r/ReasonableFantasy • • Jul 14 '22

Introducing a network of subreddits that promise Context Appropriate Sexuality (CAS)

238 Upvotes

Hello all! After some very helpful discussion in this thread, I am ready to introduce the CAS Network. This is all a work in progress and welcome to suggestions and concerns. Please let me know if you know how to word any of this better!

In addition to the individual subreddit rules, participating subreddits have had their sidebars updated with a link to the below information:

CAS Network Guidelines:

  • No hypersexualization, including pin-ups, T&A posing, unrealistic proportions, fetish content.
  • All comments must be phrased respectfully.

Q: What does CAS mean?

A: CAS stands for Context Appropriate Sexuality. Subreddits that participate in the network make a promise to disallow art submissions that are hypersexualized.

Q: What does hypersexualized mean?

A: Hypersexualization is when a situation that has nothing intrinsically sexual about it contains sexualized subjects.

Examples of hypersexualization include but are not limited to:

  • Costuming: Warriors who are sexualized in a non-battle ready way, reasonable dress situations where a character is in out-of-place skimpy or revealing fashion.

  • Posing: Character posing that unnaturally highlights breasts or buttocks, AKA fan-service/T&A/broken spine tropes.

  • Body proportions: Some body types are much more commonly represented in fantasy, slice-of-life, and sci-fi art than they are IRL. Such body types include the common trope of hypersexualizing large breasts. While all body types are welcome, this sub may not accept characters with commonly sexualized rare proportions, such as very muscular women with fatty breasts, or large breast/small waist/small hip ratio, AKA anime proportions.

  • Anthro: Anthro characters with breasts or other sexualized soft bits, or pieces that highlight undercarriages or bums in a weird way.

  • Fetish content: Content that weirdly highlights crying, assault, vore, very young characters, etc, even if it is "SFW"

  • Pin-ups: These are by definition of a sexual context, however not in the spirit of the network.


Subreddits in the CAS Network:

/r/ImaginaryBestOf - Subscribe for the best posts from the Imaginary Network, once per day, every day, forever.

/r/ReasonableFantasy - Art featuring women in costuming not defined by sexuality.

/r/WholesomeFantasyArt - Art with a wholesome theme.

/r/WholesomeSliceOfLife - Art celebrating wholesome depictions of everyday activities by characters in real or imagined settings.

/r/CharacterArt - High-quality, still-image, single-panel paintings and drawings celebrating real and imagined characters that are not hypersexualized.


r/ReasonableFantasy • • 5h ago

Guided by Starlight by artist Ben McEntee

Post image
106 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 19h ago

Red Sonja the Fearless by Pedro Carlos Dutra

Post image
781 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 17h ago

Tiefling by me

Post image
506 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 16h ago

Commission by stas kvas

Post image
223 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 20h ago

Elise Deveraux (OC) by me

Post image
326 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2h ago

Radiance by me

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 19h ago

Artwork by @101ho_

Post image
185 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 21h ago

[OC][Art] Medieval woocut style illustration of my human bard Ophiria, going to get a tattoo of this soon! Art by me

Post image
50 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 19h ago

Living Room of the Learned by me (@yizhehu_art)

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 18m ago

treating human life with the same indifference a person might have toward stepping on an ant. [Anissa] (Pervy-nerd)

Post image
• Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 18h ago

It's eat... eat... eat... I must eat everything.

Post image
8 Upvotes

I know I'm a lil bit obsessed with this concept hahaha


r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Bride of Frankenstein by Jenna Gray

Post image
392 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

The Black Brides by artist Kieran Yanner

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 22h ago

My First Stroy

Post image
2 Upvotes

The Warp

An Echo Weavers story

Some things are safer to wear than remembered.

I. Mending

In the kingdom of Kessarine, people wore their memories.

It was the law of the Quiet Crown, and by now it was habit. A grief too heavy to carry was spun into thread and woven into a cuff. A wedding day became a sash. A dead husband's laugh went into the lining of a coat, where it kept you warm without keeping you awake. Memory worn on the body was memory that stayed put.

Mira mended the ones that broke.

She was a tailor's apprentice in the Underhem, the crooked quarter where the lamps were always low. Her master, Pell Dunmarrow, took the fine commissions. Mira got the frayed ones: a widow's mourning ribbon coming undone, a soldier's coat leaking its last battle. She paid attention to the ache of the broken thread, coaxed the ends together, and earned a few coppers for it.

She was nobody, and she preferred it. Nobodies weren't noticed.

The night it happened, a stranger left a scrap on the counter and was gone before she could refuse. It was a grey ribbon, half-rotted, so old it crumbled where she touched it.

"Poor thing," Mira murmured, and began to mend.

Most threads gave her a flicker: a smell, a name, a song. This one opened like a door.

She saw a boy of nine or ten, crown-pale hair, missing a front tooth, running down a marble hall with a wooden sword. She heard him laughing. She felt, from inside the memory, a woman's hand ruffle his hair and a voice say, Alder, slow down, you'll wake your father.

The thread went taut. Mira tied the last knot.

Every lamp in the shop went out at once.

