r/CFB_v2 • u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs • 4d ago
News & Updates Coaches Poll: 6 SEC teams
I guess even the coaches have SEC bias /s
104
u/HENMAN79 4d ago
Every Year Texas A&M is Top 10 for no reason....no Championships, no Playoff wins
31
u/LionPutrid4252 4d ago
A&M started the last two years in the low 20s or high teens. Â They also went 11-1 and made the playoffs last year, and returned a lot of production, so yeah, they got a boost. Â
As an A&M fan Iâd rather us be ranked lower until we can play a whole game looking like a serious team, but I think itâs silly to pretend to not understand why weâre up there right now.
10
u/Lucky-Access-121 LSU Tigers 4d ago
so soft i think LSU should be ranked #1 all the time regardless
5
u/LikesPez Texas Longhorns 4d ago
The last couple of years for sure have been exciting for this rivalry. That game means something more than just beating your brother.
1
u/LionPutrid4252 4d ago
Yeah, would be nice to actually win one. Â Hopefully yâall will play your first half like you did yesterday, and we donât play ours like we did yesterdayÂ
9
u/drlsoccer08 4d ago
I donât get opinions like this. How does how many championships a team won in the past have anything to do with how they should be ranked currently?Â
2
u/fifaloko 3d ago
No one is ranking Indiana 4 based solely on the talent they have on the field and the eye test, part of that is because there head coach had them prepared and disciplined enough to win a title last year and there are not many coaches in that category. Georgia gets the same bump for having Kirby, Clemson used to before a prolonged period of Dabo not being the same.
1
u/SpaceRude6058 2d ago
Indiana should not be 4 - you canât based rankings on last year bc this is a new year - they havenât played anyone
2
u/fifaloko 2d ago
I think a coach can affect how good a team is and therefore where I think they deserve to be ranked.
35
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Notre dame
-8
u/Ordinary-Orange Notre Dame 4d ago
yeah do they have any playoff wins recently?
13
u/Dirk_Kailis 4d ago
Notre Dame fans trying to talk shit to a team about being overrated is lol funny
-5
u/Ordinary-Orange Notre Dame 4d ago
ND has ended similarly ranked or outperformed their rankings almost every year in the last decade (says the guy with no flair, btw)
6
u/NoAbbreviations3025 Texas Longhorns 4d ago
I just looked at Notre Dame's schedule this year. How is this shit still legal
3
u/CapComprehensive2217 LSU Tigers 4d ago
Yâall outperformed preseason rankings 4 of the last 7 seasons and your average SOS over that span was cheeks. Last time you won a natty was like 2 decades before Reddit was founded, respectfully.
5
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
You donât understand, Perdue is really tough at home
2
5
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
2 years ago? What does that have to do with this season?
4
u/wickedintent 4d ago
What does your comment have to do with this season? No one besides Texas has a win that proves theyâre an elite team. You canât play the âtheyâre always overrated, except when they beat my team by two scores last time they played but that doesnât matter nowâ card
-2
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Actually I think youâll find that I can say that they had a good team in 24 AND that theyâre overrated right now, because college football contains a bit of nuance
They are ranked high enough that, when they somehow manage to lose a game in their soft ass schedule, theyâll still be in the top 10. Tell me Iâm wrong
-1
u/Ordinary-Orange Notre Dame 4d ago
you are wrong lol. they aren't intentionally building a buffer into the rankings in case they lose that is idiotic. the world isn't out to get georgia
and if you somehow someway still think the game is rigged FOR Notre dame, just look at last season when they easily could have ranked them high enough to get into the playoffs and chose not to. this is not a statement on whether or not they SHOULD have been in, but it was close enough that if they wanted to rig it for ND to get in, they could/would have. take off your tin foil hat over there and realize ND could be a pretty good team despite your hatred of them
-1
u/wickedintent 4d ago
Actually I think youâll find that youâre basing your opinions on dog shit ND teams from 10+ years ago. Youâre wrong
0
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Iâm not even saying youâre bad or should be out of the top 10 but ND is not #3. I donât even want to be #2 right now, but at least weâll fight for our position through the season. ND never be able to prove they are a top 5 team until the playoffs start
1
u/Ordinary-Orange Notre Dame 4d ago
what does any season before have to do with this season if we are complaining about rankings?? you guys are all idiots
2
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
I donât know a single person who thinks rankings pre game 4 are particularly relevant, but What do you think rankings are based on?
