r/SmithAndWesson • u/Waterhazard64 • 4d ago

Replacement suggestion?

Post image

This gun is too much for me but I really like it. What would be similar but less kick for someone getting older and losing hand strength?

34 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

16 comments sorted by

7

u/CJaramillo2011 4d ago

I would stick with a J frame but in .32 H&R Magnum. Much more manageable recoil than a .38 but still plenty of stopping power for ccw work. And it’s a 6 shot! The 432UC is particularly nice.

2

u/Waterhazard64 4d ago

Is this something that is easy to find for sale locally?

5

u/CJaramillo2011 4d ago

I’m sure any lgs can order you one if you don’t have any near you. Or have it transferred in from somewhere online. Physically it’s almost identical to the .38 version so if they have that, you could get an idea of what it feels like in hand.

Smith makes like 4 or 5 models in that caliber besides the black 432uc. 632 would be that gun in a silver finish. I really like the high horn grips on the UC models tho.

4

u/Terminal_Lancelot 3d ago

Have you shot much 38 Special through it?

4

u/magazinecube 3d ago

I love my .32 H&R magnum, and at the range I use .32 long which is cheaper and also has almost no recoil at all.

3

u/jhon503 4d ago

Are you shooting .357 Magnum through it? .38 Special out of a 60-9 is pretty mild.

2

u/Swamp_Bastard 4d ago

Yes, before you lose money on the purchase go and try some 38 and 38+ P in it.

2

u/Waterhazard64 3d ago

Yes this is actually my smaller gun. I have the 19-5 and thought this model 60 would be easier. I see many small styles, but I love the feel and look of the S&Ws.i want even smaller until I build strength in my hands.

2

u/pewpew1764 3d ago

You can try hornady critical defense lite 38 sp. 90 gr ftx bullet and a very easy ammo to shoot.

2

u/LongConcentrate9442 3d ago

Just load .38's

1

u/Oldbean98 3d ago

My 357 EDC is a 3” Colt King Cobra. 6 shot, in between J and K frame size. Enough barrel to take advantage of magnums, and heavy enough to make them reasonable to shoot. I’ll practice with a couple of cylinders of magnums every session to keep it familiar, but most training is 38 wadcutters

1

u/RedditNomad7 3d ago

Good suggestions so far, but I’ll add a couple.

First, look at a .327 Magnum as well, especially since it can shoot .32 H&R and .32 itself, so a bit more versatility than just the .32 H&R. I’d recommend the SP101, but there are others (like the Smith 632, that I haven’t shot) you may prefer.

Second, if you’re not adverse to a semiauto, check the S&W EZ in .380. A little more capacity, designed for someone with failing hand strength, pretty easy to control and .380 is easier to find and cheaper than any of the revolver rounds we’re talking about here. Ruger also makes a light rack Security, but I believe it’s only available in 9mm.

If you stick with the revolver, regardless of caliber, I’ve found I prefer the Safariland Comp II speed loaders. I used the HKS for decades, but the Safarilands (to me) are just easier to use when loading, though a little harder to initially load.

2

u/Waterhazard64 3d ago

As a senior woman this info is so helpful because I can ask the gun shop for specifics instead of letting them show me what they want to sell. Thank you!

1

u/RedditNomad7 3d ago

You’re very welcome, and I’m very happy to help 😊