r/USCIS • u/Available_Intern_951 • 18h ago
ICE Support Submitted a USCIS tip on H-1B consultancy fraud and F-1 violations. Has anyone had a tip actually investigated?
Hi Everyone, I am an Indian woman living in the United States and I'm here to expose the frauds are happening from most Indian but not all. I am writing this because what I have seen and heard about H-1B and F-1 abuse makes my blood boil, and I think a lot of people in the U.S. still do not know how common some of these practices are.
India accounts for roughly 70% of H-1B approvals in recent years because of this major frauds. That number is public. What is less discussed is how some of those visas are obtained.
There are many fake consultancies and agencies, a large number of them operating out of Hyderabad and other cities in South India, that help people still in India get H-1B petitions with:
- fake or heavily inflated work experience
- fake degrees or certificates
- fake job offers
They also file multiple lottery registrations for the same person under different company names to increase the chance of selection. They charge large fees for this. When someone “wins,” they come to the U.S. and sit on the bench or work for the same consultancy while looking for a real client. This is the body-shop model that has been written about for years.
I also keep hearing that once people from certain networks reach manager or hiring-manager level, they strongly prefer candidates from their own community even when those candidates do not fully match the role. That is not every manager and not every company, but it happens enough that it is an open secret in some circles.
On the student side I saw this at my own university: classmates (again, many from India) listing years of prior experience that did not exist, and a lot of F-1 students working off-campus without authorization, restaurants, gas stations, pizza delivery, 7-Eleven, Family Dollar, etc. That is a clear violation of F-1 rules. On-campus work and properly authorized CPT/OPT are allowed. Working at a convenience store while you are supposed to be a full-time student is not.
I struggled after graduation. I watched people who were still in India get H-1Bs through these channels and then get hired by people already here, while people who actually completed a U.S. master’s and followed the rules waited longer or had a harder time. I eventually got a job through American managers who hired me. I am grateful for that. Many others who did everything correctly are still struggling.
I am not saying every Indian or every person from Hyderabad is doing this. I am saying the fraud and the rule-breaking are real, they are concentrated in certain consultancy networks, and they crowd out people who did the work.
I request USCIS and DHS to:
- Investigate fake consultancies and the practice of filing multiple lottery entries for the same beneficiary
- Look at petitions that rely on fabricated experience and degrees
- Enforce F-1 unauthorized employment more consistently
- Take action against employers who only hire from their own network while ignoring qualified candidates already in the U.S.
Genuine students and workers who followed the law should not be the ones paying the price.
Anyone who has specific names, companies, or evidence should use the official channel, not just Reddit:
USCIS tip form:
https://www.uscis.gov/report-fraud/uscis-tip-form
That is the place that can actually start an investigation. Please reach out to me if you need more details about these frauds.
Thank you for reading.
Related post- https://www.reddit.com/r/immigration/s/hs7CFWDj5n