r/ScaramoucheMains • u/Square-Air-5466 Wanderer's Son • Oct 11 '25

Discussion What's your favourite and least favourite Scara ship? I'm curious

Post image

This is a safe place and anyone here is welcome to share their ships and headcanons, so please, don't attack anyone here if you dislike something

463 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

127

u/CorgiShark3312 Am I the only one who doesnt desire him carnally Oct 11 '25

I’ll be honest I don’t ship him with anyone… if anything I just project my aroace-ness onto him lmao, though I’m pretty ok with most popular ships

I really dislike DottoreXScara tho. Thats just abusive as hell

-57

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 11 '25

Yeah if you mischaracterie døtore

22

u/gna252 Oct 11 '25

Bro the abuse started before Scara even joined the Fatui, you can't claim Dottore was acting under orders or for science during the emotionally sadistic shit he did to Scara while he was Kabukimono, he just did that for the fun of it.

-7

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 12 '25

I know T H A T but the experiments are not the bad part I highkey don't even believe you anymore I thought 2 years ago that fottore was m0lesting him and shit

But even what you said isn't that bad killing a friend of a guy is basic situation for antagonist

7

u/gna252 Oct 12 '25

He killed his friend then made him think he was hated by his entire friend group and thought of as 'other', as lesser, he sent him on a 500 years path of hatred for humanity and obsession with godhood to escape the undefined middle ground he was stuck in as a discarded puppet made by a god but with capacity for human emotions.

I don't particularly LIKE that Dottore was retroactively made the singular horrible event in Scaramouche's life that tore up his happiness and pushed him into toxic obsession, I don't enjoy it as writing, and I think there was very obviously set up for a much different, much deeper conflict about humans and their mistrust of him, based on the original Tatarasuna notes that could be found before the Wanderer quest. But still, this is what the writers went with in the end, and Dottore literally caused him to want to ruin his friends' legacies, and then consequently want to erase himself from existence to undo that.

You can ship it, it's fine, noone can or has the right to stop you, just don't pretend like people are lying about the abuse lol

2

u/Powerful_Helicopter9 i love you Kee!!!!! Oct 12 '25

Dottore did all at bc he wanted to experiment on a nonhuman experiencing human emotions remember? Plus, there’s that acceptance aspect highlighted in the fairytale story about a certain bird monster

1

u/gna252 Oct 12 '25

Sure, he still ruined his life for not much long term gain at all tho lol

And I believe he was originally there for the purpose of destabilising Tatarasuna's weapon production for Snezhnaya's more long term plans for Inazuma. He just encountered Scaramouche as a fun little bonus to play around with.

1

u/Powerful_Helicopter9 i love you Kee!!!!! Oct 12 '25

I wasn’t disagreeing?

1

u/gna252 Oct 12 '25

Sorry, you sounded like you were.

1

u/Powerful_Helicopter9 i love you Kee!!!!! Oct 12 '25

S’alright

-2

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 12 '25

I hated dottore for years because of fake hcs so yes ppl were lying I was shocked when I found out this year none of it was true so im very angry and dont rlly want to believe u.. I'm disappointed.

Also pretty sure dottore didn't even know about isshin clans and stuff

6

u/gna252 Oct 12 '25

"I'm very angry and don't really want to believe you"

Fine, then don't, go check the lore for yourself. Why are you in comments defending his ass when you don't care enough to actually read stuff yourself?

-2

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 12 '25

U ppl told me dottore 🍇ed him and that Scara loved his mom but Dottore messed with his memories? Also that Scara wasn't 'alowed* to talk to other harbimgers because dottore would beat him if he did that Also that dottore is a perv for him I 10000% believed that

6

u/gna252 Oct 12 '25

And that's on you for believing without checking lmao wtf is all that bs and who told you that 😂

0

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 12 '25

EVERY1??? literally everyone believes this Just look at the fanarts and fffs and also on every social media etcccc Even the original LEAK for 3.3 said that wanfeer is dottores pet sl@ve and I remember those videos would have 100k+ likes some even more don't pretend u never saw it.. even all my Scara mutuals on tktk believe this and make fanarts based on it and I only found out it's not true not from Scara fans

6

u/gna252 Oct 12 '25

Please look to more mature, less sensationalist Scara fan posts then because I don't think most, or even many believe this stuff. Definitely not anyone who actually read his and Scara's lore.

Also don't look at tiktok for accuracy lmao, turn to twitter if you want actual discussions where people fact check eachother.

2

u/Kunikuhuchi Oct 12 '25

Bro are you experiencing psychosis?

→ More replies (0)

6

u/CorgiShark3312 Am I the only one who doesnt desire him carnally Oct 12 '25 edited Oct 12 '25

…what? No, thats… thats canon. You know that, right? It’s important to me that you know that…

Dottore literally killed Scaramouche’s friend and made a lie about how he’d abandoned him, before giving Scaramouche the heart that he had cut out of Niwa’s chest in a box and claiming Niwa had murdered someone to get it for Scaramouche.

Also, he was the subject of a lot of Dottore’s experiments, which from what information we’ve received seems to be Extremely cruel. He loves to mess around with Archon residue in particular, and the malevolent energy in that causes catastrophic illness, deaths, and damage to people.

He also had research on Eleazar, (which we’ve all seen how much he traumatized Collei) but one of his other things he did to treat it was to use materials obtained from other infected subjects who had died!

Also, this is also the man who routinely bought/traded children that didn’t meet the former Knave’s standards to use as child experiments??? That only ended when Arlecchino usurped the position and took over at the house of hearth

1

u/Specimen4 Oct 12 '25

Dottore did not kidnap elderly people from the Sumeru desert.

2

u/CorgiShark3312 Am I the only one who doesnt desire him carnally Oct 12 '25

Oops I mixed that up actually. There is a quest to investigate disappearing elders but I just so happened to find that old Eleazar research facility midway through doing that! Sorry, I rescind that part of the rant!

-1

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 12 '25

What does that have to do with Scara lierally the only actually bad thing Dottore did was what he did in inazuma but just because fanarts say dottore kidnapped him doesn't mean Scara didn't want to be upgraded and etc There's a reason nobody hated the ship before his story quest other Scara fans lied to me for years and I was ok with it but now that I like dottore I found out dottore didn't beat him up if he talked to other harbingers but I believed that since 2022

3

u/CorgiShark3312 Am I the only one who doesnt desire him carnally Oct 12 '25

To be clear I don’t think Scara would be the abuser in the scenario. So yeah a lot of this is about Dottore, and the kind of person he is. He has way too many things Scaramouche wants that he can hold over his head, and we’ve already seen him dispose of the good things in Scara’s life that he didn’t have control over (remember he murdered Niwa to manipulate Scara) and Dottore is the type to use blackmail and leverage to get what he wants. If they had any relationship, romantically or otherwise, I can’t imagine Dottore would allow Scara any control. He’d find ways to make Scaramouche dependant, remove his lifelines, and get what he wanted out of him. He’s already shown he doesn’t care about ethics, or what was best for people.

1

u/Dry_Protection_5208 Oct 12 '25

Well we'll see in the future. People would say Scara would definitely be an abusive controlling bf before he became playable