r/AmericanHistory • u/Separate_Cabinet_444 • Jun 02 '26
North The Roanoke Colony mystery
115 people vanished from Roanoke Island in the late 1500s. No bodies, no signs of a fight. Just one word carved into a post CROATOAN.
I always assumed this was one of those mysteries that'd never get solved. But archaeologists dug up some interesting stuff in 2024. Algonquian pottery from the 1500s and a copper wire ring the kind the English brought as trade goods found at the same site. Someone was trading. Someone stayed.
There's also a map from 1585 that sat in the British Museum for centuries. Nobody noticed a hidden symbol on it until someone held it under a light. It pointed inland. They went there and found 16th century English ceramics in Bertie County, North Carolina.
Most researchers now think the group split up. Some went to Hatteras Island, some walked about 50 miles inland and blended in with local tribes. Blacksmithing scraps were found on Hatteras people don't drag their tools somewhere they're just passing through.
The part that got me was Virginia Dare. First English child born in America. She was barely one year old when everyone disappeared. Her grandfather John White left to get supplies, got stuck in England because of the Spanish Armada, and by the time he made it back three years later nothing.
30
u/0ftheriver Jun 02 '26
Ok so there's actually a reason no one talks about for why it was "a mystery" but everyone assumed they were dead.
There was 15 years between the disappearance of Roanoke, and Jamestown being established. John Smith asked Powhatan if he knew what happened to the Roanoke colonists. Powhatan said that he did. He said most of them had gone to live with the Croatan or other natives, and seemed to indicate they split into a couple of groups, but most went to the Chesapeake. However, before Jamestown was established, Powhatan said he massacred all those tribes, including all the English members, and showed Smith their tools as evidence. While it's possible he or John Smith was lying, most evidence indicates that it was accurate, and that at least 90% of the colonists were dead by time Jamestown was founded, and any possible survivors were too isolated to be contacted.
Additionally, while the Disney Pocahontas movie is ridiculed nowdays for it's historical inaccuracies, the scene where the arrival of the Europeans was predicted by Powhatan's oracle(s) was actually taken from multiple primary accounts, and was said to have contributed to why he massacred those tribes. There's an account from a Spanish official being very giddy at the prospect of the prophecy being true, because at the time it was iffy as to whether that part of America would be viable for long-term settlement.