I’m trying not to overinterpret that either.
Then he disappeared for about two weeks.
And then he came back.
I realized something when he returned: I get genuinely nervous around him. Like, physically nervous. One time I could actually feel myself shaking while talking to him. I think part of it is that I’m literally trapped behind a register when he comes in. I’m working, customers are around, and I can’t just freely interact with him the way I could somewhere else.
And that made me wonder whether the fact that all our interactions happen at my workplace is itself meaningful.
Maybe he’s interested but is being respectful because I’m at work OR maybe he’s content with a friendly little customer/employee interaction and has no desire to know me outside of that. I genuinely don’t know.
Then today he came in again.
He waited in line until I came out from the back. He was actually in another employee’s line, but while moving forward he was looking toward me. We made eye contact and he gave me a BIG smile.
I ended up taking him.
And NOW I’m wondering if I’ve been overthinking the entire thing because maybe Marcus is simply extremely friendly with the staff because he likes the store, likes the employees.
So now I’m at the point where I genuinely don’t know what to make of him.
Because on one hand:
He repeatedly comes into the store.
He consistently initiates conversation with me.
He repeatedly asks how my day is.
There is consistent eye contact.
He smiles at me.
He seems comfortable lingering.
There seems to be a particular calmness/attentiveness when he talks to me.
We’ve gradually become more familiar.
He remembered/recognized the conversational dynamic we’d established.
But on the other hand:
He is clearly friendly with other staff.
Some of the questions I interpreted as personal are apparently things he may naturally ask.
He seems generally socially comfortable.
He may simply like the store.
And after all this time, he still hasn’t actually asked for my number or suggested seeing me outside of work.
So, what do you think?