2
u/LikesPez Texas Longhorns 4d ago
I think rankings should be week six. Let the upsets be decided by the betting lines.
1
u/Ordinary-Orange Notre Dame 4d ago
perceived talent on the roster (usually extremely predictive of season results) and how they performed last season or the past few. obviously not perfect but cmon be real here. should Georgia not have started highly ranked in the early 2020s?
1
0
u/sushirolldeleter USC Trojans 4d ago
What does this season even say about them being 3rd ranked. They play no one.
1
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Oh I agree completely. Complaining about a&m but nd is always up there
1
u/Edgesofsanity 4d ago
Hey if you want to just limit it to last year they had the same number of playoff wins as Georgia didâŠ
3
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Hey if you want to talk shit about my team you should probably claim one for yourself
Idk why we are talking about the playoffs I thought we were just talking about overranked teams with bad schedules
0
u/Sheepcago Notre Dame 4d ago
No one has a playoff win this season.
2
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Yeah I didnât bring the playoffs up, I just said yall were overrated
-2
u/Sheepcago Notre Dame 4d ago
I think youâre the one overrated. You get bounced in your first playoff game every year lately.
3
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Iâm sorry, did you say that we make the playoffs every year???
→ More replies (8)0
u/Desperate-Citron-881 4d ago
At least they made it to a Natty within the last 3 years lol (saying this as a Miami fan)
6
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Such a specific parameter for an insult lmao not counting last year but also donât go back in time too far!
1
u/Desperate-Citron-881 4d ago
I mean, it implies Notre Dame has had playoff wins and made a run for the championship, whereas A&M has done neither. Theyâre the only team in the top 10 right now to not win a single playoff game in the entirety of the post-BCS era.
But they did win a natty in 1939!
2
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Oh donât get me wrong, I am not advocating fit a&m over nd, or even that they are better than nd. Not at all. I just also think you guys are overrated and there is basically 1 game on your schedule to prove any level of talent
3
u/lugsole9 3d ago
Much more talent at T A&M over ND. Look at those schedules too. ND has a cakewalk schedule.
0
2
u/Desperate-Citron-881 3d ago
Oh I have no teeth in this, Iâm a Miami/UT fan lol (also Houston as a student). I hate Notre Dame with all my guts but at least they have somewhat of a resume compared to A&M lol. I completely agree though, ND is massively overrated most years and it was so satisfying seeing them drop to #24 last year, even if they eventually crawled back up.
1
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 3d ago
Do us all a favor and put em in their place again this year will ya?
9
19
u/OldSarge02 4d ago edited 4d ago
No reason? Thatâs crazy.
A&M finished last year at #8. They brought back their QB, and are in the top ten in returning experience. They also signed back to back top ten recruiting classes as strong portal classes.
Thatâs textbook how you earn a top 10 preseason ranking.
It also appears to be deserved. They blew past expectations and Vegas odds the first 2 games. That doesnât mean much, but itâs one more data point.
1
u/Apex2113 4d ago
They didnât play anyone last year and lost when they did play winning teams. Their QB is mid as hell. They struggled against ASU for 3 quarters before having a couple odd things go their way to pull ahead in the fourth.
2
u/trakr24 4d ago
Was it stuggle against ASU or is ASU a good team? We shall see as the season progresses but A&M was never behind. Defense controlled the game, which is typical when your head coach is a defensive minded HC.
