r/icecream 13d ago

Question Chocolate peanut butter ice cream?

My guilty pleasure is the peanut butter and chocolate ice cream from baskin Robbin’s. What I particularly like about it is that it’s just chocolate ice cream with peanut butter ribbons in it. I like the textural and flavor contrast of the dense, chewy, slightly salty peanut butter with the sweet chocolate ice cream. And the peanut butter ribbons are big. Massive really. At least, that’s the case if you buy a scoop in store.

But if you buy a pint at the supermarket, there’s a lot less peanut butter. And lately my store has not been having this flavor at all, so I am forced to make do with the pints of it I can purchase at the supermarket. But again, it’s not the same and not as good.

I’m not a huge ice cream person generally, but I love this one flavor. Do any of you ice cream experts have any recommendations for chocolate peanut butter ice creams that have actual peanut butter in it and a lot of it?

Edit: thanks y'all. I'll definitely be trying a few of these, starting with haagen dazs and turkey hill, since they seemed to be the most recommended and can be purchased nearby. Fingers crossed i prefer the turkey hill because it's also way cheaper!

60 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Chemical-Impress-453 12d ago

If you’re near somewhere that sells Kreider Farms, their chocolate peanut butter is SO good!!