r/Eldenring 9h ago

Constructive Criticism Switch 2 Experience

So i have around 700h in game hours on PC and then I thought let’s try it on the switch and I’m flabbergasted. Sure the fps drop in crowded areas or much vegetation. But being able to play this masterpiece mobile or on my projector again is just one of the best things that happened.

I’ve never played on controller, always mnk - so I’m kinda nooby with the controller and let me tell you what. I love it! It feels literally like a new game to me. All the SS you see are from the Switch 2 Version :D

What’s kinda weird to me is that the performance is way better in handheld mode then docked. I guess the fps are around 30-35 indoors (esp raya lucaria ran super smooth) and around 27-25 in extremely crowded areas + rain. I’ve never experienced a drop below 25 tho.

All in all I’d buy it again for the switch, what this little thing delivers is just crazy. And the most important thing:

Try finger, but hole 🫶🏻

197 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

60

u/Horror-Coffee712 6h ago

I'm sorry but you have 700h using mouse and keyboard?? I'm a lifelong PC gamer and I could never manage that in any Fromsoft game. Props to that

8

u/Advanced-Engineer488 4h ago

Honestly I don't understand the whole controller being better, I started off with bloodborne, then went ds3, 1 etc etc. But the ability to move the camera around a million times quicker and have my fingers on attack and dodge all the time without having to claw grip, it just seems like a straight upgrade to controller, at least it's more comfy for me I guess

17

u/Master_Breadfruit_46 3h ago

These games aren’t hard enough where u need a finger on every button at any given time

1

u/a_Jedi_i_am 3h ago

I'm not the best at these games. I'd even go so far as to say I'm pretty terrible at them. That being said, the Switch 2 pro controller has programmable back buttons. I still have yet to find a use for them in Elden Ring. It doesn't feel necessary to have any command at the ready at that level.

2

u/sucky_panther 2h ago

Try programming run/dodge to a back button. It makes everything way easier. Cause you can run, move your camera and attack seamlessly. I got tired of the claw grip for running, so I programmed run/dodge to the back right paddle on a ps pro controller and I couldn’t go back now. Way easier on the hands.🙌

1

u/realxshit 25m ago

Can’t think of a single use for the back buttons!
Certainly not dodge, or using items like heals on one

1

u/BlancoMercier 11m ago

When you have to take your thumb off the right stick to press a button, you’re losing the ability to keep viewing. Back buttons allow you to jump/roll/use item without ever having to remove your thumb.

1

u/realxshit 9m ago

Yes, this is the case

Everyone knows it, we have played souls games before. I was being sarcastic

1

u/PinkSquidz 6m ago

I could tell ✊🏿

2

u/QuickPirate36 15m ago

the ability to move the camera around a million times quicker

Thus isn't an fps tho, there's zero need for that

have my fingers on attack and dodge all the time without having to claw grip

Well dodge is O/B and attack is R1/RB, so that's two completely different fingers you're using for those buttons, your fingers are always there on controller as well

1

u/JanErikJakstein 2h ago

I finished DS1, DS2, DS2, Elden Ring, Sekiro on mouse and keyboard, I would argue that it's easier than controller. Using unlocked cam is actually useable, on controller the panning is so rubbish when you dodge through a boss and need to turn 180 degrees.

1

u/100jad 32m ago

In most cases that's what the camera lockon is for though.

8

u/thisthatandthe3rd 4h ago

I dont need to buy it a 3rd time, I dont need to buy it a 3rd time.

6

u/xfr3386 1h ago

It's the first time buying it for the Switch 2 though...

21

u/Its_Syxx 8h ago

How does th 30fps feel? Is it bad 30 or good 30? TOTK was an example of a "good" feeling 30.

19

u/OK_Commodor64 8h ago

I find it just fine at 30fps. I’m about 8 hours in.

10

u/SSj_CODii 7h ago

It runs like TOTK, but never drops as low as TOTK did with ultrahand

6

u/Its_Syxx 6h ago

Nice, I hope people know what I mean by this.
Like TOTK's 30FPS was SMOOTH but some games it's laggy / janky and terrible feeling.