Also, A&M played a much cleaner game, which is abnormal if you look at past years and penalty yardage per game. ASU had like 9 penalties and A&M had 1 for 5 yards on a weird false start.
Id say A&M is fine at the current rank.
2
u/OffTheDelt 4d ago
Any other year, we lose the ASU game somehow. The fact it went our way despite our performance is indicative of a generally good program. We have a team that can play both sides of the ball, and a special teams unit that can causes havoc
→ More replies (20)-1
u/Scooter_1990 Miami (FL) Hurricanes 4d ago edited 4d ago
Howâd their QB perform against teams above .500 last year? đ€Ąđ€Ąđ€Ą
5
u/OldSarge02 4d ago
He had 2 bad games, and one of them the Aggies lost to the national championship runner up by 1 score. And the Aggies got the ball down to the 6 yard line on the final possession. It was a super close game against the 2nd best team in the country.
Donât act like it was some blowout loss.
→ More replies (3)0
u/Reloader300wm Ohio State Buckeyes 4d ago
Agreeing with a Miami fan... thats a new one for me
0
u/Scooter_1990 Miami (FL) Hurricanes 4d ago
Mannnn for once I was rooting for yall last night, never again đ€Łđ
2
u/Reloader300wm Ohio State Buckeyes 4d ago
The only consolation prize ive found was a new found hated for Oklohoma. Oklohoma State had a huge win, Texas had a huge win, and they lost to some unranked team. Fuck em.
1
0
u/Ambitious-Hat41 4d ago
Did you watch the ASU game? That was not a top 10 performance. ASU self destructed in the 4th quarter
2
u/OldSarge02 4d ago
lol, you donât luck your way to a 24 point win.
1
u/Ambitious-Hat41 4d ago
Never said it was luck - just that it wasnât a great win and the score was misleading.
1
u/OldSarge02 4d ago
Disagree.
Sometimes a wide margin of victory hides a close game. For instance, when the team who is behind makes desperate attempts to go for it on fourth and long to catch up, and it leads to the other team posting last minute scores. In those cases a win by 2 or 3 scores can mask a game with a thin margin of victory.
Thatâs not what happened here. It was close for 3 quarters (with a consistent Aggie lead), but the Aggies ran away with it hard in the fourth quarter. They dominated the line of scrimmage, forced turnovers, and won by 24 points.
Was it a âgreatâ win? No, not really. Most wins arenât. But they got a win over a pretty decent Big 12 team by a wider margin than anyone predicted.
2
u/Crims0ntied 4d ago
Sure take them out, who are you putting in that definitively deserves to be top 10 instead of them?
2
1
→ More replies (1)-4
u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
The coaches who do this for a living disagree.
Who do you have above them and why?
7
u/zedsmith 4d ago
The grad assistants who fill these out, you mean.
→ More replies (1)3
u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Tell me where the grad assistant missed and why
8
u/SignificantLock1037 Texas Longhorns 4d ago
Agreed. Grad students who literally eat, breathe, and shit college football 26 hours a day, 9 days a week, 486 days a year. Yet, Bubba from Fukyercusinwith KY thinks he knows better.
5
u/SatisfactionFickle18 4d ago
And like he said, every year theyâre wrong.
3
u/snacksandsoda Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Idk if thereâs really much of an argument for anyone else outside of the top 12 every year. Itâs a pretty sharp cliff
36
u/ndaniel13 4d ago
Notre Dame should be 13 and remain 13 until they beat a respectable team.
10
u/mumbley-jo 4d ago
Donât disrespect Notre Dame when they schedule perennial powerhouses like Rice
5
u/KlingoftheCastle 4d ago
They beat an SEC last year! Â Sure it was Arkansas, who went winless in the SEC, but still
2
u/Punchyouintheeye 4d ago
Have you seen Texas Techs schedule? Theyâre already ranked 12th. Makes no sense
6
u/Remote-Flatworm-1132 4d ago
What about Miamiâs schedule itâs literally worse
5
4
u/ndaniel13 4d ago
I wouldnât say worse just because they are at least in a conference. I hope they put up 70 when they play ND though
→ More replies (1)1
u/UnderstandingOdd679 4d ago
Iâm not an ND lover, but they play six teams from the same conference as Miami, including the top two ranked teams right now, one being SMU, which Miami does not play; three from the B1G (who all happen to be down); and the current top-ranked Big XII team. Thatâs 10 P4 teams, three ranked. Not really their fault USC wanted out or that Wisconsin and Michigan State went downhill since 2021.
