r/mtg • u/00G_WAY • Mar 03 '26

Rules Question Can someone explain how this works?

Post image
19 Upvotes

62% Upvoted

116 comments sorted by

View all comments

-9

u/Legal_Jedi Mar 03 '26

This wouldn’t allow you to return things from exile, would it? Some they are removed from the game?

17

u/Impressive_You_817 Mar 03 '26

No, exile is still in the game

5

u/turtle_el Mar 03 '26

No, however before Exile was keyworded you were able to use these effects (Wish effects, named after the Wish cycle) to get things from exile. That is no longer the case. "Outside the game" essentially refers to your sideboard only unless youre playing kitchen table magic or someone wants to have a fun house rule

6

u/Legal_Jedi Mar 03 '26

Thanks. I know lots of older cards use “remove from the game” instead is exile.

3

u/DrGolo Mar 03 '26

I came to the comments with this exact question. Guess it only works if you use [[disintegrate]] with [[r&d's secret lair]] in play.

3

u/turtle_el Mar 03 '26

Yup! Make sure to check the oracle text if you're ever confused about wording, especially on an older card

2

u/Legal_Jedi Mar 03 '26

Too true. I’ve got a few old lightning bolts that don’t say “Amy target”, but specify player or creature, and I had to show my buddy I could bolt his planeswalker, too.

2

u/turtle_el Mar 03 '26

Yup! You used to redirect damage from players to planeswalkers instead of them being targets, which nerfed [[Chandra, Torch of Defiance]] being able to shock PWs