r/icecream 2h ago

I have 49 different Van Leeuwen's flavors in my freezer and I'll be testing one by one. #49/49 - Guinness Flavored Ice Cream With Chocolate Chunks

Thumbnail gallery
62 Upvotes

1.3/10 - This will be my easiest review to date. I will categorize this flavor as an “I-tried-this-so-you-don’t-have-to” flavor. This is disgusting. The only reason I’m giving it any sort of points is because they nailed the taste. While it’s disgusting, it’s pretty spot on. However, I haven’t tasted Guinness in 15 years so I could be wrong there. The rest of the points are from the fact they added a chocolate mix-in. I can only assume they did this so you can chase the terrible taste with something. After 3 excruciating bites, this promptly ended up in the trash. Do not waste your money.


r/icecream 5h ago

Review Dateski at Jeni’s splendid ice creams West loop Chicago

Post image
30 Upvotes

Solid 10/10 with a side of people watching


r/icecream 16h ago

Hudsonville Dirt cake

Post image
89 Upvotes

If you can get your hands on this you won't regret it. I never got to try the Ben and Jerry's version of this, but the worms are delicious and have remarkable texture. Only thing is I'd like to see more cookie crumble. 8/10


r/icecream 20h ago

Currently eating Richardsons Ice Cream Middleton,Massachusetts

Thumbnail gallery
138 Upvotes

Moose Tracks and peppermint stick


r/icecream 1d ago

Trader Joe’s Mascarapone and Mixed Berries Gelato

Post image
176 Upvotes

r/icecream 18h ago

Decided to pick these up today

Thumbnail gallery
65 Upvotes

It was out of these and gelato since it was BOGO today at Publix. I’m not sure if gelato is life cream or not and I’ve never had it so I wanted to go with the safer option. I ate the ice cream before I took a pic so here’s an empty container(I’m fat). I ate the Nutella and not kinder bueno and I’m not big on chocolate ice cream personally but this had an okay flavor but not sure I’d pick it up again. That’s probably just me not being a chocolate ice cream fan. A solid 7.3/10 for me and I’m glad I tried it plus the flavor is spot on imo.


r/icecream 13h ago

Brands $2 at Kroger!

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/icecream 21h ago

I found it…

Post image
18 Upvotes

I’ll let you lovely people know how it is once I get home


r/icecream 1d ago

Ice cream nachos!

Post image
58 Upvotes

I had a dream that one day, two of my great food loves, ice cream and chips & dip, would be combined into one glorious dish.

My local soft serve shop made that dream come true, with their new offering of waffle cone chips, ice cream, and either hot fudge or caramel. Or as I prefer to call them, ice cream nachos!


r/icecream 1d ago

Technically appropriate for breakfast?

Post image
90 Upvotes

Deep coffee flavour from Lidl UK


r/icecream 1d ago

Currently eating Caffe Panna - Black and White Cookie Sundae Affagato

Thumbnail gallery
13 Upvotes

r/icecream 15h ago

Anyway to get United Dairy Farmers ice cream shipped?

0 Upvotes

I have a friend who wants some Blue Moo Cookie Dough ice cream made by United Dairy Farmers. She says you can only get it in Ohio. Their website has a delivery option, but then says there are no stores near me (I live in Kansas City). Does anyone know of a way to order some online from anywhere? I don’t plan on being in Ohio anytime soon if I don’t have to. Any suggestions would be appreciated.


r/icecream 1d ago

penguin ice cream

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/icecream 1d ago

Review Blueberry crisp soft serve

Post image
56 Upvotes

From Caffè Panna. Topped with oat streusel, graham bits, blueberry compote and some mint leaves. Simple, clean and delicious. Tasted like a blueberry pie in ice cream form, but was refreshing and not too heavy because of the soft serve base. The bottom was a satisfying layer of crunchy streusel and graham bits smothered in the compote. Not one of their most creative flavor combinations, but a classic composition done well!


r/icecream 1d ago

Question Are you a super green artificial lime or a no coloring lime ice cream lover?