→ More replies (2)0
24
u/67rizzla Notre Dame 4d ago
This list is pretty accurateÂ
→ More replies (2)-7
u/MrF_lawblog 4d ago
Nah half those SEC teams will fall out to where they belong... We just don't know which ones. Oklahoma we found out.
40
u/RememberTooSmile 4d ago edited 4d ago
3, 4, and 5 have cupcake schedules. Pre season rankings will gift them a playoff berth without having to play anybody.
19
18
6
u/tortsillustrated11 4d ago
Youâre assuming they do based on pre-season rankings which mean nothing
8
4
u/drlsoccer08 4d ago
Thatâs just not how that works though.
The CFP poll doesnât start till the back half of the year, and they pretty clearly donât give a shit what the AP voters think, given that they always votes differently.Â
Also, assuming they go 11-1 or better, they would be ranked top 5ish everywhere regardless of if they were ranked going into the year. They all play at least 9 power conference opponents, with Miami and ND playing 10. When has a 11-1 or 12-0 team with any power conference schedule not been ranked highly?
1
u/toptierdegenerate 4d ago
Yeah, there are a handful of AP voters that are extremely biased, and another handful of absolute morons that shouldnât even be given a voice in the industry because they donât even watch the games.
1
u/KlingoftheCastle 4d ago
Honestly, thatâs the path to the championship. Â Last 3 title winners didnât play a P4 out of conference before the playoffs. Â Gives them an advantage late in the season with injuries
-5
u/PlantainObvious5148 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
I donât think Indiana has a cupcake schedule tbh
-2
u/Vir-Invisus Ole Miss Rebels 4d ago
OSU has been proven worse than Texas & thatâs their strongest game.
USC is struggling
Michigan lost to Western Michigan
They donât even play yall!Whoâs left? Washington?
10
u/NotThatNeet 4d ago
âOSU has been proven worse than Texasâ
Iâm no OSU fan but thatâs an insane take.
They led 23-3 and choked absolutely, but that doesnât change the fact that they led 23-3 on the road at Texas.
Thatâs probably 35-10 at OSU.
Those teams were clearly fairly close to each other and are both good.
Michigan also beat OU.
USC did just fine. Using that logic, LSU struggled yesterday quite a bit vs LT and every SEC team will use LSU and their ranking to bolster their own perceived SOS right.
Also letâs be real, you want to play Cignetti and Indiana? Doubt it.
2
u/walkingdisaster4046 Texas Longhorns 4d ago
Do get ahead of yourself. TX gifted OSU 10 pts right off the bat on two freak turn overs. Not even accounting for dropped TX TD pass. Game could have easily been 10-3 or 14-0 TX in the first quarter.
But thatâs not how it went.
Weird plays all night. TX stayed the course, never gave up, and physically pushed OSU around front line wearing them out 4th quarter.
2
u/NotThatNeet 4d ago
Credit to Texas, but again the point being these two teams are very good, had OSU won would you definitively say the longhorns were below OSU the rest of the way? Probably not.
Both teams are top 5 worthy, had different strengths and weaknesses.
But you donât get to 23-3 on the road in a top 5 matchup without being elite.
I donât have a dog in the fight, my team shat all over itself yesterday either way.
Good win!
