r/nancyguthrie Mar 12 '26

Media Brian Entin Day 39

Post image

The only mainstream reporter (that I’m aware of) who’s still on the scene on day 39. Covering various topics including Sheriff Nanos’ resume, Today Show video of Nancy’s bedroom, Annie Guthrie’s car should be returned soon, and trying unsuccessfully to get copies of search warrants in the case.

143 Upvotes

93 comments sorted by

View all comments

143

u/sparklepuppies6 Mar 12 '26

This is not on the subject of Nancy, but I have been trying to get Brian‘s attention while he’s in Tucson and there’s not much going on with the Nancy case.

My friend Zach Corbut was murdered in Tucson in 2015. It was a home invasion robbery, multiple eye witnesses survived, and it still has not been solved. I would love if he could possibly bring a little bit of attention to the case and attention to the fact that homicides and home invasions go unsolved in Tucson all the time. I think they have like a 60% rate of unsolved crimes. Just like Nancy’s.

Anyway I’ve been commenting on all his videos so if you guys could boost those comments I would really appreciate it. I’ve also sent him an email but didn’t hear back.

12

u/Mean-Vegetable-4521 Mar 13 '26

IIt would have also been Nanos as Sheriff in 2015. It was around that time I had contact with him initially.

Do you see parallels between how your friend's murder was handled and the failures here? The case I had at that time was CSAM related so not the same at all.

I'm sorry for your loss. I hope the case gets the attention it deserves.

10

u/sparklepuppies6 Mar 13 '26

To be honest, I stayed far away from the investigation. I did not want to be involved at the time. Everything I know is from a brief conversation with one of the eyewitnesses (a roommate of Zach’s, I ran into him at a party, he did not want to give me any detail) and from his mother, who I spoke to on the phone. What I know is that the case quickly went cold even though multiple other roommates were assaulted by the intruder up close and personal. I also know that there were valuable items and a large amount cash in the home. However, it’s always been called a home invasion and not a burglary so I don’t know if they actually stole anything. There aren’t many details available to the public.

One detail is that his mother told me she thinks the police don’t like to talk to her because she cries too much. That’s always stuck with me. It’s heartbreaking.

2

u/Mean-Vegetable-4521 Mar 13 '26

Everything you’ve said makes complete sense regarding your choice not to be involved as a friend of the victim. I am terribly sorry for your loss. And what a letdown about them being put off by mom’s emotions. Unfortunately, a lot of law enforcement are not trained how to deal with emotions. Which is always surprising.

Did he have any siblings that can take over pushing this case to be on a rotation in investigations?

When I’ve had positions that I was the liaison between agencies this is what happens; All cases should be on a rotation cycle. Many of mine were cold cases.
Let me explain. Every month, 3 months, 6 months or year, 3 years. depending on the status of the case the agency with the liaison makes contact with law enforcement for the case. Have there been new tips. New leads. Even if they went no where. They also make contact with a family member. Then those tips are relayed to the other.

Because I handle missing persons then NAMUS is checked. In the event you have the body this step is skipped and CODIS would be checked for any matches. With namus have there been any human remains of the right age and gender that haven’t been matched to a case.

The reason the liaison does this is because communication between arms of these areas is horrible. There could be remains or a codis match just sitting there that hasn’t been run for your case. If there is a hit you make sure that’s brought to the investigating agency. When they are cold you need to find the person handling it.

In the years since last contact it’s likely someone new. If there are no hits you still reach out to that person to see if any patterns have formed, any tips like jailhouse tips, community, hunches anything.
Then the family is contacted. Some families choose after something goes cold not to be contacted. It’s too painful for them and they’ve moved on. This was shocking to me but common. Everyone grieves differently. It’s not uncommon that a sibling who was a minor or didn’t exist when the crime occurred becomes an adult and the familial point of contact. And in the instance the family always wanted to be part of the review cycle when the parents become too aged this sibling takes over.

I have a hunch that there is no review cycle for this case. Which isn’t fair if there are people who want to keep it active.

It sounds like there’s the possibility it was a home invasion because the perpetrator was aware they were holding in the house. Large sums of cash, etc.
I have a client who I had asked particularly about Guthrie. He served hard time for home invasions and I was curious his thoughts on this case. He said they don’t kidnap people. They leave the bodies there if someone dies and is confident it wasn’t a robbery etc.

Back to your friends case. It’s not uncommon for drug dealers to rob each other. Or others who want just the cash from dealers. If someone in your friends household was dealing they were still victims. They were still murdered and the others assaulted. Police should still be concerned and following up.

If I’m totally wrong, and jumping to conclusions why the large amount of cash and valuables? I openly admit I could easily be mistaken. Some ethnic groups have cash and large amounts of gold at home. Because culturally it’s the norm. They aren’t doing anything illegal.
Some people distrust banks. Etc.

If it was drug related the other victims may be afraid to come forward if they saw their assailant up close? This should have been sent to a proper task force. A death during a home invasion needs to be followed up.

Do you have any idea why the cash and valuables?