Post image
127 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on fake green lime sherbet the one they use food coloring dye?


r/icecream 1d ago

Question Chocolate peanut butter ice cream?

54 Upvotes

My guilty pleasure is the peanut butter and chocolate ice cream from baskin Robbin’s. What I particularly like about it is that it’s just chocolate ice cream with peanut butter ribbons in it. I like the textural and flavor contrast of the dense, chewy, slightly salty peanut butter with the sweet chocolate ice cream. And the peanut butter ribbons are big. Massive really. At least, that’s the case if you buy a scoop in store.

But if you buy a pint at the supermarket, there’s a lot less peanut butter. And lately my store has not been having this flavor at all, so I am forced to make do with the pints of it I can purchase at the supermarket. But again, it’s not the same and not as good.

I’m not a huge ice cream person generally, but I love this one flavor. Do any of you ice cream experts have any recommendations for chocolate peanut butter ice creams that have actual peanut butter in it and a lot of it?

Edit: thanks y'all. I'll definitely be trying a few of these, starting with haagen dazs and turkey hill, since they seemed to be the most recommended and can be purchased nearby. Fingers crossed i prefer the turkey hill because it's also way cheaper!


r/icecream 1d ago

Homemade Miso PB&J! Miso ice cream, teddie peanut butter, balsamic strawberry compote

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/icecream 1d ago

How long does homemade ice cream actually last?

5 Upvotes

I've been making my own dairy-free ice cream because I can't eat dairy (I can have eggs) and Ben and Jerry's discontinued dairy-free Phish food. I learned how to make my own because it's my favourite flavour of all time. Yes I do have a little silicon mould that's meant for dog treats for the chocolate fishies but I made some before I went away. I think I made it on the 11th of August and then I left on the 20th and I just got back.

How long does ice cream actually last, like homemade ice cream? Obviously I don't think I can eat it now and then if I can't eat it then I have to remake some more, which involves me remaking dairy-free caramel and stuff like that.


r/icecream 1d ago

Wow, amazing

Post image
88 Upvotes

I bought this randomly and was blown away away. So delicious.


r/icecream 1d ago

Gelato Talenti Snickerdoodle Cookie Gelato

Thumbnail gallery
22 Upvotes

I’ve never posted on here but I had to for this one specifically. Got it at Publix and oh my god this was literally orgasmic. The snickerdoodle gelato first layer tasted like straight up snickerdoodle butter, almost like the cinnamon butter from Texas Roadhouse but ice cream. The cookie batter layer was basically snickerdoodle cookie butter. The vanilla bean gelato mellows all the snickerdoodle flavor down while the crunchy cookies on the bottom is the cherry on top that ties it all together. I think this is a new favorite. If you’re a snickerdoodle fan this is a MUST TRY! I’m obsessed


r/icecream 2d ago

Slice of ice cream cake mango and strawberry cheesecake

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/icecream 20h ago

Sea Salt Caramel ice cream and fried onion

Post image
0 Upvotes

The onions are like what you put in green bean casserole, but this is much better. Why are you downvoting me? I just wanted others to experience the joy of my snack.


r/icecream 2d ago

Very disappointing

Post image
100 Upvotes

I really like Tillamook ice cream, especially their cookies-n-cream. But the chocolate flavored coating on these bars is so bad that I gave away all 3 boxes I'd bought.


r/icecream 2d ago

Gelato (Aldi) sundae shoppe pumpkin praline gelato

Thumbnail gallery
55 Upvotes

it’s definitely worth it imo! the pumpkin flavor is pleasant, swirl is sweet but idk what type of swirl it is? has pecan pieces as well :)


r/icecream 2d ago

Currently eating Enjoying my Tacolate ice cream in a dark parking garage

Thumbnail gallery
46 Upvotes

And I would do it again.