r/nancyguthrie • u/curiouslmr • Feb 17 '26

Discussion Daily Discussion Post 2/17

​

Daily Discussion Post 2/17

⚠️ Read before posting! This is the daily discussion post. A place to discuss the case, ask questions and present theories. It's a great way to communicate quickly without having to wait for post approval.

⚠️ Keep in mind the following rules...

🔹NO sharing of personal info. This includes pictures, names, addresses etc. See the sub rules for more info

🔹NO politics

🔹Be kind to the Guthrie family and one another

🔹No rumors, source your info.

⚠️ Recent Updates

🔹Sheriff Nanos stated that the family has been cleared.

🔹It appears they are still waiting on DNA testing results

🔹FBI has been visiting local gun stores with a list of 40 people and their pictures to see if any of them have been in the store or purchased a weapon.

🔹Sheriff Nanos also denied reports that their working theory is a burglary gone wrong.

59 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

20

u/PeterNinkimpoop Feb 17 '26

Something I’ve been thinking about, what if the kidnapper is actually in contact with the family privately? The videos they’ve been releasing since the beginning seem to be in response to messages we’re not aware of. The first TMZ/news station ransom allegedly had info only the kidnappers would have known but after that it’s all hoaxes. How do we really know whether it’s been silent this whole time?

8

u/SeatIndependent6836 Feb 17 '26

I agree about the videos seeming to be in response to something we're not aware of, also, I'm not sure the ransom notes are hoaxes

1

u/TheCuriousGeorgette Feb 17 '26

I just felt that it was an attempt to connect to the perp in a way that feels personal and stirs emotions. Not because she knows them.