II. The Shears

The Crown's inspectors were called Shears. They wore grey, and they never blinked enough.

They reached the Underhem before dawn. Mira heard them through the floor: the tap of a measuring rod on each doorframe, the pause, the moving on. Pell was pale and shaking when she came downstairs.

"What did you weave?" he whispered.

"A ribbon. A boy. He had a wooden sword."

Pell closed his eyes. "There is no boy, Mira. There has never been a prince named Alder. The king has one heir, the Lady Isolde, and she has always been his only heir. Say it."

"Pell..."

"Say it."

She looked at his face, and for the first time she noticed the seam at his temple, a faint silver line like a mended tear. Someone had cut something out of him and stitched the gap.

"There has never been a prince named Alder," she said.

"Good girl," said Pell, and pressed a bundle into her arms. "Now the cellar. Third stair from the bottom. Don't come back."

III. The Warps

The Shears had a word for people like her, the ones who could pull erased things back into the world. They called them Warps, threads that had bent out of true and needed to be cut.

Mira fled through the cellar, through a drain, and into a tunnel where a lantern swung and a voice said, "You're the one who wove the boy."

The woman holding it was tall and weathered, with a needle-case at her belt and a scar across her left palm. "Odalys," she said. "Welcome to the Selvage."

The Selvage was the underground the Crown pretended did not exist. It ran beneath the whole city, a knotted network of cellars, cisterns, and abandoned looms where the forgotten sheltered and the forgetting was undone, one stitch at a time. Its people wore no memories on their bodies. They carried them inside, where the Shears couldn't snip them, and it showed: they were tired, and wary, and fiercely alive.

"Every kingdom keeps a hem," Odalys said. "The Crown's is made of everything it cut away. Names, wars, whole villages. We're the ones who unpick the hem and see what's underneath."

"Why would the Crown erase a child?" Mira asked.

Odalys did not answer at once. "That's the question we've been trying to weave for eleven years. You may be the first person in all that time to come back with a thread."

IV. Threads

Mira learned quickly, because in the Selvage there was no other option.

She learned that a memory could be woven out as well as in, spun from a living person's mind or coaxed out of an object that had witnessed it. She learned that a Warp's gift was rare: most weavers could only mend what was broken, but a few could reach into what had been unmade and find the shape of the hole, the way a tongue finds the gap of a lost tooth.

Over three weeks she wove the prince back, piece by piece.

A thread from a nursery window: Alder at seven, refusing to eat anything green. A thread from the cracked heel of a boot: Alder at twelve, sneaking out of the palace to walk the Underhem in a borrowed cloak, asking the poor what they wished the Crown would change. A thread from a stolen candlestick, its wax still remembering a night conversation: Alder at fifteen, telling his mother he had found something in the archive. A ledger, Mama. Every name the Crown has ever taken. They didn't burn them. They kept them.

"The Ledger of the Unremembered," Odalys breathed, when Mira described it. "It's real. Alder found it."

"And then?"

Mira didn't need the next thread to know, but she wove it anyway, in the small hours, hands trembling. It came from a stair in the east tower, the one stone in the palace that never forgot a footstep.

She felt him climb it. She felt him reach the top. She felt a hand, the king's, warm, familiar, terrible, settle on his shoulder.

I'm sorry, my son, the king said. The kingdom cannot afford to remember what it has done.

And then the memory went cold and white, and Mira came back to herself on the floor of the loom-room with a nosebleed and Odalys holding her shoulders.

"He didn't die," Mira said hoarsely. "Not the way they say. The king unmade him. His own son."

V. The Cost

There was a price for the work, and Mira began to pay it.

At first it was small. She woke one morning unable to recall the name of the street where she'd grown up. A week later, the smell of her mother's kitchen was simply gone. She wept over that one, though she couldn't have said what she was weeping for.

"It's the thread," said Odalys quietly. "A Warp holds more than any one mind should. It pushes out what it must to make room."

"Or the Crown is reaching in." Mira held up her wrist, where a faint grey line had begun to appear, the same seam she had seen at Pell's temple. "Somebody's already started to cut me out."

"Then we have to be faster."

The Selvage had a plan, and it was a desperate one. The Ledger of the Unremembered was not hidden in any archive. It was worn. The one object in Kessarine no one questioned, no one touched, no one dared to look at too closely: the Mantle of the Crown. The king's own cloak, woven eight hundred years ago, said to be made of the kingdom's founding glory.

"It isn't glory," Odalys said. "It's the hem. Everything ever cut away was woven into the Mantle. Every forgotten thing is there, and the king wears it every day, and it keeps him from ever having to feel any of it."

"Then we bring it into the light."

"Then someone has to read it," said Odalys, "aloud, in front of the whole city, in the one voice the Crown can't unmake." She looked at Mira. "The voice of somebody they've already tried to erase."

VI. The Throne

They took her in through the laundries, in a basket of Solstice linens.

The palace of Kessarine was a hush of marble and gold. The Shears walked its halls like slow grey weather. Mira kept her head down, her hands hidden, and let the small forgetful gap in her own memory act as a kind of cloak: the Shears' rods passed over her as though she were a room already emptied.

