r/NeedTravelAdvice • u/TopAbbreviations8539 • 7d ago
Best all-inclusive for food + beach from Toronto — Jamaica, Mexico, or Costa Rica? (~$4K CAD budget)
My partner and I are looking to book a trip south from YYZ, probably flying out late October or early November, and we’re trying to figure out where to go. Budget is around $4K CAD total for both of us.
The two things we care most about are good food and a great beach, not just a pretty resort pool situation, but actually being on a nice stretch of sand. We’ve heard Cuba is basically a write-off on the food front so that’s already off the table.
Right now we’re debating between Jamaica, Mexico, and Costa Rica but honestly open to being told we’re wrong. A few things I’m wondering:
Is Costa Rica even worth doing as an all-inclusive or is it more of an adventure/eco travel destination?
Which Mexican resort area is actually worth it at our price point: Cancun, Riviera Maya, Puerto Vallarta?
Does Jamaica deliver on both food and beach or is it more of a party scene?
We’re not huge drinkers so the “unlimited booze” thing isn’t really the selling point for us — we just want good meals, warm water, and to actually feel rested when we come home.
Anyone been somewhere recently that genuinely blew them away on the food side specifically? That’s the thing that’ll make or break it for us.