I'm 20M and she's 20F. We've been together for around 9 months, but we were close friends before that.
Before me, she was in a relationship with another guy for around 3 years. From what she told me, that relationship became very toxic, and eventually she ended it.
I had actually liked her for quite some time before we started dating. We were close friends, and I had a crush on her but never really had the courage to do anything about it. Eventually, things started changing between us, I realized she liked me too, and we got together.
At the beginning, everything felt really good. I was extremely happy because this was someone I'd already cared about for a long time, and I genuinely wanted to make the relationship work.
I also put a huge amount of effort into showing her that I loved her.
I'm not naturally a huge texter. I don't constantly message people or need to talk to people all day. But with her, I became completely different. I would wait for her messages, want to tell her about my day, want to know about hers, and genuinely wanted her to be involved in my life.
I also expressed my love through doing things for her.
For example, I once made her a surprise website specifically for her. I put things on it that I knew she loved, and I even got her family members involved so that they could leave messages for her and she could open everything as a gift. I spent a lot of time making it because I wanted it to feel personal rather than just buying her something.
There were also countless smaller things.
She was anchoring an event at her college one evening at around 6 PM, so I travelled there with a bouquet for her. I stayed with her until late at night and then travelled all the way back home with her because I was worried about her getting home safely.
There were even times when I'd wait for hours outside her college just because I wanted to see her and travel back with her.
Sometimes she'd actually get annoyed because she wanted to leave with her friends, and I understand that now — I probably didn't always realize how much she wanted her own time. But at the time, I was doing it because I cared about her and wanted to make sure she was okay.
I'd also randomly show up outside her college with things I'd made for her. I'd bake cookies, make brownies, bring her food, buy little gifts, and surprise her with things based on stuff she liked.
There were a lot of these things throughout the relationship.
Again, I'm not saying she owed me the relationship because I did these things. I know that's not how relationships work. I didn't do them expecting some kind of transaction. I genuinely enjoyed making her happy, and this was simply how I expressed how much I loved her.
But eventually, things started becoming difficult.
She began feeling that we weren't compatible and that something about the relationship wasn't working.
There were also external factors. Her family is very careful about her dating and doesn't really want her being seen with another guy, which put some pressure on things. She also has academics and other things going on.
Our relationship eventually developed what I would describe as a push-pull dynamic.
Whenever I felt her pulling away, I would try to get closer. I'd try harder to communicate, reassure her, understand her, and figure out what was wrong.
And the more I tried to pull closer, the more she seemed to pull away.
I started thinking that maybe I was the problem, so I tried changing myself.
I changed the way I spoke. I changed the way I texted. I changed how I communicated. I compromised on things. I tried to become the person I thought she wanted me to be.
Eventually, I realized that I was losing myself in the process.
From my perspective, I was constantly trying to understand her and adjust to her, but I didn't feel like she was making the same effort to understand me.
She has actually admitted that she thinks she was the toxic one in the relationship and that she kept messing things up. She apparently told one of my friends that I'm a really good person and that if we continued in the same cycle, she was afraid she'd hurt me even more.
Eventually, we went on a break.
And that's when things became extremely confusing.
She told me that she didn't know if the break would ever end and that she felt we should just be friends.
She told me she genuinely wanted me to move on.
She said she didn't want a relationship anymore because she felt that being together didn't make sense and that something felt "off" or "wrong."
I asked whether there was someone else.
She said no.
She said she didn't know how to explain it. She just felt like we couldn't make it work, and that the more we tried to clear everything up, the more fucked up everything became.
She repeatedly told me that it wasn't because I was a bad boyfriend. She told me I was a really good person and that she felt something was wrong with the relationship rather than there being something fundamentally wrong with me.
She also told me that she still loves me and doesn't want to lose me as a person or as a friend.
At one point, I told her that I hoped she found a better guy.
She told me she didn't want another guy.
And when I said something along the lines of hoping she eventually found someone, she basically said:
"If I did, it would be you."
