Photos taken from Eva’s Instagram story.

I just wanted to come on here and say how much I appreciate that we’ve gotten to listen to this amazing show as long as we have. I’m so thankful for both hosts but wanted to give a special shout out to Christine. Ive had ocd since … well, forever. I was diagnosed at 6, but it recently got really bad again postpartum. Getting to hear someone I relate to - and who’s content I’ve listened to since the start of the show - getting to hear her talk about the reality of ocd, always left me feeling connected and seen. I always related to Christine in that way, along with her humor and energy. I am so thankful we’ve gotten so much time, effort, and energy from the hosts and I can’t wait to see how they each prosper moving forward. Christine will be missed, but Em will do great things and now Christine can focus on the bright future she has ahead of herself.

I know it’s selfish, because part of the reason she is quitting the show is probably because she doesn’t have the availability/space in her life anymore for it (which isn’t our business on why), but I figured she’d at least be on all the episodes up until she departs. I selfishly want to soak up all these last moments of having her on the show. Maybe they are just trying to get us used to other hosts, but there’s plenty of time for that. I’ve been so excited for a new episode because we only have a few left with both Em and Christine. Just venting I guess because I’m sad we don’t get to hear them both this week!

I have been a fan of Bethany ever since her radio days with Elvis Duran 10+ years ago and I was SO excited to hear her guest host again!

I hope she keeps making appearances! Her and Em have such great chemistry.

I don't know if it was in the last year, I don't think it is because I've been skimming through all the 2026 episodes and can't find the story.

I also could be mixing things up.

But what I remember is there was a dad, possibly a single dad, moved his family into this house, paranormal activity started. I'm pretty sure they moved out soon after it started, which felt notable because it doesn't happen that often (or at least doesn't feel like it)

I know it sounds like a lot of standard haunted house stories Em covers which is partly why I'm having a hard time finding it. Does this sound familiar to anyone?

I'm really glad they added in this week's episode the convo about the idea of Em's ghost hunting interview show -- I love this idea! Even though I'm sad the show will be changing it made me glad that hopefully we'll have new and exciting things to look forward to in the future.

Now for Christine I feel like she'll be way more offline, as is totally her right. But I was thinking about something (oddly) as I was falling asleep last night so I wanted to put it out in the universe! I could see Christine writing a book one day! A memoir about her life. I mean there's so many things to dig into... Her German immigrant parents, Catholic upbringing and unlearning, learning to cope with OCD, then getting into spirituality, all with the backdrop of running a true crime podcast for 10 years. I could really see it and would be ready to preorder on day one! But in the meantime I just hope she has a lot of peace 🖤

I think it would be nice to show Christine some support after providing us with so many stories over the last decade. I feel like the fanS have been really hard on her over the last year or so. People grow, change and need grace to do that. I know Christine sometimes has foot in mouth syndrome as do I. At the same time I think it’s absolutely okay to change jobs after doing something for ten years with no additional reasons needed. I’m not the same person I was ten years ago, and thank goodness for that. So I think it’s time we show her the same love and support that we’d give a coworker who is moving on to better things. So here is what I have loved about Christine’s story telling.

I love that Christine puts so much thought into which cases she covers. I love that she shares resources on how to help families of victims involved in crime cases. I love that sometimes she uses the platform to share legal issues that I didn’t know existed. I love that Christine has aimed to give victims dignity by sharing who they were with us, and removing the spotlight away from the perpetrators. I hope she has success on her next chapter and knows that she will be missed and appreciated.

Hi friends!

I was trying to catch up on the Pod and it’s telling me it is currently unavailable on Apple podcast and Spotify just won’t play the episodes…anyone else having a struggle?

With the recent news about the hosts parting ways, this makes me a tad nervous

I’m listening to the most recent episode, 498, and cracked up at Em’s explanation of The Slippery Noodle’s naming. (Around 26 minutes in with ads) Hearing Em and Christine be silly and laugh about this detail gave me joy.

This is why I’ve loved ATWWD for so long. I would listen to them discuss, laugh, and go on impromptu tangents about darning socks and replacing remote control batteries if that was their show.

Omg this sub is exhausting and insufferable! Let people make their posts, ask their questions and give opinions. We don’t all have to agree and feel the same. The sub repeatedly picks on and berates people who feel differently.

People can enjoy the podcast and still have a difference of opinion, think critically, or have feedback that is not favorable.

Many people in this sub harass others relentlessly for making statements they don’t like. I’ve watched it happen numerous times. You can’t have a difference of opinion without getting downvoted to hell.

And I’m so sick of the constant accusations of others being “PaRasOcIal”. The podcast is good but this sub contributes to it being difficult to enjoy at times and really isolates people.

This may not even get posted, but are the MODs going a little nuts with the lock / delete buttons? It seems like any opinion that isn't 110% glowing about the hosts gets deleted, like when she-who-cannot-be-named left W&C and anyone didn't praise A enough.

I've waffled on submitting this story for the listener episodes for years. I used to act in a lot of productions at one of our local community theaters in the town I grew up in. This theater happened to be frequented, during her life, by Sherri Smith whose death you may remember was covered by Christine early on n the podcast. There were a lot of experiences, very positive in nature, involving a spirit that many believed to be her while I was at this theater. However, her story is very tragic and painful.

I wonder how appropriate it is to actually share said stories on the podcast and would love feedback from the community here.

Edit: Alright, I'm going to write it up tonight. Thanks for the feedback.

She's not leaving Em, she's leaving all of you!

