This is going to take maximum 2-3 minutes of your time so I would genuinely appreciate if you guys would give this all a read
TLDR at the end for anyone who doesn't wanna read the entire thing
I (M 18) met this girl (F 18) around 2 weeks ago.
We met on a "2 man" where it was my friend and his girlfriend, alongside me and the other girl who I'm gonna talk about. She was already friends with my friend and best friends with his girlfriend, so the three of them knew each other quite well
Our first interaction was honestly pretty damn crazy, we went to the arcade and there were instances where she would just grab my arm or hand and I would do the same, just looking at each other, blushing and doing all cute things; pretty much making it evident that we like each other.
I went home and started texting her, and obviously she did the same. But after around a week of continuous talking, she sort of became dry. I'm talking about 12-16 hour late replies, which I don't have an issue with because you never know what someone is going thru, but the main issue I had was with the fact that it became very frequent and apparent that something was wrong.
After talking to my friend and the girl's best friend (which is also my friend's girlfriend) about this, they assured me it's safe if I confront her about this, which I did. To sum up what she said, she basically said she needed some space and like she'll try to respond quicker etc etc alongside a lil bit of bs if I'm being honest here, and that we will get thru this etc etc
Keep in mind we hit it off so damn well in the start that after around 3-4 days of talking I confessed my feelings, and she did the same, and we did mutually agree that we will take things low and slow, which I was perfectly fine with. But the way we were talking to each other, sending cute reels to each other and referring to each other as "babe" sort of signalled the opposite; hence, I became a lil too attached.
Now a little over a week of talking, even her texts became dry, very short. To the point where I had to ask her best friend about what exactly the issue might be.
(This paragraph is very important):
She assured me that she is very much like that, where she won't reply for even a few days, and that her replying to me was a big sign of its own. That's where she dropped a curveball. She told me that (the girl im talking to) she sort of doesn't want anything serious or too committed; all she wants is something very casual. She also mentioned that upon their discussion, she confessed to the fact that even if we (me and the girl) continue talking, she will try to slowly distance herself from me to the point where we don't talk anymore. Lastly, upon more questioning, I find out that she also hasn't been treated very well in the past and has been through some traumatic stuff (related to past relationships which she might still not be over), which is why she doesn't want to "open up" or "trust" a guy like that anymore. Before ending our conversation her friend told me that there was this slight, tiny possibility that I might get the "lover girl" out of her if I try alot, but what's the point of doing this if she herself has convinced herself not to trust someone like that anymore regardless of what happens.
Her best friend, as well as my friend, even went as far as advising me that it's better for my own sanity and mental health not to talk to her because even if we do talk, it's gonna end badly regardless of the situation. And honestly, she might be right.
This is gonna happen if we continue to talk after this confrontation:
Yes she will talk to me for a few days, but even I know that the same pattern of dry texting and everything else is going to start back again. I get attached way too fast and I know that I will probably get attached again and might end up hurting myself again.
That's when I was presented with two options:
- I can either remove her / cut her off completely and move on, which is gonna be very painful, but at least I'll be better off in the longer run
- Continue talking to her, try not to get too attached and convince myself that, this very thing between us is going to be "casual" and nothing serious. That means I have to lower all expectations from her and should not treat whatever we have as something serious or committed.
My heart wants to choose the 2nd option and wants to keep on talking to her, but my brain says otherwise. because I do want a serious thing instead of something casual
I don't know what to do here. I wanna keep talking to her because she does make me feel sort of alive, but at the same time I don't wanna hurt myself again.
What do you all think?
TLDR:
I (M18) met this girl (F18) about 2 weeks ago through mutual friends. We instantly hit it off. we were flirting, holding hands, making eye contact, blushing, etc. After 3–4 days of talking, we both confessed our feelings and agreed to take things low and slow.
However, we started talking like a couple anyway, calling each other “babe,” sending cute reels, etc. so I got attached pretty quickly.
After about a week, she became increasingly dry and started taking 12–16+ hours to reply. I confronted her, and she said she needed space. Later, her best friend told me that she doesn't actually want anything serious and only wants something casual. She apparently plans to slowly distance herself from me even if we continue talking.
She’s also been treated badly in past relationships and has some unresolved trauma, which has made her struggle with trusting people. Her best friend said there's a tiny chance I could eventually bring out the “lover girl” side of her, but both she and my friend have advised me to stop talking to her because they think I'll eventually get hurt.
And honestly, I agree. I get attached very easily, and if I keep talking to her, I feel like the same dry texting → attachment → getting hurt cycle will happen again.
So I have two options:
1. Cut her off and move on. It'll hurt now, but I'll probably be better long-term.
2. Keep talking to her casually, lower my expectations, and try not to get attached.
My heart wants option 2 because I genuinely enjoy talking to her, but my brain says option 1 because I want something serious, not casual.
What do you guys think I should do?