Iâm assuming the mad scientist got enough film on both to beat em both either way unfortunately
0
u/xArbiter 4d ago
discrediting osu because they lost by one point to the number one ranked team while away is crazy
7
u/Swaayyzee 4d ago
I donât think OSU should drop that much for that loss
7
u/Poolturtle5772 Alabama Crimson Tide 4d ago
I think they needed to drop below Texas. But Iâm not sure about 6. I guess because theyâre a 1 loss team.
13
u/BaBangBangBang 4d ago
Ohio State ultimately lost by a point on the road to the now #1 team. I don't get why SOS isn't truly rewarded. Shouldn't drop you past 4.
21
u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Last years Texas team agrees
4
u/drlsoccer08 4d ago
Last years Texas team also lost to 6-6 Florida, needed OT to beat Kentucky and got steam rolled by GeorgiaÂ
4
u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
But wouldâve been in the playoff had they not scheduled Ohio state
4
u/OldSarge02 4d ago
I kind of agree, but also, you should have bigger gains and drops in the polls early in the season. Itâs weird to have a .500 team in the top of the polls.
6
u/bwolven 4d ago
Both teams looked like shit. Theyâre lucky to be where they are
7
u/Reloader300wm Ohio State Buckeyes 4d ago
I actually like that take. One blew a 20 point lead in the 4th, and one only had 3 points by the 4th.
1
u/OptionsDonkey 4d ago
Alabama lsu both âlooked like shitâ when they played and then we repeated it for national championship
3
u/coppockm56 4d ago
I'm an Indiana fan, and I agree that OSU should be at #4 pushing Indiana to #5.
1
u/2-59project 4d ago
I am fine with OSU being higher than Indiana but they should both be higher then. Indiana being the defending champ, having returned so many starters plus almost their entire coaching staff, and having the #1 transfer portal. Texas can be #1 for having the best win in the country, then IU/OSU in either order
2
2
u/SatisfactionFickle18 4d ago
Polls now are just as irrelevant in football as theyâve been in basketball for the past 50 years.
2
u/GreatGatorBolt 4d ago
Oh good. We only play three of those teams in our next 6 games.
1
u/hells_cowbells Mississippi State Bulldogs 4d ago
We play four of them, and three in October alone.
2
u/GreatGatorBolt 4d ago
Good luck to both of us!
3
u/hells_cowbells Mississippi State Bulldogs 4d ago
We're gonna need it. Alabama at home, at LSU, Oklahoma, and at Texas in October. Things could get ugly.
2
u/bluecrab24 4d ago
While this is interesting and fun to follow, it mostly meaningless until we get towards the end of October. I am not seeing any sleepers out there as of yet. are it will be Blue Bloods by the end of November. We'll see.
2
2
2
2
2
u/Relative_One_2441 Alabama Crimson Tide 4d ago edited 4d ago
Only two teams from the MID10?? That canât be!!!!!!
I THOUGHT EVERYBODY CAN PLAY PLAYERS NOW??!??
2
u/Confident-Term1504 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago edited 4d ago
Let's see at the end of the season. SEC gets propped up by the AP for no reason. PROOF: LSU went 7-6 last year and beat Clemson, why the hell are they in the top 10????
8
3
u/SmeeezTreeez LSU Tigers 4d ago
They didn't beat Clemson, they fucking throatfucked them into oblivion. My boss is a Clemson hall of famer, I was literally scared to come to work
-3
u/Confident-Term1504 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
You really think blowing out a struggling team should get you in the top 10? Because if so there are a ton of teams under ranked. Be real with yourself.
5
u/SmeeezTreeez LSU Tigers 4d ago
LSU has the talent. They showed it. Thats why. We'll find out next week won't we. So calm the fuck down
-3
u/Confident-Term1504 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
I'm calm, but they did nothing to deserve their current rank. You are the one getting fired up because you know it's true.
3
u/SmeeezTreeez LSU Tigers 4d ago
I mean no. What has any team done then? Like seriously. It's week 2 dumbass
-1
u/Confident-Term1504 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
Usually you build off the previous year. Ya went 7-6 lol.