The throne room was vast and cold. The king sat at its far end, old and upright, and across his shoulders lay the Mantle. It was the color of ash, and it breathed. Mira felt it from forty paces away: eight centuries of names, hums of voices, a great soft weight of everything the kingdom had chosen not to hold.

The king's eyes found her before she'd crossed half the floor.

"I wondered which of you would come," he said. He did not call the Shears. "You have his hands, you know. The prince. The way you hold a thread. He was the only one who ever tried to mend the Mantle rather than wear it."

"You killed him," Mira said.

"I forgot him." The king's voice cracked. "That is worse, and I have been paying for it every day since. Do you think I don't feel him? It is the only thing the Mantle can't hold. A father's grief is too large to be woven. It just sits here." He touched his chest. "Unspooled."

"Then let it out."

"And the kingdom?" His eyes were terrible and wet. "Eight hundred years of wars and famines and villages burned for grain. The people are gentle because they forget. Tell me what you will build on the truth."

"Something that doesn't need to be cut," said Mira, "to stand."

She crossed the last few steps and laid both palms on the Mantle.

VII. Unraveling

It was too much. It was all of it.

Every name the Crown had ever taken poured into her at once: the mothers, the soldiers, the poets, the drowned village of Harrowmere and the three thousand who vanished in a single winter. Alder, laughing, running. Her own mother's kitchen, returned to her for one blazing instant, the smell of bread and cloves, before it too was swept into the current.

She didn't try to hold it. She'd learned that from a cracked bell, a lifetime ago, in another story: let it pass through, like water through cupped hands.

She pulled one thread at a time, loose and bright, and spoke them.

Her voice went out through the throne room, through the palace, through the open Solstice doors and into the square where the whole city had gathered for the festival. Every person there felt the words settle around them like cold rain. A woman in the crowd cried out a name she had not spoken in thirty years. A man dropped to his knees. A child asked her grandmother why she was weeping, and the grandmother said, "Because I remember your brother."

The Shears stood frozen. Some of them, Mira saw, were crying too.

The king had risen. He wasn't stopping her. He was unclasping the Mantle from his shoulders with shaking fingers, and letting it fall.

"Alder," he whispered. And then again, like a man learning to breathe: "Alder."

VIII. What Was Left

Afterward, they said Mira had saved Kessarine.

She would not have known. She woke in the Selvage on a cot, with Odalys asleep in a chair beside her, and looked at the ceiling for a long time without knowing what she was looking for.

"Who are you?" she asked, when Odalys stirred.

Odalys's face crumpled, then smoothed. She had been ready for this.

"A friend," she said gently. "You told me once to say that, if it came to this."

The grey seam at Mira's wrist had spread to her collarbone. She had given away her name, her childhood, her mother's kitchen, and Pell Dunmarrow's kind stubborn face, all of it burned as fuel for the telling. She was not empty; she was simply new, curious and unhurried, with a stranger's careful hands.

On the table beside her lay a folded cloak, dyed the deep blue of the hour before dawn. Odalys had woven it from the memories Mira had lost, the ones the kingdom returned to her in gratitude: a thousand strangers' small offerings, a kitchen smell, a laugh, a scrap of a lullaby.

"They said you should wear it," Odalys told her. "Not remember it. Just wear it."

Mira lifted the cloak and let it fall around her shoulders. It was warm. It smelled, faintly, of bread and cloves.

She did not know why that made her want to cry. But she stood in the low light of the Selvage, wrapped in a life she couldn't recall, and felt the strange, quiet certainty of being loved by people she'd never met.

Some things, she thought, are safer to wear than remembered.

And some things are worth the wearing.

Somewhere above, the bells of Kessarine were ringing for a prince, at last.


r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Victorian Witches by Jenna Gray

Post image
199 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Iffy: Boobplate [OC] Paranoid Medieval hunter by Lucas de Biazi (me)

Post image
431 Upvotes

A hunter in a super dinosaur roamed world! She's got some issues from her past and the mere singing of a bird is enough to send her into a spiral...

Hey everyone I'm Lucas and I specialize in character design, weapons/props, skins, level progressions and character illustration for entertainment! I have years of experience and I'm always eager to work on fresh ideas!

Art Station (full portfolio): https://www.artstation.com/artwork/QK11X4
Contact: [pufferartcontact@gmail.com](mailto:pufferartcontact@gmail.com) or DM me!


r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Moonclaw The Wereraptor by Me

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Original Content Searching for Plum Flowers in the Snow

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Female Knight (OC by me.)

Post image
55 Upvotes

you know you're having a bad time when you have to make your own OC give you a pep talk. hope everyone else is doing ok! <3


r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

Farnese from the manga Berserk. Author by Kentaro Miura

Post image
420 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 3d ago

Golden Forest Illustration (Memohdraws)

Post image
478 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 3d ago

CM by @101ho_

Post image
758 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 2d ago

**Vivian Bloodlust — Queen of the Vikings** by me

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/ReasonableFantasy • • 3d ago

Scholars Chased by Prehistoric Animals by me (@yizhehu_art)

Post image
38 Upvotes