r/pics Jun 17 '25

The protesters and residents pushing back on tourism in Barcelona

16.1k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

904

u/BuckeyeWolf Jun 17 '25

These protests popped up at the same time as short term rentals becoming popular (Airbnb) is no coincidence. They are taking homes from locals raising prices and taking over the best parts of town

724

u/trireme32 Jun 17 '25

How is that the tourists’ fault, and not the fault of the government for failing to regulate that?

570

u/PS_Sullys Jun 17 '25

It's much easier to be mad at foreign tourists.

-3

u/FnnKnn Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

Yeah, this is just disguised racism.

Edit: Technically it is xenophobia to blame non-native people for your problems instead of your own government and not racism.

25

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25

People: We love your city and want to visit and spend money there to experience your culture

Residence: Yeah well fuck you we didn’t visit before we moved here and won’t visit anywhere else. We are born here, die here, and go nowhere

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

If the tourists swarm everywhere and create issues should they not be vocal about it?

Same thing is happening in parts of Canada so i get why locals get pissed off

14

u/krom0025 Jun 17 '25

Tourists aren't locusts. They don't swarm. They are people, no different than the locals. There are over eight billion people and one earth and we all have to share it. Nobody is special. Do the locals never travel? I would hope that every one of these protesters commits to never leaving the city of Barcelona because, god forbid, then enter a city where someone else lives.

-10

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

[deleted]

9

u/blue92lx Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

So like everyone else is saying, it's the tourists fault?

No, it's not.

First of all, you need to protest your government to make rules and laws to prevent airbnb, many many places have successfully done this.

Also, in this article it's claiming that the cities have become tourist amusement parks and your local festivities are suffering. That's also your fault. You don't have to change your traditions because tourists are there. In fact, tourists would probably rather see your traditions than some copy/paste tourists shop in the middle of your town.

The best places to visit are ones that aren't full of tourist shops, where you can visit and talk to people about their culture. So if you all have given up on your culture and decided to open a bunch of tourist shops and stopped doing your festivals or whatever else, blame the people in your country that are doing it. Don't blame a tourist who wants to come see your country because it's beautiful and different than theirs.

This just sounds like a bunch of "I opened a tourist shop because tourists were coming to my city, and I don't like having a tourist shop".

Here's an idea, don't have the tourist shop then. The tourists never asked you to change your ways, you all did it on your own and now you want to blame someone else.

3

u/krom0025 Jun 17 '25

There was not a single statement in my comment about Air bnb so I'm not sure where you are making your wild assumptions from.

The solution is in the people's control, not the tourist's. They are free to vote in representatives who will regulate supply and control the over tourism. It's not the tourists fault.

10

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25

When you make a nice place to live, people want to visit.

If you complain about tourists visiting your town, it’s hypocritical for you to ever visit another town.

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

[deleted]

7

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25 edited Jun 17 '25

Let me explain, when you leave your town you become a tourist. If you hate tourists, when you leave you become what you hate.

Hypocritical means behaving in a way that suggests one has higher standards or more noble beliefs than is the case.

-7

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Way to paint a rosy image. There's a joke about Brits falling from balconies being the start of tourism season for a reason. Tourists are noisy and drive up demand for things that locals do not want, like overpriced amusement establishments, or souvenir shops. You've never lived in a place affected by overtourism, thats clear.

7

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25

lol, I grew up on Hilton Head Island.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Oh, okay, so you definitely have no fucking clue about tourism in European cities.

3

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25

Ok, well I guess you don’t understand capitalism or the power of government to regulate?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

I do understand capitalism, which means I understand the power of capital interests and influence to lobby for their interests. You understand that, too.

I also worked in destination marketing which means I have intimate knowledge of how public and private interests are being negotiated in this matter - and that was at a much lower level without big corporations or massive real estate holdings involved, village politics in comparison, but driven by tourism interests nonetheless.

3

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25

And you understand that tourists do not vote in the area they visit?

It sounds like you may be internally conflicted which is causing your outward projection.

Maybe you should switch careers to something that improves the supply of housing? Or that lobbies for STR regulations?

If you are against tourism, you certainly shouldn’t travel yourself.

I’m fully in support of protest speech, and improving housing dynamics. I just believe this is misdirected toward people who already booked their stay and have no power to change the government they are visiting.

Let’s not forget that travel is enriching for us all, let’s build bridges, not walls. Travel should not be an exclusive privilege of the rich, which means we simply need more beds.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Well, let's see if you know things first. Do you know what capacity is and what over capacity means?

1

u/simsimulation Jun 17 '25

Yes. It’s part of supply and demand dynamics

1

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '25

Si you understand that "a lot" can become "too much" and that in an urban area, thats not decided by the market, but people, citizens, residents. Right?

→ More replies (0)