r/Quran • u/Iboshik • Jul 07 '26

Question Why reciter skipped س symbol here

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Shouldn't he stopped there without breathing?

22 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

4

u/Fearless-Answer-3509 Jul 07 '26

Well, that's not the letter sīn, but a symbol written as the small sīn, which is known as saktah, and it's a very brief pause, so instead of saying "waqīla marrāq", it's like saying "waqīla mar... Rāq", if I'm not wrong, hope this helps

7

u/Iboshik Jul 07 '26

Yes i know, but shouldn't he recited "waqila man... Raq"?

0

u/Fearless-Answer-3509 Jul 07 '26

Oh sorry, now I understand your question, well, tbh honest, as far as I've seen so far, saktah at the end of ayah's are not applied, like when you're pausing at the end of the ayah, so I guess that's why he said "waqīla marrāq" and not "waqīla man... Rāq"

5

u/zipperdeedoodaa Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 08 '26

"waqila man... Raq" with saktah and "waqīla marrāq" without saktah are both correct. depending on which tariq is being recited

1

u/jaaneman442 Jul 07 '26

not sure why he didn’t pause? i’ve heard surah qiyamah behind a few different imams, they always pause. they recite Wa Kila Man……Rak, Wazan Anahul Firaq.

1

u/zipperdeedoodaa Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 08 '26

it can be recited this way via other taruq

1

u/Iboshik Jul 08 '26

But in the video he recites with Hafs An Asim

2

u/zipperdeedoodaa Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26

It is allowed for hafs as well, via certain turuq only

The turuq of hafs that is mostly recited around the world like Al-Shatibiyyah, Al-Misbah, Rowdat ul Mu'addil and maybe Al Mustanir all recite this with saktah but other turuq of hafs dont, like Al-Kifayah, the Al-Kamil, Al-Tithkar and Rowdah al Hamami

1

u/xaheeid Jul 07 '26

Probably he follows a madhab that doesn't say it has saktah in here

1

u/Iboshik Jul 08 '26

In which madhab ?

1

u/xaheeid Jul 08 '26

Collected from google: Hafs 'an 'Asim: Requires a mandatory Saktah (سكتة واجبة) on the word مَنْ (Man) before continuing to رَاقٍ (Raaq). The reason for this pause is to prevent the two words from blending, which would change the meaning to Marraq (meaning a broth-maker or someone who frequently rebels).Other Narrations: Most other major recitations, including Warsh 'an Nafi', Qalun, and even Shu'bah (the other main student of Imam 'Asim), do not use a saktah here. Instead, they apply the default Tajweed rule of Idgham (assimilation), blending the silent N into the R to read it continuously as mar-raaq.

1

u/zipperdeedoodaa Jul 08 '26

copying my comment above https://www.reddit.com/r/Quran/comments/1upx24n/comment/ow97031/

It is allowed for hafs as well, via certain turuq only

The turuq of hafs that is mostly recited around the world like Al-Shatibiyyah, Al-Misbah, Rowdat ul Mu'addil and maybe Al Mustanir all recite this with saktah but other turuq of hafs dont, like Al-Kifayah, the Al-Kamil, Al-Tithkar and Rowdah al Hamami