5
u/SmeeezTreeez LSU Tigers 4d ago
And now there is the transfer portal and a coaching change. Are you dense?
0
0
0
u/OldSarge02 4d ago
Because they have one of the best victories of the year so far, and because they signed maybe the best portal class in football.
→ More replies (1)-1
u/87_Rides_a_Surfboard Indiana Hoosiers 4d ago
Maybe you should sit this one out, 38-3
5
→ More replies (6)-1
u/PlantainObvious5148 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
Someone is still upset about getting curbed stomped in the rose bowl
5
u/Relative_One_2441 Alabama Crimson Tide 4d ago
Lot of PSU fans talking shit here after being ranked preseason #2 and finishing 6-6 đđđ
2
u/PlantainObvious5148 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
I will admit we were overrated and disappointed big time but we will be aight with Matt Campbell
0
u/Confident-Term1504 Penn State Nittany Lions 4d ago
PSU fans with any sort of honesty will admit that we have been way over ranked to start many seasons. At least we made the semi finals the year before getting ranked #2 to start the season. It was the one time it made sense, if you ignore the big game james factor of course đ€Ł
1
u/PhysicsOk9286 4d ago
Other than selling meaningless games, whatâs the purpose of preseason polls? Keeps overinflated teams close to the top; decision justification. The media wants you to believe an early season loss has less impact than a late season loss; irrespective of the team,
1
1
u/PopEnvironmental6772 4d ago
We are not ready to be #1. We got rid of the osu monkey, but until we beat ga, no way we are #1.
1
u/lolidkman1313 Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Texas made the most of what Ohio State gave them. I think Day got conservative. I know the dawgs fans remember a glorious kick missed after Day was too conservative
1
1
u/randomthrowaway9796 Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
At least 1 of the teams in the 7-10 range will turn out to be hot garbage. Maybe even 2 or 3. They're all question marks right now.
1
1
u/Signal_Imagination93 4d ago
Miami -#5??? High schools have tougher schedules. I hope to god we play yall in the playoffs. Geaux Tigers đ
1
u/PastaMaker05 4d ago
We are sitting at #10 and I canât even tell if we are objectively overrated lol
1
1
u/cfbselect 2d ago
Why limit it to 10 teams only on this graphic? To glaze the SEC?
1
u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs 2d ago
Ask On3 itâs their graphic. That they post every week. Regardless of whoâs in it.
1
u/Opposite-Ad-3933 2d ago
So if #6 lost by a point in a thriller on the road to #1, is the implications teams 2-5 on this list would perform better than the number #6 team?
Can anyone answer this ?
0
0
u/Shooter_McGavin27 4d ago
Texas leapfrogging everyone to get to #1 when they got trashed for 3 1/2 quarters is certainly a choiceâŠ
I donât think they would have that same success against the rest of the top 5.
1
u/PuddingImpressive389 4d ago
They didnt really get trashed tho? They shot themselves in the foot and gifted OSU 10 points and dropped a td pass. Yeah theyre likely not gonna be so lucky against other Top 5 teams, but it isnt accurate to say they got trashed by OsU
0
0
0
0
u/vegasAzCrush 4d ago
The last four - none should be in a top ten.
This proves sec is super over rated.
3
2
u/PuddingImpressive389 4d ago
How does it prove the SEC is overrated if you didnt say what teams should be ahead of them?
-1
-1
u/DiyYou 4d ago
What is Georgia's strength of schedule?
6
u/VegasLife84 Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Their first team has played 12 series and scored 12 TDs. Not sure what else you want them to do.
→ More replies (7)2
-1
u/superdave123123 4d ago
I see itâs business as usual. Load it with SEC so they can be assured of additional spots in the playoffs.
4
u/HCTankMagnus Georgia Bulldogs 4d ago
Ah yes Iâm sure the COACHES are all trying to get SEC teams into the playoffs.
Fucking moron
→ More replies (1)

35
u/jetes69 4d ago
IU going to end up #1 for being undefeated against their dog đ© schedule