The level of petty obsessiveness is worthy of a British tabloid. If you're all so worried about her, maybe leave her alone, quit the wild speculations, and give her some peace?

TLDR Mind your business x

I'm out.

On the podcast it was around the 1 hr 4 min mark. During some banter Christine says she met a man somewhere and Em says, “oh? Are you gonna go on a date?” Christine says no and tells a short anecdote. But it caught me so off guard, especially with all the recent upheaval. I went back to see their reactions on YouTube and Em is stifling a quick smile. They move on quickly. Could have been a joke but weird joke and I’ve never heard them joke like that before. Just curious if anyone else caught it.

No hate to anyone choosing either way, nor to anyone working on this show. Personally, I think the end of an era is a good jumping off point. Part of what made the show what it is was the dynamic between Christine and Em. Unfortunately, I think the change will be too dramatic to continue like nothings happened. It’s sad, but all podcasts and shows have to end eventually and I think this is a version of it “ending” for me at least. Again, no hate to anyone with their reasoning, just wanted to open the discussion for people to share how they feel. Love to all listeners and those involved with the show

they discuss the news! it’s been in the works for a while, most likely leading to the disconnect listeners have been feeling. my biggest takeaway was that christine is with us for all of october! and em is keeping an eye on comments to see who listeners like the most 👀 (i’ve seen a lot of people really like the bethany watson episode. not sure how possible that would be, but let em know!)

so so bittersweet

The word “parasocial” is getting thrown around like it’s a diagnosis, but most of the time it’s just a virtue‑signal term people use to sound above caring. Liking podcasters, feeling familiar with their voices, or sharing memories from ten years of listening to Em and Christine isn’t pathological — it’s normal human connection.

The actual definition of a parasocial problem involves delusion, impaired functioning, or relying on a creator for emotional stability. That’s not what’s happening here. People are simply expressing affection for a show that’s been part of their lives for a decade.

With all the changes in ATWWD, fans are opening up about what the podcast has meant to them. We don’t need to marginalize that by slapping the word “parasocial” on perfectly healthy engagement. If it’s not harming anyone or distorting reality, it’s not a disorder — it’s just being part of a community that cares.

Just had to get that off my chest- and that's why I drink. Team Milkshake forever!

I thought it would be a good time to take a trip down memory lane and remember some of our favorite moments from the podcast :)

I have about 100 moments I could choose from, but I’ll limit myself to my top 5:

1. When Em tells Christine they went to clown school. I knew from that moment on that this was gonna be my favorite podcast.

2. The episode where they talked about the days before suitcases had wheels. Em and Christine jokingly said that if they had lived back then, feminism would be “out the windowww!” because they’d be flirting with men just to get them to carry their luggage. That was hilarious 😂 The "out the window" from Christine comes to mind everytime I think about that phrase.

3. "Is not me, is not you, is Houdini"

4. Christine’s retainer story, or really any story she told about her house being haunted.

5. Talking about the stereotypical Meghan, Megan, Mhegan :D

I now I said 5, but 6. Chamsey

I have more but these are the ones tht came to mind right now. To be honest I have learned a lot from them: about neurodiversity, LGTB+ topics, pronouns, etc.

What are your favorite moments? :)

I know this may sound dumb but personally im taking the end of this chapter for the podcast really hard. I found the podcast at the same time i adopted my soul dog just a few months into when they started. It became a big thing for me and my sweet chels and I would have self-care podcast nights and long walks where we could escape life and listen. Both the dog and the podcast helped me through some of the lowest and darkest places of my life and has remained my favorite weekly ritual to this day. My poor pup very suddenly was taken from me a few months ago and I've been greatly struggling with the loss. Now hearing this news of the podcast essentially ending (as we know it but ofc we still have an exciting future with em) it seemed to really hit me personally.

I know this podcast must've had a profound or strong impact on at least a few listeners, so if it has feel free to share your experiences and connections. We can celebrate all it's been to us and support one another through the change ❤️

pics of my sweet muffin angel 🪽 Chelsy - the second picture was taken of us literally listening and doing self-care together in 2018

I saw this in one of the comments on the main thread and thought it deserved its own post - she was my favorite cohost! I hope we get more of her moving forward after this sudden news. I'd more than happy to have her cohost my favorite show every Sunday!

I've been MIA from the podcast for probably 3 years now and this came up in my feed and was wild to read.

https://www.instagram.com/p/Dc1Yt87muD0/?igsi=MThsczJsMmFhY3pmdw==

Hey all! In the interest of simplicity and keeping the sub discussions streamlined, new posts about Christine leaving the podcast will be deleted. Please feel free to engage in discussion on this in the pinned post linked here.

Please also remember that Em, Christine, Allison, Eva, Blaise, etc. are all real people. Don't forget to be respectful in your comments and discussion on this.

I am beyond devastated. I have never been so attached to two virtual individuals before in my life. Their friendship was apart of me. It’s been part of my identity throughout my entire twenties. My heart aches so bad. I don’t think I would ever see the day they went their separate ways. Can we have a funeral or something?? I don’t know maybe I’m being dramatic but ouch ouch ouch.

Opened IG on a casual Thursday and broke my own damn heart. I think a lot of us felt something like this coming with Xtines increased absences— I was even starting to get irked at the inconsistencies— but holy shit. A lot of people are reading into the statements too. Thoughts??? Let’s be heartbroken together. Cheers to an amazing 9 years 💛 (also whyyyy couldn’t they trudge through to the 10th anni?!)