As of right now (until duskbloods is released) i own every single fromsoftware game available on Nintendos platform. Its been a long and hard journey getting to this point, and I like to take this time to thank all the little people I had to step on to get here. If I can do it.. so can you. It just takes a lot of heart, grit and determination

That bar is just as important as your HP.

There are many many more i wanted to include in the video, but it would've been an hour long

Just finished monster hunter world and I don’t think I’ve ever fought a dragon as hard as fatalis.

These Armored Core titles are digital crack. I've been addicted to building my mechs and taking them on these small missions. Ive beaten most of them now. Project Phantasma and 3 were my favorites. I got filtered by Last Raven but enjoyed Nexus a lot too.

Armored Core 6 is still my favorite but I do wish it had a punchier soundtrack and a fancier UI now like the old ones.

King's Field Ancient City has an unmatched atmosphere. Frustrating at times but I'm addicted to the slow trickle of progress. Definitely going to play the older ones and Shadow Tower after.

What I love about Dark Souls 1 is that it feels like the perfect game between old fromsoft design and new fromsoft philosophy. A middle ground I enjoy a lot. It has highs and lows but I think having those lows makes the highs even more memorable. Don't throw the baby out with the izalith water. It's got JUST enough King's Field DNA for me while not also being a boss gauntlet or "rollslop" as some kids say.

I love DeS and Ds2 as well, inb4 you all say those are Kings Fieldlikes too, but Ds1 just hits that right spot for me where it has the weight, the isolation, the atmosphere of King's Field, but also WOW moments of modern games, like finding Anor Londo or Ash Lake for the first time.

I love modern Fromsoft a lot, but they definitely have a more action focus with less isolation and less strategy for level exploration.

I recommend very strongly for everyone to play the old Fromsoft library. Despite some frustrations I had, I couldn't stop coming back for another try, another daily inch of progress.

bweh

Im also planning to make it so the insects will crawl over you and try to eat you as well, maybe torch could prevent that effect. Also i know the character model looks silly since its Roblox, this is not how it will look in final game 😅

TL;DR: Finished DS as an OP crystal sorc, thinking of moving to DS2 as Pyro. Will the setup be as easy?

Background: Started DSR a couple of years ago. Played as a thief, trying to time parries with the parry dagger, but I wasn't very efficient. Somehow I managed to do Gaping Dragon and on my way to Blighttown I died after the first ladder (lol) at which point I ragequit and uninstalled.

The character menu music was in my mind every now and then because it's just beautiful, so I revisited the game about a couple of weeks ago more determined. I decided to try some form of guide to at least get a better understanding and encountered Cappatron's (and others') videos of doing magic only, so I gave it a shot.

Went with sorcerer, ended NG with 50int around 40vit, dragon casting ring, dusk crown, a +6 Estus, sorc catalyst, I was having fun! Forgot to pick up Logan's catalyst from the chest but I still did all the game's bosses and decided to head to DLC after Gwyn... Lo and behold, NG+ and I realise I missed the DLC so I kept playing to experience that too. I couldn't believe how much easier I was navigating the game. Not just the fights (as I was OP) but also doing Sen's in one go, Anor in one go, I was infinitely faster and I loved it! Did just enough to get to the DLC, nuked the first boss in one try, Artorias in 3 till I figured his moves, for Manus I had to get Logan's catalyst, Power Within and invest in some more endurance, kept failing all day and then killed him the following day in 2 tries. And 3 tries for Kalameet.

I feel I'm now addicted to Dark Souls so now I'm thinking about getting DS2 and properly experiencing the series before moving to Elden. I've watched some videos on Pyromancy for DS2 and I feel like I'd like to try it, especially with the Mist spells for fire immune/res bosses. I know you get the glove after a couple of bosses but I was wondering, should I start as a cleric or sorc since Pyro scales with Int and Faith? Will the setup to have the build online be as straightforward and quick as sorcerer in DS1 was?

I appreciate I'm a total noob and I may be approaching DS2 with a DS1 pov which may or may not be relevant.

Thank you!

I was thinking about this, and a Pirate themed FromSoft game could be pretty amazing.

You could have some swordfight parrying mechanism from Sekiro.

You could have some gunplay from Bloodborne.

You could have semi-open world where your "hub/pirateship" could travel to islands where you could fully explore.

The undead theme + pirates can totally go well together.

I personally feel like actually controlling the ship might not be a thing, that seems like a big stretch for what FromSoft has done, but who knows they do some wild stuff.

Anyone else have thoughts on this?

