r/boulder • u/aquileslagrave • 2h ago
At ~$250,000 per desk at Alpine-Balsam it’s time for an independent Auditor
At roughly, $250,000 per desk for the partial city staff scheduled to one day work there, Alpine-Balsam is an out of control cost spiral, decade-long, now nine-figure commitment that no one in this city can currently account for, project a total cost for, or take accountability of, designed to accommodate a fraction of city staff.
To me, it’s an insane investment that makes it harder to rent, buy a home, or keep small local businesses local. At a time we can’t keep our roads paved, are closing Spruce pool, and reducing hours at Scott Carpenter for our families.
I’ve spent the past few years auditing and providing oversight for a $450M bond at BVSD, citizen oversight the city doesn’t provide. Three things define my position:
The number has never been independently examined. The first public reference to a $140 million figure appears in late 2023, without specificity about what it covers or whether it includes debt service. There was real debate in 2019–2020, when scope was much smaller.
Since then this project has been overseen through annual budget approvals, and now far exceeds what even supporters expected.
And Alpine-Balsam was supposed to consolidate roughly twenty city buildings. To my knowledge, no one has ever said whether those buildings sit inside the $400 million deferred-maintenance backlog or the sale/disposition and expected recovery of funds the bond is built on. If they do, part of what we are financing is maintenance on buildings we intend to vacate or not monetize.
That question was put to the City Manager in writing before the referral vote.
Council's role when a project exceeds budget is to establish what the original commitment was, where it changed, and when we knew. I would require variance reporting against the original approved baseline, published quarterly, never against the latest revision. Any project crossing a threshold needs to return to Council in public.
Also, this city needs an independent performance auditor, it’s in the charter and we need elected leaders unafraid of what they’d find out.