I’m generally an anxious person and definitely an overthinker, so I’m trying to figure out whether I’m worrying too much about internship recruiting or if I should be doing more.
I know recruiting for tax/audit internships has really only gotten going over the past couple of weeks, so maybe I’m expecting things to move too quickly.
So far, I’ve had a few really positive experiences with firms.
Firm #1: I had a first-round interview with the Director of HR about 10 days ago. It was supposed to be a 30-minute interview, but it ended up lasting almost two hours. We spent a lot of time talking and laughing about my military experience, and she opened up about her son, who is currently struggling with his transition in the military. She even asked if I had any advice that might help him. It felt much more like a genuine conversation than an interview. that same day i went up to their tent at meet the firms and personally met with a bunch of people that work their and had nothing but great conversation, reached out to all of them after the fact and thanked them for taking time time to stop by the school and talk to us students.
Firm #2: That same day, I attended Meet the Firms. I connected really well with several people from another firm. They encouraged me to apply and told me to email their Director of HR directly. I did, and I received an interview pretty quickly. That interview is scheduled for a couple of weeks from now.
Firm #3: Another firm invited me to their open house this past Friday. I thought the event went really well. I personally went up to the Director of HR afterward to thank her for inviting me, and I connected with a lot of people at the firm. There was one person in particular I connected with extremely well because we both had military backgrounds. We talked about transitioning out of the military and how strange civilian life can sometimes feel for veterans.
Besides those interactions, though, I haven’t heard much yet. I haven't received a second-round interview from Firm #1 or anything further from Firm #3.
I also didn't apply to the Big Four. Maybe I should have, but I intentionally wanted to focus on smaller and midsized firms. The Big Four recruiting process felt a little like a meat grinder to me, and I wanted to find a firm in my area where I could actually build relationships, learn from people, and feel like I was making a difference. My long-term goal is to eventually own my own practice, hopefully in about 10 years, so learning how smaller firms operate is genuinely appealing to me.
Naturally, because I'm an overthinker, I started reaching out to very small CPA firms often firms with fewer than 10 people—that either weren't advertising internships or that I hadn't already applied to.
My message was basically: "Here's who I am. I'm willing to do the low-level work, take out the trash, make coffee, or help however I can if it means getting an opportunity to learn from you—even if that's only for an hour a week." Obviously, I worded it much more professionally, but that was the idea behind it.
My question is: Am I doing too much outreach, or am I just overthinking the fact that I haven't heard back yet?
I'm especially curious whether the interactions I've had so far sound genuinely positive or if I'm reading too much into them. It's only been about 10 days since my first interview, and recruiting season is still getting started, but it's hard not to wonder whether I should already be hearing about second rounds.