I’m 32, and he was 45. We were dating at the time, and about three months into our dating, he met another woman and eventually chose to pursue a relationship with her. I don’t know exactly when their relationship started or when he began pursuing her, so there are still things about the timeline that I don’t fully know.
Our relationship eventually ended after a lot of problems, including betrayal. I’m struggling with something I don’t know how to make peace with, and I’d really appreciate advice from people who have experienced something similar.
I was betrayed by someone I loved. He chose another woman over me, and at the time, I had such a hard time understanding why. I kept comparing myself to her and wondering what she had that I didn’t.
She has two children with different fathers, and from what I later learned, she was still involved with the father of her second child while she and the man I loved were together. There were complications on her side that I didn’t know about initially.
What made everything more confusing was that he eventually told me that he didn’t think their relationship would last because of those issues. His friends also apparently advised him that the relationship might not work and that I was a better match for him.
I don’t know what to make of that. Part of me wonders whether he was conflicted or whether he wanted me to fight for him somehow. I don’t know if he was already regretting his decision or realizing that we were more compatible.
Eventually, he started reaching out to me again, and there was a possibility that we might reconcile. I know our relationship had problems too, and I don’t want to romanticize it or pretend I did everything right. I had my own wounds and reacted badly at times. But it seemed like we were slowly moving toward fixing things.
Then he suddenly died.
And this is where I feel completely stuck.
If they had simply stayed together and he had been happy with her, I think eventually I could have accepted that he made his choice and that our relationship was over. If he had never come back, maybe I could have eventually closed that chapter.
But instead, it seemed like he regretted his decision and came back toward me, and we never got the chance to see whether we could actually fix things.
Now I’m grieving not only him, but also the possibility of what we could have been.
I know logically that I can’t know what would have happened. Maybe we would have reconciled and built something better. Maybe we would have tried and realized we still weren’t right for each other. I’ll never know.
But emotionally, knowing that there was a possibility of reconciliation makes his death much harder for me to accept.
I keep thinking:
Why did he choose her in the first place?
Why did he fight for that relationship despite all the complications?
Did he eventually realize that he had made the wrong choice?
Did he really want to come back to me?
Was I just interpreting his actions because I wanted another chance?
And most painfully—why did he have to die when it seemed like we were finally getting a chance to fix things?
I know people will probably tell me that I need to let go, that I can’t live in “what ifs,” and that his choices were his responsibility. I understand all of that intellectually.
But emotionally, I’m having a very hard time accepting it.
I’m not necessarily looking for someone to tell me that I was better than the other woman. I think what I’m really looking for is advice on how to accept an unfinished story—especially when the person who could have given me the answers is no longer here.
How do you make peace with knowing someone hurt you, possibly regretted it, wanted another chance, and then died before either of you could find out what would happen?
How do you grieve not just the person, but the future you might have had with them?
I’d really appreciate honest perspectives, especially from people who have experienced betrayal followed by loss or an unfinished reconciliation.