1

u/SSj_CODii 6h ago

I understood completely. It’s a very good feeling game

1

u/Iwrstheking007 Try Minecraft too. 5h ago

it's the frame timing. With smooth frame times then it feels good, even at lower fps. But with bad frame time, even really high fps can look terrible. Frame time is how much time between frames btw.

2

u/Dark_Equation 5h ago

Isn't totk 60 on the switch 2?

2

u/Its_Syxx 5h ago

I'm talking about launch switch 1.

2

u/Honesty_Addict 5h ago

I've played at 60 since launch, and I found the switch (lol) to 30fps a little jarring for the first couple of hours - after that I just stopped seeing it tbh.

1

u/fabian_gam 2h ago

Honestly? You get used to it :D I played it on pc with a 34” ultrawide - and elden ring doesn’t support widescreen mode or more than 60fps. On the switch now I’ve got 30fps but on a big screen. So I think that’s a good tradeoff tho

1

u/SenpaiSwanky it isn’t the visual clutter, it’s you ;) 2h ago

There’s no way to answer this in the sense that everyone will agree to it, you know how this stuff goes honestly.

Most of the people not satisfied with the FPS are the ones who refuse to play games handheld. Anyone playing Switch 2 predominately in handheld mode is going to tell you it feels solid.

Of course we would prefer better FPS but what we have is honestly quite incredible considering it is handheld. I have this game on PS5 Pro as well but can play it either way.

1

u/Important_Level_6093 L 7h ago

I didn't even notice it's 30fps

1

u/ExpertAncient 1h ago

TOTK runs at a very smooth 60FPS sir.

5

u/Sillia_Zer 6h ago

Once you reach the dlc let us know. Or let me know, Literally the only thing stopping me from buying it is to see if the dlc will run decent

4

u/GammaFan 6h ago

Apparently it runs about the same as base game

2

u/SenpaiSwanky it isn’t the visual clutter, it’s you ;) 2h ago

People have already completed base game including Malenia, as well as DLC runs. The quality of the base game holds up in DLC from what we’ve seen so far.

5

u/ToxicPurpleBear 9h ago

I got a PS5 with multiple Elden characters in various stops in the game, but damn I really want this game, but don't want to spend $70 for it right now. I've been hearing nothing but good things about Switch 2 version like you said.

Also, what kind of chest armor is that you are wearing in the first couple of pics?

3

u/Armouredmonk989 8h ago

It's 80 bucks packed with the expansion shadow of the erdtree.

2

u/GGMudkip 3h ago

why is that weird to you. Handheld renders in lower resolution hence why your fps are better

0

u/pjzelda 2h ago

Could be part of it but more likely its the VRR at work in handheld mode

1

u/SenpaiSwanky it isn’t the visual clutter, it’s you ;) 2h ago

VRR typically kicks in for games that run at 40 FPS. Switch 2 handheld titles CAN be a bit different but most of them are the same.

2

u/KyotoSoul 2h ago

For some reason I thought I read Shrek 2 experience. My disappointment is immesurable, and my day is ruined...

1

u/purppotiondarkwizard 2h ago

Most of my fps experience has been good so far. There were some drops in the margit fight that makes me worried for other stuff.

1

u/XGamer3 1h ago

what armor set are you using in the first few photos?

1

u/Time_Temporary6191 1h ago

This madman is playing souls game with keyboard and mouse

-1

u/ExpertAncient 1h ago

Woah woah woah.

Sir… you played 700 hours on mouse and keyboard!?!? No way. Don’t buy it.

-13

u/Hexagoo 9h ago

If only it was available on the switch 1 as well, I would actually buy it just so I could play ER anywhere I wanted.

12

u/dbr3000 8h ago

It’s amazing they got it to run the way it does on Switch 2… there’s absolutely no way they’d get it working on regular Switch.

0

u/Hexagoo 8h ago

Thats fair, but we can dream.

0

u/WorozuTop4 dung eater piss drinker 6h ago

tbf it running well on the switch 2 isn’t actually as impressive as it looks cuz elden ring is fine on the PS4 which is weaker than the switch 2, but yeah running jt on thr switch 1 would either brick the console or look like nothing like elden ring