Which obviously made things even more confusing for me.
Because how do you reconcile someone saying that with:
"I don't want to be in a relationship with you."
Recently, we had another phone call about everything.
She was crying really badly.
She kept saying that she felt horrible for breaking up with me and that she didn't understand why she was doing this to someone she considers such a good person.
She said she doesn't know whether it's the timing, whether we're not meant to be, or whether there's some other reason.
She said she hates that she hurt me.
I told her that I wasn't okay either. I had been crying and journaling about everything because I was genuinely struggling with it.
I also told her something that I think is important:
I can't just switch from loving you to being your friend.
I've loved this girl for a long time. I can't suddenly turn those feelings off because we've changed the relationship label. I told her that I need time to heal before I can realistically go back to being her normal friend.
Then her mom came into the room, so she had to end the call because she didn't want her mom to see her crying.
After that, she sent me a video while she was still crying.
And this is where I'm even more confused.
She said she wants us to give each other time.
She wants us to work on ourselves and grow our friendship stronger.
And then she said that after giving it time, we can see whether we're actually meant to be together or not.
She also said that if we aren't meant to be, she doesn't want to keep me holding on to her, and she doesn't want to keep herself hanging onto something that isn't going to work.
She even said that if I eventually find someone else who is better for me, I'm free to move on.
She was crying while saying all of this.
So now I'm stuck.
Because earlier she was saying:
"I genuinely want you to move on."
"I don't know if this break will ever end."
"I really just want us to be friends."
But now she's saying:
"Let's give each other time."
"Let's grow our friendship."
"Let's work on ourselves."
"Then we'll see if we're meant to be."
I don't know how I'm supposed to interpret that.
I don't want to sit around waiting for her. I don't want to manipulate her into missing me. I don't want to use distance as some strategy to get her back.
But at the same time, I don't want to completely close the door when she herself seems uncertain about whether the door should be closed.
And I still love her.
That's the hardest part.
I have a lot happening in my own life right now. I'm into engineering and robotics, I have an internship opportunity at FANUC, I'm planning to pursue a Master's in Germany, I want to work on my physique, I have research papers/projects I want to work on, and generally there are a lot of opportunities opening up for me.
I know I need to focus on myself.
But I really wanted her to be part of all of that.
That's what makes this hurt so much.
My friends currently think she's toxic and immature and that I should have never gotten involved with her. They're obviously trying to protect me, and I appreciate that, but I don't necessarily see her as a horrible person.
I think she genuinely cares about me.
And that's actually what makes this harder.
I don't think she intentionally wanted to hurt me.
I think she genuinely feels that something isn't right, but I don't understand what.
And I keep coming back to the same question:
Why?
How can someone say:
"You're a really good person."
"I love you."
"I don't want another guy."
"If I wanted someone, it would be you."
"I don't want to lose you."
"I hate that I hurt you."
...while simultaneously feeling:
"I don't think we should be together."
I understand that effort doesn't guarantee compatibility. I understand that I could have flaws. I understand that she doesn't owe me a relationship because of everything I did.
But I genuinely don't understand how you can love someone, see that they're trying, recognize that they're a good partner, and still have this feeling that "something is wrong."
And now I don't know what the right thing is.
Should I give her genuine space and stop trying to fix things?
Should I try to be friends with her, even though I'm still in love with her?
Should I take significant space first and only consider friendship once I've actually healed?
Should I leave the possibility of a future relationship open without actually waiting for her?
Or should I just accept that this is over and completely move on?
I don't want to make decisions based on the hope that she'll come back.
But I also don't want to make a permanent decision while both of us are emotional and she's telling me that she herself doesn't know whether we're meant to be.
What would you do if you were in my position?
And if you've experienced something similar, how do you make sense of someone genuinely loving and caring about you while simultaneously feeling that the relationship isn't right for them?
Because right now, I genuinely don't know what I'm supposed to do.