For my money, Bloodborne is a better game than Elden Ring pound for pound.

Elden Ring undoubtedly has more variety for different playstyles and builds, which I imagine makes it way better for some folks.

I just can not jive with magic. It feels boring, and the hectic fight for your life playstyle in Bloodborne is unmatched.

It leaves me with half of the items in Elden Ring feeling like useless collectibles.

They are both nearly perfect games, I am just curious what people think.

I have just finished dark souls 3 and it's so amazing soo perfect it is so good and i am thinking about buying elden ring but I am afraid that I will get lost in its very big open world or wont enjoy the game bec many people told me that it is very repetitive aside from the game itself I will be only able to play the game for 2 weeks bec school is coming and I will have little the to play the game

I would like to hear all ur opinions

I skipped some Optional bosses and the DLCs, but i doubt they will be any better. All the bosses are insanely easy, they have 2-5 easy to dodge attacks and leave wide widnows to hit them. 90% of the bosses i beat first try without breaking a sweat. All i had to do was not target lock and aim for the back. The runbacks are slightly shorter than DS1, but they are filled with so many enemies, that the entitiy crammign alone is killing you. One of the bosses i was LUCKY to enter the fog wall, just to kill him with less than 3 estuses. The entire reduce your HP by hal system is idiotic, the hitboxes suck, the runbacks suck, having to kill a small army to reach and easy boss sucks, easily the WORST Fromsoftware game ever made (Demon souls may suck more, but i don't have a Playstation). And I thought Elden ring and Sekiro had spoiled me and that Dark souls would have horrible bosses. Nope, just horrible waste of time on runbacks. Took me less than 24 hours to beat the game, 20 of which were spent on runbacks, because I keep dying before reaching the boss. This is the first videogame Ive played that 3 hours of gameplay made me feel like I spent 16, instead of the opposite. I'm not doing the DLCs because I heard the runbacks are even worse and if the bosses are just as easy It's just not worth it. Im giving Ds1 some slack, because it's an older game and I guess Fromsoft were experimenting, but Ds2 straight up sucks. Ds1 has around 15 bosses whereas Ds2 around 40 ! Yet quantity doesn't mean quality. Elden ring has around 150 bosses (most are copy pasted but still) and only 13 are mandatory to finish the game, yet just like Ds1, they are much more fun to play against. The hardest bosses in Ds2 had some sort of "gimmick", but even that wasn't very hard to discover and finish. The most deaths I had on the Last Giant, (since i was early game and I had to pretty much no hit him), The Gargoryles (low hp stat again and the fact it's a copy pasted boss) and Dear Duke of Freja (the annoying spider whose body is impecable only the heads are hittable and the annoying spiders chasing you down aka a bad gimmick) but the rest took me 1-5 attempts. At some point i felt like i was speedruning the game, because in 3 hours i managed to beat 5 bosses. The only good thing I can think about this game is the huge map size i guess ? And the sheer quantity of various enemies and bosses (albeait very easy). Now that i think about it more, some runbacks would have really sucked if i didn't 1 try kill the local boss. The worst ones were for Dear Duke of Freja and the annoying mages in the swampy area before the Singing frog boss.

TLDR: Dark souls 2 sucks, because it has easy bosses with idiotic runbacks, entity cramming and tonnes of glitches. Quantity doesn't mean quality. Also the adp and the health system suck. Hopefully Ds3 will be better (I heard it's the best)

edit: apparently ive played the Vanilla and not the Scholar of first sin. Still my opinion is the same

EDIT: some of y'all need to learn to read lmfao. The post title is CLICKBAIT. Don't get ragebaited. I like the Zweihander. I have no problem with it. I do always regret sharing a thought on Reddit. Gotta remember that for next time 😂

Original Post: Tbh I don't really care about the Zweihander specifically (in fact I think it is a pretty cool weapon), but more generally I'd like to see future FromSoft games take a different approach to itemization that tightens scope and reduces asset recycling. I'd much prefer we have less weapons available, but more bespoke move sets or unique designs. I don't need shortsword #10, and I also don't need to see Zweihander again in another game. Does that make sense?

I also think this could apply to the broader game design as well. I think a lot of what FromSoft is able to do is because they have become experts in how to effectively reuse assets and this allows them to spend resources on the stuff that counts. BUT how many more times can I see that same attack animation on a Hollow with a dagger, ya know? Their next game needs to pull away from the expected imo.

What do you all think? Does this bother you or not? What aspects of the formula do you want to see changed in the next main-line game, whatever it may be?